Mini 992 - Mafia in Handsometown - Game Over

[TheLonging]

Pie's great at being scum. I can attest to that. He fakeclaimed cop and had us all believed until Day... 5 or something? (Of course I was opposing scum so I didn't care )

Good game Pie

[InflatablePie]

Thanks for all the congrats. I replaced in to two townie quicklynches, I was all PLEASE FOR ONCE I WANNA BE SCUM PLEASE and then got my role PM

I know I wouldn't have been able to convince gonnano Artem was scum, so I would have went for gonnano again. Unfortunately, I kind of directed the kill to AGar and avoided his lynch this last day, so I would have lost.

Huge gamble to enforce a LAL, but I had no other choice.

@Artem: I do get the point of docs claiming PGO or BPs claiming doc, but I was scum this game, so....

(BTW, TL's game he's talking about was a large, 17 or so players IIRC offsite, in a game of mostly newbs, so I don't count that. It's on my wiki page I think if anyone cares to read through a long long game)

[TheLonging]

It was actually like 20 or more.

[InflatablePie]

Same thing

[AGar]

Will post thoughts soon, but we were lucky to grab this. In retrospect, insta-bussing Swiss was a mistake on our planning.

Also, Quoi getting chosen to claim before me really messed up my plans. -_-

[AGar]

Ok, thoughts time!

Day 1, that quicklynch made things golden for us. None of the three of us had to say or do much. I honestly opposed the ZF wagon, only because I didn't feel like he was threatening to us and I was more worried about JVW/Seacore being a menace to us.

I dictated that we should kill JVW night 1 because I was honestly afraid of what he might do if he had time to post.

Day 2, again, perfect. Mallow basically sealed his own fate during Day 1's twilight, and I had positively managed to somehow get on Seacore's good side.

Night 2, Seacore was pretty obvious. No sense in letting him try and kill us.

Day 3, that's where in my opinion, we fell apart. I should have realized during our night 2 discussion that we would likely be 3:3 going into the day and put out that we should try and effortlessly push for a no-lynch. Instead, I agreed to the idea of IP pushing hard at Swiss, and I tried to stay on my course of attacking gonnano. Unfortunately, Artem was smarter, and presented the claim idea. Once that got rolling, I had fabricated a false-claim, only to have Quoi spoil it. I was hoping to be picked early on so I could gambit the claim. If countered, I would suggest no-lynching and then cross shooting, knowing I was NK-immune. However, I felt countering Quoi would be too risky because he did seem way too believable. Then for the next round of claims, I tried to fabricate something believable, but couldn't think of anything. Gonnano's doc claim felt off from the moment it came out, so I decided to try and attack it. When I realized it was futile, I decided to move towards Swiss. Even in presenting myself as scummy, I knew I would at least solicit Quoi's NK, and we should be able to kill gonnano. That would bring us to 2:2 and then we would be able to force a NL, even if we outed ourselves in the process. From there we would shoot Quoi, and even if he shot at IP, I would still go into D5 with Artem and win based on the fact that he didn't have a kill.

Night 3, we went through with the gonnano kill (although I had said I would submit a PM, then forgot to. I was freaking out my entire way home from work that morning thinking "Oh shit, we didn't get a kill off.") I checked the QT, IP said he sent a PM so I breathed a sigh of relief... only to find no one dead the next morning. Day 4 I figured I was dead meat, and was hoping gonnano and Artem would aggressively put me at L-1, where I would self hammer to cut off discussion. When I wasn't at L-1, I decided to give gonnano a shot. I fully expected it to fail, but somehow it worked.

We were lucky to pull this win out, all things considered. Again, we shouldn't have gone after Swiss so intentionally, I think. Even if we outed all three of us and forced a no-lynch and Quoi shot IP or Swiss, it was still 2 v 2 next day (assuming we didn't give the chance for the doc claim by gonnano).

Gonnano, the false-claim was brilliant. The back-tracking, not so much. I would've stated that the limitation was actually a one-time self-protect or something. A bit of a tougher sell, but it would've nullified the Lynch-All-Liars case against you, and probably would've sealed a town win.

Quoi - who would you have shot if I was lynched and flipped scum in the N4? (Gonnano/Pie/Artem).

[Swiss]

I did try and hint to you guys that we pretty much had it locked down - but I didn't want to literally say it.

"I just need 2 more people to not lynch"

GARRGHGHHH

Still, GG. We won and that's wat matters ^^

[InflatablePie]

Yeah, I raged a little bit when there were 5 people alive at the start of day. ._.

My bad.

[AGar]

BTW, I'm fine with posting QT if you two are.

[Swiss]

Ofc

[InflatablePie]

Since you two said yes....

[FakeGod]

whoa this game was like a hurricane

I must say, it was a very amusing 15 minutes I just spent.

[CallMeLiam]

Glad we could help. Reading Day 3 as it happened was great.

[MeMe]

last post