Um... generally the mass flavour idea should be used to find scumz. You do flavour analysis and determine what fits or doesn't. Kind of like in Disgaea 1/2 that Dram ran. Flavour analysis did assist there, somewhat. Kinda. Maybe CEBM is better. When you take us out of RVS stage you generally have a direction to go for. I assume that means you now have a scum suspect found in Boberz.
Otherwise taking us out of RVS just to take us out does nothing since we have no starting point. Your reasoning to why a mass flavour claim is scummy. Your attack on bob is meh at best since The Fonz did the leg work in that attack.
@Darla
Um.. we are just confusing? Specifics plz. You're not being very detailed in
HOW I'M CONFUSING
. But you're simply stating an opinion. I can't clarify an opinion of observation. It's like me saying you are blue. I think you are blue. I'm missing the subtext to how this relates to your reasoning. (i.e. I think you are blue, thus you must be an ALIEN FROM A BLUE PLANET).@Ribwitch
Or a town meta. You do realize the other side of that coin. Besides, there's juicy information to the Hydra dynamic. Maintain your pressure right now and see what happens. Just FYI:
You're very vocal about this stance which is good. This means you're sticking to your guns. Players like Demonhybrid kind of drop off the wagon for no good reason. Nor does she explain why she joined the wagon. If you consider it, I'm making people draw stances on why they want my heads to claim. People need
to explain why
they take that stance. I don't care if people want me to claim. Nor if they find it neutral. I want them to explain why.So out of all the people doing something, DH is the worst coming out of it. Darla doesn't find me scummy, but her vote off the wagon is odd. A day 1 page 2 wagon isn't dangerous. Optimal play says that town will prevent a quick hammer. Even if a quick hammer does go through, with a fairly experienced player list, you'd find scum driving that wagon.
You can apply optimal play theory here. Newbieness won't be an issue.
@Benmage
1. Silly you, the day kill is called
a gambit
to draw reactions from diddin
obviously since it was fake. I've drawn proof that it's likely that Tragedy and Diddin are linked players. Thus if it's later revealed that either players are scum, the other is scum. Did you not read my attack on Tragedy? I established a link through a day kill gambit. I find that gambiting is helpful.2. Anti-town is quite different from scummy. Hell, I approve lying as a valid strategy? Hey guess what, do you know this player name Fate? Yeah do you know this game http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... =3&t=14737
Oh right he lied. He was a Bullet Proof Role but he claimed Beloved Princess. I digress from the main idea, but I don't mind analyzing the wagon that's on me.
3. If you dislike the fluff, go past the surface and look at my analysis.
Iso 2 disagrees with the Flavour claim.
Iso 5 explained the hydra arguments for everyone who didn't read Supernatural Mafia (I skimmed it)
Iso 6 shows me linking 2 players via my above gambit.
Iso 7 is questioning Darla to explain her confusion. Confusion means neutral reads. I dislike neutral reads since those are very dangerous to carry around. I want people to form opinions.
Playful is also a posting style, nor does it offer any analysis to your position on me. So your whole second point is fluffy in itself. Draw more alignment arguments.
4. I find your critism of Llamma's vote to be odd considering HE AGREES WITH YOU. So you disagree with the man who agrees with you? In fact he's doing more with his questioning on bob then 80% of the wagon then most of the people who are voting for the sake of agreement. So yeah.. contradiction of position and attacks much?
5. "shrugs" I'm seeing how badly you care (applies to Ribwitch). If you don't care enough to do some background reading, then I can't place you guys in the obv town category. I read over Supernatural Mafia when Llamma gave it. I gave you like 5 games that I was involved in. I'm in all of them. Just look at the player lists and cross check.
If you don't care enough to reread, then you're hurting my read on you. Tip the scale and let me see if you care enough to stick to your guns. That's the main point. SHOW ME THAT YOU CARE ENOUGH TO DO SOME 5 MINUTE SKIMMING.
You can guess for all I care.
The point is not for you players to get the name right, but for me to gauge who is willing to go out and find the information. Someone could spout out a randomly from all the games. But the act of people going to the threads was the important thing. Town would care enough to do that. Scum goez what ever. Lazy people remain neutral to read
. The end. My gambit revealed. I will pout nao.@Hirakai
Early game vote hopping is a town tell lulz. Someone forgot how effective Battle Mage was. Vote hopping and multiple wagons = lots of information. Having 2 good wagons is basic mafia theory to determine reads. You can compare people relative to how they respond to other people forming links. So lululululululz
