Mini 1222 - Blaz Blue: Calamity Trigger Mafia (Game Over!)

[Pomegranate]

I'm voting her for a semi theory reason. why would you delay the game? Is it not more helpful to the town to have random vote then be obstructionist? So to answer you question, it isn't as much scummy as it is anti-town. Early game, I believe they are 1 in the same for voting purposes.

I do not think meta dictates someones play.

Her meta is to

always

do this in her games

. That does not exclude her from being scum. My vote stays simply because voting for someone else would not really mater. And for the whole not voting for a real player theory reason. Which is just as good as any bullshit rvs reason if you ask me.

This post makes no sense. UK is delaying the game/being anti-town? And just because she always does it, it's scummy?
VOTE: Subcom.

[Nobody Special]

Possibly NS. I'm trying to figure out if it's dumb or scum. Him posting more will facilitate this.

I have a lot of neutral reads right now though, so.

Honey, you know I'm as dumb as a box of hair.

Also, subcom looks to me more newbish than scum. But, whatever.

[scooby]

That's precisely what I hate about thim. I think he is faking the noob card.

[scooby]

Since I am unfamiliar with this tar person ( ) I did a quick search of his non marathon games...

Would a noob unfamiliar with tar, call him "tar"?

[Nobody Special]

I think it's a natural shortening. Not a tell.

[Friend]

I'm voting her for a semi theory reason. why would you delay the game? Is it not more helpful to the town to have random vote then be obstructionist? So to answer you question, it isn't as much scummy as it is anti-town. Early game, I believe they are 1 in the same for voting purposes.

But you yourself noticed that in Tar games, voting the mod sometimes does something. So why wouldn't UK's mod-vote be protown and non-obstructionist? Isn't she just testing the mechanics?

I do not think meta dictates someones play.

Her meta is to

always

do this in her games

. That does not exclude her from being scum. My vote stays simply because voting for someone else would not really mater. And for the whole not voting for a real player theory reason. Which is just as good as any bullshit rvs reason if you ask me.

I never said it excluded her from being scum. I just said it wasn't scummy that UK voted the mod because she's done as town many times.

Vote: gandalf5166

Because I just realised he's in this game.

FoS: Zodiark

Is this a policy vote or do you think what he's done in his first couple posts has been scummy?

Random vote was random. More to the point I should think is why was it deserving of a FoS? Or am I just the scapegoat to see if FoSing will do anything?

Because you seem to be ignoring all the business with subcom and you're still making random votes. If it was a real vote I wouldn't have been so suspicious, but you still seem to be fucking around when there's scumhunting to be done.

That's precisely what I hate about thim. I think he is faking the noob card.

What leads you to believe this (besides the Tar thing)?

[Nobody Special]

You know, subcom is putting an awful lot of energy into this.

subcom: Do you like pickles?

[Zodiark13]

Vote: gandalf5166

Because I just realised he's in this game.

FoS: Zodiark

Is this a policy vote or do you think what he's done in his first couple posts has been scummy?

Random vote was random. More to the point I should think is why was it deserving of a FoS? Or am I just the scapegoat to see if FoSing will do anything?

Because you seem to be ignoring all the business with subcom and you're still making random votes. If it was a real vote I wouldn't have been so suspicious, but you still seem to be fucking around when there's scumhunting to be done.

You do realize its been 23ish hours since the game began? Random voting, regardless of weather or not scumhunting has begun, is something I believe should always be in ones first post. I don't think it fair to be deprived of my right to random vote, just because I'm a few hours late. Plus, I read the "business with subcom" as usual "whipping up insignificant stuff as scumtells" that some of these newer players like to indulge in.

[gandalf5166]

Gandalf, what about NS's post was "scumposting," in your eyes?

The fact that he just came up with the stupidest reason to park his vote on a town power role ever.

And weighing in on the RVS thing, I think scum can be found in RVS and that it is an important phase of the game. I also believe that people trying to avoid it or drag the game out of it for no reason are more likely scum. But if we already have two caught scum there's not really any point.

You know, subcom is putting an awful lot of energy into this.

subcom: Do you like pickles?

Oh, and now he's trying to perpetuate RVS despite the fact that there are serious questions to be asked. And BTW, I don't find Zodiark scummy for the same reason because lots of people who miss the RVS come in late and continue it, I don't think that's a scumtell.

[Nobody Special]

Gandalf, what about NS's post was "scumposting," in your eyes?

The fact that he just came up with the stupidest reason to park his vote on a town power role ever.

You assume a lot. That's not good.

unvote: UK

Vote: Gandalf

[GreyICE]

Oh wow, he caught himself on page 3. This time I'm not there either

Hi 'dalfin

Vote: Ganondalf

[scooby]

That's precisely what I hate about thim. I think he is faking the noob card.

What leads you to believe this (besides the Tar thing)?

No newbie game, deep knowledge of "meta", "scummy vs antitown" and "rvs".

So you speculate that there is some sort of mechanic related to voting for the mod? Okay.

This feels forced.

[gandalf5166]

Oh wow, he caught himself on page 3. This time I'm not there either

Hi 'dalfin

Vote: Ganondalf

Oh, third buddy. GAME OVER

[UncertainKitten]

GI: You're votin' wrong, subcom is the scum

Katsuki: I'd vote subcom right now but I want to confirm Tar's player status first.

VOTECOUNT PLEASE, TAR

@gandalf: Doin' it rong, GI isn't scum, just silly.

[gandalf5166]

GI: You're votin' wrong, subcom is the scum

Katsuki: I'd vote subcom right now but I want to confirm Tar's player status first.

VOTECOUNT PLEASE, TAR

@gandalf: Doin' it rong, GI isn't scum, just silly.

I know, I just like being snarky to GI.

[Friend]

You do realize its been 23ish hours since the game began? Random voting, regardless of weather or not scumhunting has begun, is something I believe should always be in ones first post. I don't think it fair to be deprived of my right to random vote, just because I'm a few hours late. Plus, I read the "business with subcom" as usual "whipping up insignificant stuff as scumtells" that some of these newer players like to indulge in.

Shit, I totally had you confused with someone else. I thought that was your second post.

Anyways, though, why do you think the case against subcom is insignificant?

Gandalf, what about NS's post was "scumposting," in your eyes?

The fact that he just came up with the stupidest reason to park his vote on a town power role ever.

How do you know Kats is town? Why are you automatically assuming that?

And weighing in on the RVS thing, I think scum can be found in RVS and that it is an important phase of the game. I also believe that people trying to avoid it or drag the game out of it for no reason are more likely scum.

But if we already have two caught scum there's not really any point.

Now, that bolded feels forced. Like you're trying too hard to latch on to all those other people saying "YEAH WE'VE GOT CAUGHT SCUM ON PAGE 3 AWESOME!!"

So you speculate that there is some sort of mechanic related to voting for the mod? Okay.

This feels forced.

This is not my quote.

Oh wow, he caught himself on page 3. This time I'm not there either

Hi 'dalfin

Vote: Ganondalf

Oh, third buddy. GAME OVER

More of the same forced-ness. Gandalf's play reads very unnaturally this game, combining these posts with his most recent one. I've played with town-gandy and scum-gandy, and this feels more like scum-gandy.

[scooby]

So you speculate that there is some sort of mechanic related to voting for the mod? Okay.

This feels forced.

This is not my quote.

My bad here. It was from subcom.

[gandalf5166]

You haven't played with me recently, Friend. My playstyle changes over time. I don't usually give people I think are scum the benefit of the doubt anymore. I just call them scum, because it makes everything easier. Kats could be scum, but I seriously doubt he's making it up. And if he were scum, I don't think he would have claimed what he did(unless people targeting him hurts HIM instead of the people targeting him).

[Magister Ludi]

Low access guys. will be around sometime in next few days,... maybe.

[gandalf5166]

Low access guys. will be around sometime in next few days,... maybe.

LIES AND DECEIT

I'm really bored. Someone say something I can actually call out.

[Nobody Special]

You're scum.

How's that?

[Friend]

You're scum.

[Friend]

Ah, fuck, NS.

[Subcomfreak]

I'm voting her for a semi theory reason. why would you delay the game? Is it not more helpful to the town to have random vote then be obstructionist? So to answer you question, it isn't as much scummy as it is anti-town. Early game, I believe they are 1 in the same for voting purposes.

But you yourself noticed that in Tar games, voting the mod sometimes does something. So why wouldn't UK's mod-vote be protown and non-obstructionist? Isn't she just testing the mechanics?

Assuming that counting the mod does something, assuming that voting the mod gives power to the town in some way, and assuming that it will be triggered by only one vote... I would vote for the mod. However, her vote is far more productive if it is on an actual player who can actually be lynched.

I do not think meta dictates someones play.

Her meta is to

always

do this in her games

. That does not exclude her from being scum. My vote stays simply because voting for someone else would not really mater. And for the whole not voting for a real player theory reason. Which is just as good as any bullshit rvs reason if you ask me.

I never said it excluded her from being scum. I just said it wasn't scummy that UK voted the mod because she's done as town many times.

On theory I must vote for someone who does not directly benefit the town with their vote. Period.

And to clarify, not voting for a legitimate player just delays the inevitable. We will eventually get information, but rvs is in my opinon the best way to do it. Ether you don't vote off of principle, or you vote for someone who could

actually

get lynched. Anything else is obstructinist and anti-town. That to me is enough to deserve a page 2 vote.

That's precisely what I hate about thim. I think he is faking the noob card.

What leads you to believe this (besides the Tar thing)?[/quote]

You know, subcom is putting an awful lot of energy into this.

subcom: Do you like pickles?

Nope. Actually I really dislike pickles. I do however, like cucumbers. Also, I came from another site that had similar (yet not exactly) style of play. Note the had. That is why I came here.

[Nobody Special]

Ah, fuck, NS.

Let's focus on the game, shall we?