SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[DemonHybrid]

V/LA until Tuesday

Were in a state of emergency and have no water, electricity or any food but salad until Tuesday. Sorry.

Understood.

[manho]

diddin is still not scum.

Reason being?

his actions are not that scummy. at least i've done that before as town. BL is much more scummy than diddin.

Hey, this seems familiar...remember when Hoppster and Ranmaru said the same thing about my actions? "I've done that as scum so it's a scumtell." "I've done it as town so it's a null tell!" It's still a worthless argument.

But then tell me, what's not scummy about first dismissing the Bunny wagon and then jumping on it without acknowledging your previous read? Or sheeping ALL the cases you believe have merit without any fresh input? And what about his misreps? Are they pro-town behavior?

k, i saw what you mean. missed that vote by diddin on BL. diddin is scum.

i'll consider changing my vote to diddin.

[manho]

V/LA until Tuesday

Were in a state of emergency and have no water, electricity or any food but salad until Tuesday. Sorry.

take care...

[Sunset]

diddin is still not scum.

Reason being?

his actions are not that scummy. at least i've done that before as town. BL is much more scummy than diddin.

Hey, this seems familiar...remember when Hoppster and Ranmaru said the same thing about my actions? "I've done that as scum so it's a scumtell." "I've done it as town so it's a null tell!" It's still a worthless argument.

But then tell me, what's not scummy about first dismissing the Bunny wagon and then jumping on it without acknowledging your previous read? Or sheeping ALL the cases you believe have merit without any fresh input? And what about his misreps? Are they pro-town behavior?

k, i saw what you mean. missed that vote by diddin on BL. diddin is scum.

i'll consider changing my vote to diddin.

What. The. Fuck.

Heavy FoS: manho

Hoppster: How can I paraphrase a quote? If I do it won't be a quote, and then it's worth nothing, right? Also I will sign my posts for now, awaiting response from Spoon on what he thinks.

~Johhog

[DemonHybrid]

Okay, so the generator came on. We have the power and internet, but no water and low food, so expect me still on V/LA. I'll post if I need to answer something or make a huge accusation but it wont be every day.

[Isa]

I hope you solve everything, DH. Best of luck.

manho, that's one major turnaround. What did you base your townread on?

[Isa]

Mod: Xeras and Parabollocks needs to be prodded

Already did that a day or two ago. They're probably getting replaced.

[David Xanatos]

Sorry to hear that DH. Hope it all comes back soon.

[Isa]

Don't like Bunnylover, probScum, but Jakalope seems worse to me.

VOTE: Jaka

Analysis when my stomach stops churning.

How's that analysis coming along?

[Celebloki]

Yeah, not dissing the votes on the Jaka wagon since I mainly started it, but both chkflip and david have supposed cases coming for him. Easy way to sheep a vote without having to justify it.

[chkflip]

You should know better than most on this player list that I don't talk without performing. Hats, bro. Hats. I'm just really busy with school right now and am trying to make it fluent without it being choppy or back and forth.

[WeyounsLastClone]

Okay, rereading the thread, DH kinda had some reasons to dislike RBT's play. Still don't like how in the end he wanted RBT to replace out, and also not how day 2 with an utmost certainty went after BL, but still. My vote on him is wasted anyway at this point.

Unvote.

I didn't like TheJakalope's play day 1, promising content, not giving any, and then jumping on RBT's wagon with much additional reason, and day 2 hasn't improved much.

Vote: TheJakalope.

[manho]

I hope you solve everything, DH. Best of luck.

manho, that's one major turnaround. What did you base your townread on?

i wasn't saying diddin is town. he was a null tell by that time. then i realized why you all think he is scum, agree with that, and thinking about the vote now.

[chkflip]

CHK's Jaka Case

1]] You will not convince me that this is a town-motivated way of asking for a claim. First, he fluff-notes that RBT is L-1 for town credit. Then he moves on to unvote, therefore placing RBT at L-2... and then asks him to claim? No. That's not pro-town. That's not a town post at all. Period.

2]] He never offers insight as to why he felt RBT was being scummy; instead, he states first that RBT and diddin are scummy (which he later retracts about diddin) with a few town and neutral reads he also had (which I feel is fluff filler to look pro-town), then takes a beef with RBT's play-style without actually elaborating as to why he feels it's scummy in the first place. The only elaboration therein, at all, is the fact that "I give up as scum," which automatically means that RBT was scum because they had given up? Obviously not.

3]] This is an entirely baseless accusation.

That's all I have time for for now, though these are (I feel) pretty strong points leaning toward The Scumalope.

[diddin]

diddin is still not scum.

Sounds like you were defending me pretty hard.

[chkflip]

diddin, do you find that town or scum defend more often? Which do you feel manho falls under?

[Bowser]

Parabollocks, Vifam, TheJakalope, Kcdaspot, and Xeras have been prodded.

[Kcdaspot]

post.

I'd hammer jak. i would.

but i just wanna active lurk this day so bad.

i mean i'll my scumreads are fucking wrong. meaning everything i got is shit.

I'm not giving up. i'd just rather calm down and come back to this thanx.

[DemonHybrid]

Okay, rereading the thread, DH kinda had some reasons to dislike RBT's play. Still don't like how in the end he wanted RBT to replace out, and also not how day 2 with an utmost certainty went after BL, but still. My vote on him is wasted anyway at this point.

Unvote.

I didn't like TheJakalope's play day 1, promising content, not giving any, and then jumping on RBT's wagon with much additional reason, and day 2 hasn't improved much.

Vote: TheJakalope.

Ew. This smells like mislynch all over.

WLC and Bunnylover for scum, September 2011!

[DemonHybrid]

Please get off of this horrible lynch and lynch people who aren't town.

[chkflip]

I agree with you about BunnyLover, for sure. But I also feel confident in my read on Jaka.

UNVOTE: Jakalope

I will, however, remove my vote

and insist other don't push him to L-1 right now

so we may discuss other avenues.

Aside from the uneasiness on the RBTwagon, what else makes BL scum?

[DemonHybrid]

I pointed everything out from his D1 play. He hasn't really contributed anything today.

WLC is just so obvious that it hurts, really.

[David Xanatos]

It's L-4 right now, not really dangerous but meh. I agree on WLC but to be honest, I'm not really convinced on the BL thing.. seems more.. derptown than scum to me.

[chkflip]

haha I misinterpreted KCD's post to mean that he was already at L-1. Now I feel silly for unvoting.

[David Xanatos]

Sorry, he was at L-2 until you unvoted. Stormer voted for him too..

I really wish people would use the vote tags more often.. it's not sodding hard. -.-