Open 354: Twin Trap in Morecambe (Concluded)

[Thomas]

I'm here.

Vote: Trevor

For having a townread on me then voting me.

[daftnarwhal]

Uhh hold on a second, but you must be joking. Narwhals are very real.
UNVOTE: VOTE: Adc75 for not knowing what a narwhal is.

[Adc75]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narwhal

So you're a stupid whale?

[daftnarwhal]

No, I'm a daft whale.

[Johhog]

VOTECOUNT 1.1

Sampson

: don_johnson

(L-4)

Adc75

: daftnarwhal

(L-4)

Trevor (2)

: }|{opa, Thomas

(L-3)

}|{opa (2)

: Guy_Named_Riggs, [J]

(L-3)

daftnarwhal

: Sampson

(L-4)

[J]

: Adc75

(L-4)

Thomas

: Trevor

(L-4)

Not voting

: No one.

With 9 alive it is 5 to lynch.

Deadline is (expired on 2011-11-25 04:36:09)

[Jora]

Casus Sententiae

for my vote was lost due to Post #24 by Trevor.

UNVOTE:

Everyone

but you knows that Sampson was a Jew.

Generalization!

Tempted to OMGUS but I have to keep going after OPA for using

a logical fallacy

.

Let's suppose that you are right and I used incorrect argumentation in reasoning. There is only two options for this to be true:

1) You didn't know that Sampson was a Jew.
2) You knew that Sampson was a Jew, but you thought that someone else except Sampson himself didn't.

So, is it 1) or 2)?

[J]

If someone else knew, anyone including people outside the game, your theory is flawed. =P

Hence the generalization call-out. So I choose option 3.

[Jora]

Let's consider this statement of yours.

Only one more person needs to post and that's everyone.

Is it "anyone including people outside the game" too? So whose theory is flawed, huh?

[J]

.....touche. xD

I should have been more specific with that I was talking about people in this game but yes you caught me in my own generalization fumble.

[Guy_Named_Riggs]

[J] is town
admitting to a mistake I think is town.

[J]

[J] is town
admitting to a mistake I think is town.

That's really a WIFOM reason to believe me as town. =x

[Sampson]

Just about. Do you really have a definite town read this early? We still seem to be in RVS, based on the tone of discussion so far, at least.

@Thomas:

I'm here.

Vote: Trevor

For having a townread on me then voting me.

Is this a serious post?

[Trevor]

Just about. Do you really have a definite town read this early? We still seem to be in RVS, based on the tone of discussion so far, at least.

@Thomas:

I'm here.

Vote: Trevor

For having a townread on me then voting me.

Is this a serious post?

Has any post been 100% serious?

[Jora]

Has any post been 100% serious?

All my posts were serious.

[Jora]

NOT.

[Thomas]

@Thomas:

I'm here.

Vote: Trevor

For having a townread on me then voting me.

Is this a serious post?

Uhh... yeah. But RVS.

[Guy_Named_Riggs]

No, not really

Just had to say it

[J]

Unvote
Vote: Sampson

We need to get this game going somewhere and this looks like a fun path. We could go GNR but idk.

[J]

EWBOP:

Unvote
Vote: Sampson

Sorry it's late and I just got back from the theatre. x_X""

[Guy_Named_Riggs]

why me?

[J]

Idk, I wanna say because you "guessed" me as town pretty spot on so quickly based on a rather hasty reason and it seems somewhat firm but that's just me. ;P

Who are you thinking is scummy based on the posts that people have done so far GNR?

[Guy_Named_Riggs]

For me,
hard to tell. I don't do well with reads early on in the game. And then I get NKed before the game progresses so I don't know how well i do later in the game

[J]

I agree as well. Last time I was in LYLO the person derp'ed and lynched me for like my first time of ever being lynched as town (which started a silly domino effect ;___; ) but the rest of the time, I die early.

Reads are a bit harder for me to acquire with concrete stuffs.

Plus you have a villain in your ava, I think the evidence supports me suspicion.

[Guy_Named_Riggs]

my ava?

[J]

Avatar = Doofensmertz (sp)