Mini 1313: Blood Bowl Mafia (Game over)

[PeregrineV]

@Slandaar- Suppose I were to stop voting you, but would then only vote Ghostlin or Inte. Who should I vote and why?

Vote count

(10 players alive = 6 to lynch)
(3) Slandaar – GreyICE, Glork, PeregrineV
(1) GreyICE – Slandaar
(1) Glork – inte
(1) StefanB – Ghostlin

Not voting

: Dazzy, pizzadudes7, StefanB, Tierce,

Deadline

: Saturday 31 March 20:00 CET

[Ghostlin]

@Slandaar- Suppose I were to stop voting you, but would then only vote Ghostlin or Inte. Who should I vote and why?

....Wow, this reads scummy.

"So in exchange for my vote, which mislynch/bus would you prefer?"

[GreyICE]

Grey/Malee is scum.

Nope.jpg

Try again

[Slandaar]

PV why are you voting me? because you are scum yes?

[Ghostlin]

PV why are you voting me? because you are scum yes?

Alright. I may have you as a null, but this 'accusing people of being scum because they're voting me' is getting old.

Also, there's other quality reasons why PV may be scum without him voting you. There's scum fueled wagons and then there's excessive paranoia. Guess which one you're erring on, and which one is generally considered more scummy?

[Slandaar]

The 2 cant be compared 1 is the wagons voters the other is the wagonee.

Ghost paranoia implies the person does not know whos who... in other words... its not scummy. Scum cant be paranoid.

ps; I didnt call them all scum

[Glork]

Mass OMGUS != Town Paranoia.

[Slandaar]

meta me

[Glork]

No need.

Incidentally, how does your paranoia theory stack up to the idea that tere are likely two different killing factions?

[Slandaar]

if theres 2 scum teams I guess it doesnt... scum would know theres 2 or assume it with low numbered team and be paranoid of the others.

Paranoia is still not scummy.

[Glork]

Mod:

Can we get prods on Pizzadudes, inte, and StefanB. All of them have gone more than 3 days without posting. Thanks in advance.

[Tierce]

Pizzadudes7 is avoiding this game, see his posts elsewhere. Please either shape up or replace out.

Buuut this is a good vote:

VOTE: PeregrineV

That sketchy behavior around Ghostlin and I smacked of scum lining up lynches and trying to avoid responsibility for it because 'he has seen town lie/gambit in Newbie games'. You have more experience with gambits than that, and that argument was worded all sorts of scummy wrong.

[Glork]

Unvote

.

[Glork]

I'm going to re-read the entire game tomorrow/Monday.

For now, I'll state that I have zero interest in lynching the following players today (in no particular order): Ghostlin, Pizza, inte, Glork, Tierce.

I need to sort out exactly how I feel about the game, and don't think I can do that without dedicating some serious time to reading through everything. There are a lot of *possibilities* I see, but I need to figure out which of these possibilities are most likely.

[Glork]

In the meantime, Tierce, I have a homework assignment for you.

How do you feel about GreyICE's replacement into the game? How do you think it compares to his replacement into MLP Mafia, taking into consideration the circumstances surrounding his replacement? What behavioral similarities and differences do you see between this game and that one?

[GreyICE]

I'm going to re-read the entire game tomorrow/Monday.

For now, I'll state that I have zero interest in lynching the following players today (in no particular order): Ghostlin, Pizza,

inte

, Glork, Tierce.

I need to sort out exactly how I feel about the game, and don't think I can do that without dedicating some serious time to reading through everything. There are a lot of *possibilities* I see, but I need to figure out which of these possibilities are most likely.

What?

[Glork]

Okay. I've barely read four pages of D1, and I'm comfortable putting Slandaar into the "I don't want to lynch him today" category.

Vote: PV

His very first post is a doozie. He goes after pappums for 3-votes-in-3 posts, says pappums' "worst vote" is on kondi, yet piles onto kondi anyway.

Reading on, Slandaar checks out w/the whole "If I were CLAIMED 1-shot, I'd use it D1/N1" thing. Claimed is the key word there.


I think inte's town. His response to kondi's request to eat the bomb seems protown:

its 1 shot

he'll just be the target of the night kill and were down a pr plus a suspected townie

Not wanting kondi to have the bomb because he's a 'suspected townie' is either a VERY clever scum-move (having kondi eat the bomb is something the scums would want), or inte's protown.

In a non-game-related sidenote, I think Tierce's thoughts/speech/mannerisms are eerily similar to my own. I also use "Neat." exclusively in a "thinly veiled sarcasm" way.


Ugh. While inte's reaction to kondi's "Iwantthebomb" was genuine, Malee's looks textbook scum. There's a reason I've wanted Malee dead, and GreyICE's entrance hasn't done enough to dissuade me, TBH.
Ghostlin's response to kondi also looks a bit scummy.

PV is like 95% likely scum... "I think we should make PapRat vig first so we get to use it." SOMEBODY knew who they wanted dead Night 1.



Okay. That's it for D1. I'll re-read D2 tomorrow and post continued thoughts.

[Glork]

I'm going to re-read the entire game tomorrow/Monday.

For now, I'll state that I have zero interest in lynching the following players today (in no particular order): Ghostlin, Pizza,

inte

, Glork, Tierce.

I need to sort out exactly how I feel about the game, and don't think I can do that without dedicating some serious time to reading through everything. There are a lot of *possibilities* I see, but I need to figure out which of these possibilities are most likely.

What?

You heard me, son.

[Glork]

Oh right, inte is on V/LA. I keep forgetting that. No need for a prod on him, but Pizza/StefanB need prodded hard.

[GreyICE]

-_-

What did you tell me about Magister Ludi?

[Glork]

You really want me to lynch you instead, don't you?

[GreyICE]

What did you tell me about Magister Ludi, Glork?

[Glork]

What does that have to do with this game?

[Glork]

For the record, GI, 90% of the people who try to undermine my suspicions by pointing out "but you were wrong about X in the past" are scum.

Now, answer my question before I move my vote to you and don't move it for the rest of the game. I already gave you ONE free pass not full-claiming right away. I won't give you another one.

[GreyICE]

What does that have to do with this game?

It has rather a lot to do with this game.

You thought he was town for one single reason (the Tierce wagon analysis) that I thought was easily duplicated by scum, and you ignored everything else about him.

Now Inte white knighted Kondi, and you're saying that post is a good reason to shut down suspicion.

You are putting way too much faith in "Town tells."