There are too many variables for me to figure out whether no lynch or lynching someone is the best bet... The fact that I'm not 100% sure which of you is the other townie is just making it worse, plus I don't even have time to take a real good look at this because exams > mafia right now.
Asking the mod a mechanics question. His answer should help me determine my course of action.
"They are concerned with matters hidden - under the earthline their altars are;"
Our only chance at winning is to no lynch and let SK and mafia target each other and see who wins and who is BP. They basically HAVE to target each other tonight because if they target one of us, the other will target whichever one targets us at that person will win. So it looks like this:
If SK targets Town and Scum targets SK -> Scum wins
If Scum targets Town and SK targets Scum -> SK wins
If SK targets Scum and Scum targets SK -> ???? Coin flip? Both die? Idk.
Also, you *should* be 100% sure who is scum. We had a RACE cop. There are two Gobbos, two Trolls, and two baddies left. Trolls flip scum. You do the math.
Again, your theory is either that as scum, I claimed to save the serial killer when scum would need him lynched, or that as the SK I claimed to save scum when I get endgamed by them just as easy as anyone else and would have no reason to care if they died.
Everyone thought I was definitely town, so why would either of those scenarios make sense?
That which is done out of love always takes place beyond good and evil
OK. I'm really sorry about that guys. I have the biggest test of my year today, and I've been working my ass off.
Working under the idea of BB being the SK, I asked the mod whether the last member of the mafia would be able to use both the SPP vig and the factional NK on the same night. The answer was no. Then I asked if both a BLOCK and a mafia NK were targeted on the same person, which flavour would appear. I was told both in some way.
What this means is that since we had a kill flavour we haven't seen before (beaten to a pulp), either the person who did the beating (I'm interpreting this as BLOCK) is the mafia, or for some reason has their own kill flavour.
That is, since no one "disappeared" last night, either:
Individual mafia members have their own kill flavour.
Grey, being scum, used his BLOCK last night.
The GooN faction has been eliminated.
I'll
VOTE: No Lynch
because it still seems to be the best option for town, but does the above info change anyone's opinions on the best course of action?
"They are concerned with matters hidden - under the earthline their altars are;"