Mini 1349: Words with Scum (Game over!)

[IceGuy]

Collect: F4

[whispersilk]

Can we please slow this right down? Despite the fact that DCL has been a scum read for me all game, he has exhibited significant town behaviour since he was wagoned. I think there are other people worth considering, and although flawed, his gambit has resulted in comments by other people that have led me to see things I didn't see before - of which I will be posting about tomorrow morning. I've been distracted all evening and haven't really had the opportunity to get on and compose lengthy posts.

[2minds1soul]

...Damn our activity
Go-Go-Gadget Catch-Up Post will be put into operation tommrow afternoon, we promise.

[Voidedmafia]

...Damn our activity
Go-Go-Gadget Catch-Up Post will be put into operation tommrow afternoon, we promise.

Which makes me question how much we should actually put in such a promise.

[vijay2vasandani]

Can I pick a random letter? What I need isn't on the board.

[AurorusVox]

Tbh there's a good chance of robo still being town. If you have a magical secret tell it looks like you're just whiteknighting, especially given iceguy was in line for a lynch (note to self: check iceguy wagon at time of gambit)

Tbh there's also a good chance Dcl is town. The arguments against him being town recently boil down to wifom. I dislike vm's vote to l-1 at a time when its clear that if Dcl is scum, putting him to l-1 is dangerous for town. His reply to me - that town want to collect first - doesn't mesh with him voting Dcl.

[AurorusVox]

Wait. Dcl why did you call robo second most likely to flip town of those voting for you if you'd run a gambit that caught him out?

[Voidedmafia]

NO, that came before the gambit.

Also, I believe everyone who's collected except IceGuy are already on DCL, so unless someone flips and votes him on their next turn (which would probably be a scumclaim anyways), I don't see the overall threat of L-1 (nevermind that IceGuy got ran up to L-1 before and I don't remember you raising any concerns).

[IceGuy]

I only got run up to L-2 if I remember correctly.

[Voidedmafia]

I only got run up to L-2 if I remember correctly.

...Coulda sworn you were at L-1 at some point.

[AurorusVox]

Vm do you have townreads on everyone on dcls wagon, and scumreads on everyone else?

[MagnaofIllusion]

Collect: E1

--

Also: Last call for the "D" tile on the board! I wish to collect in one of my next couple of posts.

Take it already.

--

@AV

–

BTW AV - you didn't answer about what you think about Iceguy's case ...

--

Yawn...go ahead and lynch me, scum have given themselves away through VCA.

First we have the casual “I don’t care dismissal”

Good job LLD, you managed to skim the thread and put someone at L-1 for an out of context quote. Congrats.

But 9 posts later um whut? I thought you were not worried about being lynched since it would out scum. This doesn’t match that additude.

Then we get the 1-2 WIFOM bath of Post 676 and Post 677. What scum could possibly post that? He’s totally Town now …

But if you want to lynch me before everyone collects, go ahead and do that. It's just going to hurt the town.

So now you do mind if you are lynched and it doesn’t cause scum to be caught via PoE? That’s what the Appeal to Fear here is saying …

His reads at Post 686 are also pretty ludicrous. Everyone voting him is scum except for LLD who he says is ‘retarded Town’. And in Post 740 suddenly Ice and Voided are scum with him also.

Now let me get to the worst (yes, worse than above) part of his recent posting ..

You are second most likely to flip town OUT OF THE PEOPLE VOTING FOR ME (which is a group of 5)

So in a 5 person group Robo is second MOST likely to flip Town. That means that three other players are MORE likely to be scum.

I have a confession to make. (no I'm not claiming scum) I've been running a gambit.

…

Thomith got run up to L-1.
Llama then uses a tell that he claims proves thomith is town.
I as scum immediately call bs on the tell, knowing that the tell is complete bs because I have inside info.

…

Robocopter is scum, he needs to hang. NOW.

VOTE: Robocopter

So way back when you called Ice versus Voided TvT you were setting a trap. A trap that Robo bit immediately just like you did in that particular game. Yet up until you reveal this Robo is not even in your top 3 scum picks. Post 698 came well after your ‘gambit’. You clearly say in Post 735 that Robo was scummy immediately after you did it.

A gambit? Nope, Chuck Testa …

[AurorusVox]

What specifically about his case do you want me to respond to?

[MagnaofIllusion]

What specifically about his case do you want me to respond to?

As originally asked - what are your thoughts on the side by side comparison of Iceguy-Town making a case in 70s SmallTown with Iceguy-here making a 'case'?

[AurorusVox]

Is the side by side comparison in thread or does it require me to look this other game up?

[Voidedmafia]

Moi: Jeez <_</

Collect: A4

Avox: Well, if you've followed my reads you'd know that's already false. But here.

Vijay and LLD are null (thus not all on the wagon are town).
Whisper is town (thus not all off the wagon are scum)
Amrun and 2for1 are null (though Amrun is on the town end).
MoI is town
And you know my read on you three.

WHat's your point?

P-EDIT: Don't be a sissy.

[Voidedmafia]

Collect: A4

[IceGuy]

His point is: I posted long posts in another game where I was town and shorter posts here, therefore I must be scum here.

Basically, another shitty attempt at making up a scumtell from MoI (a cursory look over my games would show that I rarely post as long posts as I did a few months ago).

[MagnaofIllusion]

His point is: I posted long posts in another game where I was town and shorter posts here, therefore I must be scum here.

Nope.jpg. Just another straw-man.

The point as you are well aware is that you posted links to IN THREAD behavior in trying to demonstrate you had a valid case in 70s.

Here you just made a list of behaviors you say I am doing but didn't show examples because you know you can't support it.

Also ... lulz cherry-picked meta here and not there ...

[IceGuy]

The point as you are well aware is that you posted links to IN THREAD behavior in trying to demonstrate you had a valid case in 70s.

So your point is: I posted long posts in another game where I was town and shorter posts here, therefore I must be scum here.

[Amrun]

i exist

catch up asap

[AurorusVox]

Vm: my point is you should care if Dcl can self hammer considering you have townreads who have not yet collected. You said people on the wagon had already collected as if that excused your scummy l-1 vote. But obv not.

[AurorusVox]

Ps moi on my phone so I can't check anything out but it sounds like ice is in the right above. So what if he's changed how he scumhunts? I know i have.

[vijay2vasandani]

Second call for me taking a random tile. Will do so in my next post if there are no objections.

What are we waiting for?

Oh and btw, dcl I was just sheeping whoever voted you to begin with. I remember agreeing with somebody.

[IceGuy]

Second call for me taking a random tile. Will do so in my next post if there are no objections.