Page 10 - Pine goes on about Derpy and whisper's comments on being prodded. meh. inte and noob go on about Matias not being around. inte wants to lynch Matias but doesn't put a vote down. Noob does. I have a town read so far on noob....inte not so much. inte reverses course and decides Philla and I are scum. He has his vote on Phil att but puts no vote down on me (until his LOL vote on page 15). Derpy
agrees with inte's observation towards me @Derpy
.....what observation of inte's are you referring to? You also state that you think I could be scum based on my
"play (or lack there of) this game."
How does that work? Is my play scummy or is the fact I have not been playing a lot scummy? And if it is my lack of play...(this coming over a 5 day holiday period where I was farily absent in all my games) then why not just look at activity levels and vote the two players with the least amount of votes
I keep going back and forth on Derpy....leaning scum atm. I do not get
Phil's Post 246.
@Phil,
if you suspect derpy AND inte....why do you have to vote one or the other? Why not both like you were doing before inte confused you?
Page 11 - Gunny has meta suspicions towards me. Just noticed
Post 254 from Derpy,
@Derpy
...have we played before? Because you are responding to a question from Gunny about how I play when I'm town. What are you basing your input on his question on? Laughing at Code liking Matias'
Post 256...I thought it was pretty crappy. I especially liked his comment at the end where he tells others to
"step their shit up"
when it's only his 6th post of the game and the previous 5 were a RV, a miller question, and 3 excuses....ie nothing.
Page 12 - While I have suspicions towards derpy and inte...I find
Phil's suspicions towards them very weak and his supicions towards whisper ridiculous (The prodding fiasco? That was a fiasco?). I think one of Derpy or inte is scum but I do not think they both are.
@Matias and Gunny
....please respond to my questions towards you in my
Post 279. Re: Derpy's response to my Post 279....how am I not willing to take a stand? Voting is taking a stand. As of Post 280 I had voted 5 people (2 only in the RVS) while you had voted 8 (only one in the RVS). Who can't make a stand? In
Post 288 D3f comes to the conclusion Derpy is scum (but without a vote) and follows that up with a Phil post where he deems Phil scum and actually places a vote. ATT D3f only has one vote in play. Why?
Page 13 - And in
inte vote 1s Phil despite already having his Vote 1 on Phil for most of the game. Nice. And noob catches it. Phil's grand effort to save himself is a pretty lame post what is 95% quote and %5 zzzzz.
@MattP
....how is Gunny's Miller claim the worst you've ever seen? Is it the only one you've ever seen?
Page 14 - Ok...MattP explains his worst claim comments. I like Gunny's explanation more than MattP's implication re the Miller claim. Shifting town on Gunny. I do not see the motivation for scum to claim Miller right out of the starting blocks. Gunny was at L-3 but 1) that is early to claim, and 2) Gunny made no mention to his claim being related to the size of his wagon. So for now, IMO, he is a regular player based on his play. MattP's strong push on Gunny for no reason I can see other than his claim is suspect IMO.
Page 15
In summary...I really don't care for inte's play but I think he's just bad abrasive town. Pine was playing pretty crap and MattP's entrance has not done that slot any favors with his ~PL push. I was of the opinion either Derpy or inte was scum (but not both)...and since I've revised my read atm on inte that leads me back to Derpy...who I think has made some inconsistent comments/votes and as he puts it...is unwilling to take a stand. I really do not like Phil's game so far....little to no contribution (aside from his 3 suspects) of value and currently no votes out. WTF
I usually don't do these types of breakdowns but for some reason with a two wagon mechanic I feel inclined to.
Town: whispersilk
Leaning town: PerV, mafia
Null-town: Action, inte, Gunny
Null-scum: Code_X, D3f Scum: Phil, Derpy, Mattp, Matias
VOTE: 1 Phil <-- L-1
VOTE: 2 Derpy
I could support a MattP wagon2 as opposed to a Derpy one if his wagon shifts from 1 to 2.