OK so I have slept on this. Here are my toughts.
I am fairly convinced we are looking at 1 more mafia, and 1 more trapper.
Case 1.
CMAr is town and 241 is trapper.
Pro:
-false guilty results after sanity check
-detectives are VT
-too many investigative roles
-general behavior(pushing on bad logic, 1 shot trap idea)
Con:
-tracker result hard to explain
There is a case to be made here, but I think CMARs explanation of the tracker result is a stretch. True, absta did claim neighbourizer, so this gives credence to a second ability, but I would argue that the tracker would track the killing ability first, no?
Case 2
241 is town and CMAR is the trapper
Pro:
-CMAR has easyest to fake claim with a miller/scumblocker
Con:
-nothing in the behaviour points to scum much
-our QT is pretty reassuring too
-role interactions between his and mine make it more believeable
CMAR claimed a weird trap for sure, but the same logic applies as to my trap.
In both cases we look for another Mafia, but the kills are somehow messed up. If i had to chose between iDanny, the tracker, or Emp, Id say its Emp.
Case 3.
CMAR is trapper and 241 is mafia
This makes more sense than the above 2. 241 KNEW that danny tracked him. he waited with his result until danny said this:
I'm waiting for the person alI tracked to reveal their results before I reveal mine.
You can deduct from this that 241 was the tracked. So now he knew danny saw him going to nopoint and he had a copclaim going. He took a shot and claimed guilty. He was wrong, so now he has to go back to sanity issues.
I fint CMAR to be more likely to be the trapper than 241. Since the trapper is a bigger threat than the mafia due to the lack of kills so far
vote CMAR