Newbie 1345: Mafia in a Bind (Game Over)

[Equinox]

Vote Count 3.07

Mac (1) - NicCage
NicCage (1) - Mac

Not Voting (3) - Didi, frog, Xiao Long

With 5 alive, it's 3 to lynch.

The deadline is Tuesday, April 23, 2013, at 5:40 PM EDT (UTC-4).

Mod Notes

Didi is V/LA until April 19.

[NicCage]

I didn't think it was going to be this much of a problem

[Didi]

obligatory post so I don't get prodded (a)

[Mac]

I didn't think it was going to be this much of a problem

Voting and then making a case is scummy

Voting and then making a case in Lylo is

especially

scummy.

[frog]

Doing the same as Didi.

[Mac]

With all due respect: we need activity.

I know I'm biased but I seriously think I've put forward some major points against Nic tripping.

[NicCage]

you mean the case that was already against me?

[Mac]

That part where you bullshit about your opinion changing "naturally" in 20 minutes is new.

[NicCage]

lol in what way, how do you expect me to say my reads changed? No matter how you try to represent it, my vote isn't going to look any scummier than it already did.

[Xiao Long]

Time to do Didi ;D

Starts off the game quite town, imo. He asks questions, tries to pressure, etc. He says he's been playing mafia regularly since 2007/08, so we can assume he's quite experienced. Applies pressure to Xeg who replies aggressively. Unfortunately, his pressure sort of loses its steam when he says "My hunch isn't strong enough yet that I'll try and drag others into this. I'll just see how this all develops" in post 75. Maybe this is just Didi's playstyle, but for me, I wouldn't want to let people relax. Even if they're not scum, pressure loses meaning when you say stuff like this. Post 217 bothers me. Your comment at the end of that post "So, I get it that you suspect me, but you're on the wrong track. I'm just a clueless townie." seems waaaaay too convenient.

Post 399 is fairly town. Tries not to rush the Mutley lynch and give everyone time to state their thoughts. 404 and 406 really echo the town sentiment. Post 419 might even be a town slip as he doesn't realise scum don't have daytalk. It's possible that he was leaving an intentional town slip, but I don't know if he's clever enough for this (no offense), but one must not forget he's experienced in mafia, so it's possible it was an intentional slip. 461 is VERY town, imo. Dislikes Mutley for derailing the game, gets pissed at Mac for putting him at L-1 after Mutley stated he would self-lynch.

Post 495 has Didi start to think Frog is scummy, despite believing he was town earlier with the argument that Frog is going out of his way to agree with him.

The only person I've seen make a decent case against Didi was MP5, but he's pretty town to me (or is he ;D).

I don't see anymore enlightenment coming from Nic and Mac continuously bickering with each other, so let's put the focus on someone else. So, I think today should be Discuss Didi Day (DDD).

[NicCage]

Blehh, well I think I've stated about everything I think on Didi at this point. Haven't heard much

from

Didi though

[Didi]

If I vote to lynch Nic, who would follow my lead?

If I vote to lynch Mac, who would follow my lead?

I want to know where Xiao and frog stand atm



Also, Nic and Mac, if you're both gonna keep up the 'I'm town ffs', get your votes off of eachother to help, as I'd hate for my vote to be a L-1 vote and if it's wrong for just 1 mafia to be immediately able to react, if possibly 2 people need to vote with me then at least I could get my vote off of it if I think I made the wrong call after all judging from their vote/reaction. If that makes any sense.

[NicCage]

Eh yeah, that sort of makes sense, but really all it's doing is taking some of pressure off of you Xiao and frog. It won't change the situation a lot, considering as soon as Mac or I get to L-1 the other will hammer.
UNVOTE: Why are you fence-sitting and asking others? Afraid your vote alone won't be enough to lynch me?

[frog]

No, I think he's genuinely torn between the two of you.
Since Mac/Nic are my proposed scumteam I'd follow you on either vote. My read on Mac is stronger (possibly due to suspecting him for longer) so if I had to choose I'd pick Mac. But I don't mind either way.

[Mac]

I'd like my vote to remain on Nic because I know he's scum.

won't change the situation a lot, considering as soon as Mac or I get to L-1 the other will hammer.

lolwhat?

Here's a game I've just scanned guys (a scum win; let's look at the final votes);

Newbie 1336

Okay so if MR E is scum I am giving him the victory, not gonna vote him.

THat leaves jason, cybertronix and marangal. I cant really see the team not having jason.

OK now i am pretty certain that Mr E and Sven are scum.

This is nearly the worst post i have seen all game.

I nearly wasn't willing to vote due to cybertronix being that Null posting blob in the corner but now i am happy to.

VOTE: Mr E Roll

Phone posting.

Sven's reaction says it all. Mr. E and Him are the pair.

VOTE: Mr. E Roll

VOTE: MR E

Not the second post and vote on a townie; passing the blame to someone else. Although this was his scumbuddy, he still does this incase his buddy doesn't hammer. Luckily, Sven did and scum won. This scene of posts came over 20 minutes.

[NicCage]

If you had the opportunity to hammer me you wouldn't take it? I don't understand the case your making.

[Mac]

Oh right, irrelevant for me cos my votes on you.

[Equinox]

...guys?

[Mac]

I don't know either, Equinox.

[Xiao Long]

Whoa, really sorry, the weekend sort of got away from me. I'll be doing my ISO of Frog tomorrow, and hopefully we can come to a resolution on the Mac/Nic thing.

[frog]

I don't think I have any more to add.

[NicCage]

I'm still around.

[Didi]

Sorry, I was away for the weekend without internet.

Mac seems sure in his idea that Nic is mafia, which I suppose is understandable considering the situation. On the other hand, Nic immediately took his vote off when I asked him to. A townie trying his best to solve this predicament, or a scared mafia trying his best to pander to a townie to get him on his side? I'm inclined to think the latter. The deadline is tomorrow, I think I've doubted long enough (plus I don't know when or if I will be online tomorrow), so I'm gonna vote now. Can't keep off this hard choice forever.


VOTE: NicCage


Here's hoping I made the right call.

[frog]

Xiao, what are your thoughts now? Mac or NicCage?

[NicCage]

I was just trying to move the game forward Didi, though it seems like it was unnecessary. I like how you want to use that against me. VOTE: Mac