Gears of War Mafia - ( Game Over! )

[DrippingGoofball]

Alright Goat gets to live until tomorrow DGB.

If we're not lynching Angelious, Rubicon, or Goat, then who the fuck are we lynching?

AN or qwints.

[DrippingGoofball]

Unvote; Vote: Messiah

DEATH TO MESSIAH

Is he scum?

[Colonel Guile]

Who knows? He's as good a bet as anyone else, right?

brb, ISOing.

[qwints]

You can't pick Goat, AN, or Rubicon. Who's next on your list?

Viomi. Then Mac.

[Colonel Guile]

Actually, we should all unvote, and not rush this.

Viomi, let's have a little chat. Are you scum? Can you tell me anything useful you've done this game?

Mac, I want to know why you think Messiah thinks/thought you are/were scum, in your own words.

Messiah, tell me what you think of EVERYTHING in the game please.

[Colonel Guile]

In good faith:

Unvote

I expect everyone else to follow suit. Please.

[qwints]

fair enough. UNVOTE:

[Antilles]

1)The "this is exactly why I voted for you" doesn't even make sense. I cited a previous game where basically the exact same thing happened and I flipped town, and you're saying that's exactly why you voted me.
2)You argue that it's too early (via page numbers) for town to get upset about a vote on them, yet simultaneously argue that your vote is totally legitimate.
2b)You emphasize so strongly the specific page number and don't even cite the correct page.
3)You proceed to call me scummy for questioning the shitvotes I have on me.

1.) I was obviously referring to the "town doesn't say that" part, which is why I then proceeded to start the next sentence with "Town doesn't..."
2.) I

almost

see your point. Your reaction to your wagon has been awful all around, mostly down to the way you demanded everyone present a case so you can defend yourself. You're trying to make a distinction between that and "You can't PROVE I'm scum!" but I don't see one, at all, even a little. The fact that it was so early in the game just made it worse, as if you somehow expected AP to be giving you cases to pick apart on page 4. (And yes, post 90 was on page 4. Go check.)
3.) I think you reacted to them in a way that appeared more scum than town, but nice try twisting it to sound better.

--
The Goat is probably town, and the votes on him are stupid. I feel like he would be a lot more appeasing in this situation if he were scum. He admitted to having skimmed the thread before voting when he could have just said he saw the thread was up and just quickly voted before dinner because he remembered that's what you're supposed to do in post 230. I also think the way he explains that people's problem with his late random vote is "[their] problem, not [his]" like in post 275 reads as more townish in this situation too, for the same reason.

mastin and Ms Marangal can be scum. Would definitely vote them.

ANG still reads as scum for the reasons I've previously stated, and I don't like the way he's continued only focusing on his attackers and responding to direct questions. In post 181 he states that GIF and I could be scum on his wagon, but offers absolutely no insight into his thoughts there. I would write something about the hypocrisy there, but it's self-evident so etc.

Oh and Nero, what do you think of Ms Marangal and DGB?

[qwints]

Who is this?

[Mac]

Actually, we should all unvote, and not rush this.

Viomi, let's have a little chat. Are you scum? Can you tell me anything useful you've done this game?

Mac, I want to know why you think Messiah thinks/thought you are/were scum, in your own words.

Messiah, tell me what you think of EVERYTHING in the game please.

Messiah thought I was scum because I thought Slandaar was town and during d1 voted for CryoNudist first & then him to counter my townreads wagon. he then accused me of waiting for his results and trying to discredit them by questioning him afterwards, which is a pretty shit excuse because I waited for both results before commenting and then asked why he felt the need to hold them back for a while into d2, almost letting piratecat get lynched.

right now, I couldn't tell you what he thinks of me or anyone cos his contribution has been zero lately.

[Viomi]

I somehow managed to skip over where he claimed the name.

Still voting goat :3

[The Goat]

Well, I made the sale. Yay me. I'm on my computer, and popped open a beer. Will answer questions.

I'm aggravated as hell now, and here are my random thoughts in no particular order.

1) I sincerely do not give a rat's ass at this point if I get lynched or not. I'm the town doctor, and have protected Messiah every night. I do find it odd that nobody even took a SHOT at him...and I even mentioned that yesterday. To this end, I am not 100% convinced that he's town. I do not think, if he IS scum, he's on the same team as Slandaar, as he pretty well cooked Slandaar's goose. I am also not convinced Guile is town. If I don't get lynched, I may or may not protect either of them. I do not expect to survive the night.

2) Guile, you're all over the place, like a ferret on crack, just ITCHING to lynch anyone. I DEFINITELY want to know what the hell this mechanism is you set in place.

3) Qwints, I don't know the connection between Guile and Rubicon, if there is any. Here's what I know.

a) I'm the town doctor
b) Rubicon counterclaims, then completely disappears.
c) Guile then says that Rubicon is going to die tonight ANYWAY, because of "a mechanism that he set in place". Again, this happened after Rubicon counterclaimed.

Now, obviously I have the advantage of knowing that I'm not scum. Look at it from my perspective. Why would one of the remaining scum stick their neck out to try and counterclaim, when they'll be hyperlynched the following day? Would it be worth eliminating my protection for a night and gaining an additional action? Probably not. So why do it? The only thing that makes any sense is if Rubimajiffy ALREADY KNEW he was going to die tonight anyway.

Also, I didn't panic. I was eating lunch and phone posting, and I miscounted. And I'm a little pissed about the way the whole thing went down.

4) Viomi...seriously?

[The Goat]

..and now I need another beer.

[DrippingGoofball]

I do find it odd that nobody even took a SHOT at him...and I even mentioned that yesterday. To this end, I am not 100% convinced that he's town. I do not think, if he IS scum, he's on the same team as Slandaar, as he pretty well cooked Slandaar's goose.

This is most interesting.

[The Goat]

Wat?

[DrippingGoofball]

ferret on crack

Welcome to UberNinja's cage.

[DrippingGoofball]

Wat?

Would two scum teams assume that he's doc-protected for 5 days? When did he claim?

[The Goat]

ferret on crack

Welcome to UberNinja's cage.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3vnbe2_EGE

[Rubicon]

UNVOTE:
although I still want Goat to die.

Flavor for both of you?

The gist is that I can deliver supporting fire to protect someone who's under attack.

I'm the town doctor, and have protected Messiah every night.

I do find it odd that nobody even took a SHOT at him

...and I even mentioned that yesterday. To this end, I am not 100% convinced that he's town.

Doctor shouldn't know this.

Why would one of the remaining scum stick their neck out to try and counterclaim, when they'll be hyperlynched the following day? Would it be worth eliminating my protection for a night and gaining an additional action? Probably not.

You make an excellent point, Goat.

So why do it? The only thing that makes any sense is if Rubimajiffy ALREADY KNEW he was going to die tonight anyway.

...Right.
I can only think of one way Guile could

know

I was going to die tonight, and it's not something I could have known before he said it. Here's an alternative suggestion, which makes a bit more sense: I'm the town doctor, and you're scum.

[DrippingGoofball]

Night 2 and Night 4... only one kill.

Why you say that no one tried to shoot Messiah?

[The Goat]

UNVOTE:
although I still want Goat to die.

Flavor for both of you?

The gist is that I can deliver supporting fire to protect someone who's under attack.

Do better. My role pm was a good bit more detailed than something you could get a "gist" from. I apparently have this cool vehicle. What do you have, other than made up stuff?

I'm the town doctor, and have protected Messiah every night.

I do find it odd that nobody even took a SHOT at him

...and I even mentioned that yesterday. To this end, I am not 100% convinced that he's town.

Doctor shouldn't know this.

I'm working from flavor. I'd like to think that a protect should appear in a writeup. Remember when I asked AN about why he thought there was a protect very early today? Interesting, no?

Why would one of the remaining scum stick their neck out to try and counterclaim, when they'll be hyperlynched the following day? Would it be worth eliminating my protection for a night and gaining an additional action? Probably not.

You make an excellent point, Goat.

Just wait till I get going. Where was I?

So why do it? The only thing that makes any sense is if Rubimajiffy ALREADY KNEW he was going to die tonight anyway.

...Right.

I can only think of one way Guile could

know

I was going to die tonight, and it's not something I could have known before he said it

. Here's an alternative suggestion, which makes a bit more sense: I'm the town doctor, and you're scum.

Well golly gee whillikers, Liary Liarpants...you want to share that with the class?

[The Goat]

Night 2 and Night 4... only one kill.

Why you say that no one tried to shoot Messiah?

I'd like to think that it would have shown in the writeup. There's been a tremendous amount of flavor this entire game. I doubt a kill attempt would have been edited out.

[The Goat]

Misread the "supporting fire" part. Interesting that there's a mention of "cover fire" (paraphrased) in the writeup from today...and it didn't save anyone.

[Colonel Guile]

ferret on crack

Welcome to UberNinja's cage.

Daykill: DrippingGoofball

[Colonel Guile]

I somehow managed to skip over where he claimed the name.

Still voting goat :3

Answer my fucking questions.