First of all, I've played with Fegelein before in Newbie 1344 and the level of analysis here versus the level of analysis there is terrifying. He tends to tunnel a little bit as town, cares a lot about his reads and gets pretty confrontational with them, but here he hasn't really shown any level of engagement with the game and he hasn't cared about his reads at all. His chainsaw defense of you was ridiculously over the top and fake as shit, and his replace out of "man this hydra sucks my partner ditched me" seems more like scum being left out to dry by his hydra partner as opposed to someone really being THAT frustrated that he had to play alone. Also, there's a small subtle hydra-scum tell in that he was angry that his partner didn't post (and act town) as opposed to "my partner was never there", but that's a new one.
I hate Goat giving excuses for his lurking. His immediate response to Nero suspecting him was "I actually like you, can you pull your head out of vendettaland?" when Nero didn't really have any sort of vendetta at all against him. It read like an attempt to buddy the hell out of him so he would take his vote off, and was not a townie response at all. His interactions with Nero are suck because he discredits the hell out of Nero every second he defends himself and yet never calls him scum, his vote on us sucks because it comes out of nowhere after Kise says we should kill him, his vote on Nero is literally spite and nothing more, and then he tries to BLAME HIS TUNNELING ON NERO.
No.
RatedR is Vifam's posting, which shouldn't need explaining, Grazie's dancing around Krabs lynch was scummy as all hell and parading the GCBC read around like it makes him obvious town is scum proud they pegged the other team. Additionally, this flavor speculation is absolutely horrible.
In post 1237, RATEDR wrote:That said, it doesn't explain why they'd get GoodCopBadCop, which was kind of obvious Mafia from the beginning, so I guess maybe it was a vig from Town and the flavor is just that The Shield kills everyone in this game...? Sorry, flavor-speculation, I'm just interested in it, I can't wait for the OP to reveal the roles at the end.