Calvin and Hobbes Mafia(GAME OVER! Grownups Mafia Wins!)

[TheIrishPope]

Considering only like 10 people have talked and we have 4 pages full of shitty votes, I have nothing
Also, given that I gave a thought about T S O and TD, I won't give reads any more

[Psyche]

These last 4 pages weren't great, but many players have managed to make something out of them.

If you don't think the grounds for what they've made out of them were good, you should actively seek to expose this reality in a persuasive way.

[Psyche]

That's how nonshitty stuff starts to happen in games.

[TheIrishPope]

Maybe tomorrow. Lynch Rubricon, I'm sure she's scum

[Psyche]

sigh

[Mr E Roll]

It's a thought I put in the open because I am transparent. Hiding info is harmful to Town, don't you agree?

Considering only like 10 people have talked and we have 4 pages full of shitty votes, I have nothing
Also, given that I gave a thought about T S O and TD, I won't give reads any more

So now you have decided to intentionally be harmful to town?

That seems a sure fire way to convince us that our votes are misguided.

Feels like you are scum that has already given up and just don't want us to be able to establish your partners through interaction.

[TheIrishPope]

Getting me lynched is also harmful for Town, because, you know, I'm Town
So since I'm giving thoughts and I'm getting lynched because of them
I have decided to not give reads

[Psyche]

do you think that is constructive

[TheIrishPope]

For my self-survival, yes

[Mr E Roll]

If you were town you would want to help town even as you were being lynched.

[Psyche]

not getting lynched is helping town when you are town

TIP just doesn't understand that refusing to produce content isn't going to help his chances of surviving the Day

[Psyche]

not getting lynched is helping town when you are town

TIP just doesn't understand that refusing to produce content isn't going to help his chances of surviving the Day

[TheIrishPope]

Precisely
Therefore I tell you to sheep me because I'm Town
Or, alternatively and conservatively, we wait for all 21 players to check in

[Mr E Roll]

How am I supposed to sheep somebody who won't vote and won't provide reads?

[Metal Sonic]

there is no scum in this game, only calvin



boy i wonder what the scum role flavor is? those zog? that old teacher whose name I forgot? exciting !

[TheIrishPope]

I did vote
I did say at least one read
Everyone's pretty much null
You guys are Town

[Mr E Roll]

there is no scum in this game, only calvin



boy i wonder what the scum role flavor is? those zog? that old teacher whose name I forgot? exciting !

What does this mean?

Isn’t scum… scum regardless of the flavor?

[Metal Sonic]

i am more interested in the flavor than the scum

because i have a very bad (and lame) flavor mismatch -__-

[Nobody Special]

Hi. I hate Day One in large games.

I'm much better starting with Day Two.

[Zed17]

Vote: MEtal Sonic

114 is weird, thought process doesn't seem natural. I doubt that if he were really wondering about scum's flavor he would say there's no scum in the game right above it.

117 is also concerning if we take 114's context. If he were scum, his thought process would follow as something like 'why is my flavor so out of place with my alignment' which is a lot more reasonable than if he were town going along the lines of 'why do i have bad guys in my flavor if I'm town'. More likely the former because if he were town thinking what I just wrote (given what he said before), he wouldn't have asked about scum's flavor because he knew it wouldn't be alignment indicative.

[Varsoon]

VOTE: Varsoon

I want some shitty reaction tests.

Sorry to /in so late.

Finally got back to the states and I now have a working net connection.

I'll catch up with the game after I Sleep.

[Varsoon]

Hi. I hate Day One in large games.

I'm much better starting with Day Two.

I swear I'll sleep sometime, but...

You like D2 more because you can talk to your allies during the night/speculate on the Nightkill?

:/

[Varsoon]

So I caught up after all.
IrishPope wagon reeks.
He's constantly claiming town, which is my smoking-gun-town-read. You can't take my smoking-gun. Then the handle will be all nasty and greasy and warm. You probably got cheeto fingers, too.

I don't like MS' speculating on the roles. That'll get us nowhere.

Zed's work is pretty methodical and good. I like this guy.

NS worries me.

Psyche's plays seem largely reactionary/fishing for reactions. Dunno how to feel about that. Feels scummy, but I've played that game of calvin-ball before.

In these huge games, it's easy for scum to snowball out of control.
Let's all work together, keep track of all the players in-game (despite the headcount), and work on it.


For now, too tired to actually do more than this.

[Dante]

Vote Count 1.1 - June 14, 2013 - With 21 alive, it requires 12 to lynch

TheIrishPope(4) - Who, Mr E Roll, Psyche, TiphaneDeath, Zoidberg

(L-8)

EddieFenix(2) - Boxxy, Skullduggery

(L-10)

Psyche - Rubicon
Demon - Zed17
Varsoon - BROseidon
Skullduggery - Desperado
Zoidberg - EddieFenix
Desperado - T S O
Not Voting(10): TheIrishPope, Varsoon, Penguin_Alien, Zed17, boxxy, Metal Sonic, Radioactive Wolf, roflcopter, Nobody Special, Dante

I voted Demon. Missing from count.

[Metal Sonic]

Vote: MEtal Sonic

114 is weird, thought process doesn't seem natural. I doubt that if he were really wondering about scum's flavor he would say there's no scum in the game right above it.

117 is also concerning if we take 114's context. If he were scum, his thought process would follow as something like 'why is my flavor so out of place with my alignment' which is a lot more reasonable than if he were town going along the lines of 'why do i have bad guys in my flavor if I'm town'. More likely the former because if he were town thinking what I just wrote (given what he said before), he wouldn't have asked about scum's flavor because he knew it wouldn't be alignment indicative.

too much mafia too little calvin & hobbes