NY 165: A Large Normal (Game Over!)

[Cephrir]

I suck at this game until I get some legitimate information (well, okay, I still suck after that too, but it helps), so... kinda.

I think that ability is more likely to be scum than town.

[Serene]

The claim is fake.

Rolecop is often a mafia role. It's pretty useless in the hands of town - one-shot rolecop is

crazy

useless for town.

[Zdenek]

Looks like everyone is so tired of this game, they're all voting Nero just to finish this day.

I'm voting him because I think he'll flip scum.

[BROseidon]

Reading from where I last posted because fuck it I’m skipping that middle part:

Calcifer still seems fine to me. Serene, what are the relevant posts that I skipped that make you think Calcifer is scum?

Dropping Nero from my townreads and moving him into the scumpile. This is fucking ridiculous. Cabd hydra is a solid townread now, though.

Letters being gone for so long makes me want to scumread the slot, and Stevie being gone strengthens my scumread on it. Cephrir makes me like the Doc slot a lot more, but not enough to shake the early scumread.

I like Ank’s 1752. Frustration seems natural and scum would have to fake that because the Nero/Serene shitstorm benefits scum.

Wow Serene makes an actual case. Woohoo something worth reading in this shitshow of a thread.

Holy fuck that wagon formed fast. Still not convinced on Shadi-town but the rest of the wagon seems fine.

Baby Spice why is Orc on your “would support to lynch” list? I can work out a reason for just about everyone else on there. Also, why is letters not on that list if you’re including lurkers?

Oh look you gave a weak explanation could you give one with specifics.

Serene don’t try to push MS he’s just being his wacky old townie self.

Okay that claim could easily a scum rolecop claiming town rolecop. I am fine with the Nero lynch.

TIP why would you unvote that is a shit claim.

VOTE: Nero

[Cephrir]

If Nero flips scum that unvote from TIP will look shady. I'm liking this lynch better than I did before the premature essentially-scum-claim.

[TheIrishPope]

My unvote came from a Town mindset
There's no scum motivation behind it

[Cephrir]

...unless Nero is your scumbuddy...

[TheIrishPope]

I'm still not understanding your point

[Rift Adrift]

If Nero flips scum that unvote from TIP will look shady. I'm liking this lynch better than I did before the premature essentially-scum-claim.

TiP's votes have been more reactive than a weathervane in a windstorm. This one's not substantively different.

[Calcifer]

If Nero flips scum that unvote from TIP will look shady. I'm liking this lynch better than I did before the premature essentially-scum-claim.

See, Cephrir. This is your problem. It's posts like this which keep Nacho from townreading ya, 'cause your logic here is entirely backwards.

If Nero flipped scum, that unvote from TIP would practically make him conftown. Scum when their scumbuddy is wagoned and clearly going down (1-shot rolecop is not a claim which will ever save a player) want the towncred. Scum when their scumbuddy is wagoned need to remain on the wagon in order to have any chance of earning that towncred. Thus, when their scumbuddy botches a claim (in this case, by claiming something which doesn't stand a realistic chance of saving him), they

push the wagon harder

, and don't jump off.

If Nero flipped town, you could maybe,

maybe

make the argument that TIP jumping off makes him scum for having instantly believed the claim when no sane townie would, but again, I quite frankly don't find that very likely.

[Cephrir]

Hm. Maybe. I don't know if I believe TIP is the type to think that far ahead. I'm not sure what me thinking about that wrong would have to do with my alignment, though.

[Nero]

repeat after me:

"If Nero flips town I promise to completely ignore the user Serene and his/her for the rest of the duration of this game."

[Nero]

The claim is fake.

Rolecop is often a mafia role. It's pretty useless in the hands of town - one-shot rolecop is

crazy

useless for town.

errr how is potentially finding a mafioso/clear useless?

just shut the fuck up

[Nero]

If Nero flips scum that unvote from TIP will look shady. I'm liking this lynch better than I did before the premature essentially-scum-claim.

See, Cephrir. This is your problem. It's posts like this which keep Nacho from townreading ya, 'cause your logic here is entirely backwards.

If Nero flipped scum, that unvote from TIP would practically make him conftown. Scum when their scumbuddy is wagoned and clearly going down (1-shot rolecop is not a claim which will ever save a player) want the towncred. Scum when their scumbuddy is wagoned need to remain on the wagon in order to have any chance of earning that towncred. Thus, when their scumbuddy botches a claim (in this case, by claiming something which doesn't stand a realistic chance of saving him), they

push the wagon harder

, and don't jump off.

If Nero flipped town, you could maybe,

maybe

make the argument that TIP jumping off makes him scum for having instantly believed the claim when no sane townie would, but again, I quite frankly don't find that very likely.

im flipping town you shit cunt and all your suppositions are trash. you're a terrible player.

[Cephrir]

rolecop generally does not do the things that you said

its best use is finding town prs

[Cephrir]

Okay seriously why haven't you been force replaced or modkilled

In what universe is this "courteous and respectful"

[Nero]

its not my fault that you're all horrendous mafia players.

[Cephrir]

regardless of whether that is true it is your fault that you're an asshole and should be banned from the site never mind this game

[Nero]

Just in: 21 year old mafiascum.net user Cephrir is horrified by someone telling him that he's bad.

[Nero]

you've sure lived a sheltered life, "asshole".

[Cephrir]

obviously what i'm upset about given that i have admitted to being a bad player in this thread

[Nero]

i sincerely apologise for putting you through such a traumatic experience on the internet.

[Serene]

im flipping town you shit cunt and all your suppositions are trash. you're a terrible player.

coming from someone who had a mental breakdown over being fossed in a game of forum mafia.

[Nero]

yeah, your breakdown was pretty unique in a plethora of ways.

[Nero]

also you're shit.