OGML did slip because he didn't consider the alternative explanation that JDoe might have vig'ed TF, and therefore actually had info about the NKs from a legitimate town perspective. He FRAMED JDoe and started to tunnel. I called OGML on it and he vanished.In post 1621, borkjerfkin wrote:I don't think OGML slipped; in fact I think (as several of us have said) that TF isn't even the mafia NK.
And where is the thought process assuming I am town? You're assuming I am scum and that's driving your thought processes. The motivation is there if town because I'm stating the obvious. TF and my other former head got into it, BAD. Someone killing him and then pressuring me for the kill is exactly what I would expect scum to do.In post 1620, Amrun wrote:I find it an unlikely line of thought to come from scum who knows Majiffy was the real scumkill, and very little motivation to fake.In post 1608, Sugar Cain wrote:Lets just pretend that TF is a vig kill, how does that make Titus less likely to be scum?In post 1595, Amrun wrote:But can everyone please address the point that if Trust Fund is a vig kill, Titus is unlikely to be scum, and if Trust fund is a scum kill, the opposite is true?
p-edit: Thor, NBH sk/vig thing is irrelevant to the game because I think, given the mechanic, an sk is silly. I think anyone else would conclude that too.
I got pulled away from the computer before posting this so probably a million posts.
p-edit 2: No, I'm not assuming your slot killed Trust Fund, Titus... Sigh.
If Majiffy was the scumkill AND your slot was scum, I don't think you would have shared the analysis about TF in thread, real or otherwise.
If Trust Fund was the kill AND your slot was scum, I think you'd be more likely to share this "analysis," because you have inside information.
In the latter case, you are not automatically scum, but your chances increase. In the former, I think it's unlikely that you are scum.
And where is the thought process assuming I am town? You're assuming I am scum and that's driving your thought processes. The motivation is there if town because I'm stating the obvious. TF and my other former head got into it, BAD. Someone killing him and then pressuring me for the kill is exactly what I would expect scum to do.[/quote]In post 1626, Titus wrote: In the latter case, you are not automatically scum, but your chances increase. In the former, I think it's unlikely that you are scum.
yes, I am aware of that. Whats that have to do with anything? You just said that I didn't have many opinions of Doe/Titus today and yet I'm having a back and forth and calling it scum so....yeah that makes no sense.In post 1612, Thor665 wrote:You are aware that I've not been, right?In post 1592, Sugar Cain wrote:You do know that I've been having a back and forth with Titus for awhile now, right?In post 1589, Thor665 wrote:Yesterday you had a lot of opinions about it, today...not so much.
Thor, this quote from Mollie is what you claim is OGML scumhunting. Do you have a response?In post 1625, No Brains Here wrote:OGML did slip because he didn't consider the alternative explanation that JDoe might have vig'ed TF, and therefore actually had info about the NKs from a legitimate town perspective. He FRAMED JDoe and started to tunnel. I called OGML on it and he vanished.In post 1621, borkjerfkin wrote:I don't think OGML slipped; in fact I think (as several of us have said) that TF isn't even the mafia NK.
He is scum and will eat delicious brain-soaked rope.
Oh, well I wasn't saying it to be a dick, it'll actually be productive if you dieIn post 1638, OhGodMyLife wrote:I hope I die tonight too, that was a major motivation for claiming
noIn post 1643, OhGodMyLife wrote:borkjerfkin is a strong candidate for scum too, in the (likely) event I'm wrong about at least one of my other reads. I don't really find Pitoli scummy anymore.
This confirms OGML is town and not SK before anyone tries to be annoyingIn post 847, OhGodMyLife wrote:Vote: Jon Doe
FoS: Sugar Cain, Mastin2, pitoli
I think I'll just channel Silent Mafia as a counterweight to the half a dozen players here dead set on having 1000 posts by the end of the game.