The Walking Dead Mafia! ( Game Over )

[ActionDan]

why did you shoot Majiffy again?

[sangres]

for the record OGML is town and we're not lynching him but he seriously, seriously, SERIOUSLY needs a leashing after we die. be sure to hold him to that because otherwise the mafia is leaving him alive.

[OhGodMyLife]

why did you shoot Majiffy again?

My criteria were 1) who has posted too fucking much already and 2) which of these people seems the scummiest

[OhGodMyLife]

If I could have rat-a-tat-tat machine gunned every person with more than 50 day one posts I would have

[sangres]

Venmar: VC is incorrect.

[MattP]

VOTE: Sangres

Wow asking me what the fuck I'm doing a century after that ordeal ended is sooooo sincere!

[sangres]

mett i'm being shot tonight plz be logical ty ;]

[OhGodMyLife]

Matt I'm going to shoot Sangres tonight vote for Titus if you want to be helpful.

If Sangres doesn't die it's because I was right about Milton, Mafia Doctor being in this setup.

[OhGodMyLife]

I do have alternates in mind if I feel the cosmos telling me Sangres got a doc protect

[Thor665]

Why do you have a town read on him and disagree with me being willing to lynch him?

I don't like lynching people I don't have an opinion on because it's a crapshoot. I enjoy lynching players who I have a scumread on most of all and it's really hard to give up that feeling for someone who has not posted.

My method lacks the strategic hole your method has.
Just saying.

My third category is "not begging for death quite so earnestly as others", which I'm sure is a category you can understand and get behind.

That's called 'degree of willingness to lynch'

I think Elli is town.

I agree!

[OhGodMyLife]

Actually, I'm willing to lynch Sangres and shoot Titus instead.

Unvote, Vote: Sangres

[Thor665]

Reading up on this Merle character - he sounds more pro-town than traitor to me.

Season 3

NBH doesn't include the finale where apparently he does quite good for the group, is mourned by his brother, and basically is a solid guy all around - meaning his character arc was traitor --> loyalist, not the other way around.

I can reads a wiki, ladies.

@OGML - why did you shoot Majiffy?
I'm asking for the second time now.
Other people asked as well.

[MattP]

We're more likely to get a Titus lynch through

VOTE: Titus

[Thor665]

Why is it the only time a hot wagon formed on someone I thought was scum I was asleep?

[OhGodMyLife]

Thor:

why did you shoot Majiffy again?

My criteria were 1) who has posted too fucking much already and 2) which of these people seems the scummiest

Unvote, Vote: Titus

[Thor665]

*sigh*

Okay - WHY did he seem scummiest to you of the people who had posted so much?

[sangres]

PV, mastin2, AJ, Ellibereth, GiF.

PV: Hasn't posted shit this game, will not lynch him because his lurking has been too extreme to actually be alignment-indicative. If he doesn't do anything today, would love to see bullets or zombies on him tomorrow.

mastin2: I actually think that I'm reading mastin as leaning town at the moment. The way that he framed his approach to this game (cheesy joke in every post, we must focus on not lynching town as opposed to lynching scum) doesn't leave him a lot of room to work with since he can't rescind on those strong townreads without catching serious, serious issues. That being said, I don't really like the strong townread on me without actually working with me, but that more of a minor worry that will be smoothed out as mastin eases himself into the game.

AJ: AJ usually feels out of step in large games, so I'm mostly giving him room and letting him work. I generally like his contributions, and his response to Sugar Cain is #992 waas matter-of-fact and in a townie type of way.

Elli: Usually it's not that difficult to fake something that looks vaguely like contribution, so lazy Elli is usually town Elli. What I don't feel comfortable about in this slot is how laziness pretty much went to trolling the game and "man i'm so lost can't do anything".

GiF: GiF's been pretty lazy lately, so low content and that sort of thing is something to be expected. I kind of like his #2023 for promising the huge towniness and then disappearing immediately after; it feels like he knows he's been slacking and tries to throw a bunch of time into at once, but the cycle repeats itself and he disappears yet again.

I choose Ellibereth.

Vote: Ellibereth

[OhGodMyLife]

*sigh*

Okay - WHY did he seem scummiest to you of the people who had posted so much?

Pretty much purely gut.

[Sugar Cain]

In post 1980, Toogeloo wrote:What I don't understand is how Michonne is a vig that "herds" Walkers. For one, if she is a Vig, why wouldn't she just use her Katana?

oh my god what is this shit

So you don't think that the roles make sense in the context of the show?

Also, in 2030 you were agreeing that Eli was town but you later voted him...what made you change your mind.

[Titus]

VOTE: OMGL

Brain's flavor analysis is persuasive and the so called vig is deliberately shooting active players. Shooting n1should be reserved for lurkers or people who are known scum. Notice OMGL never said why Majiffy was scummy just merely he was the scummiest active player.

[MattP]

VOTE: OMGL

Brain's flavor analysis is persuasive and the so called vig is deliberately shooting active players. Shooting n1should be reserved for lurkers or people who are known scum. Notice OMGL never said why Majiffy was scummy just merely he was the scummiest active player.

omg

[sangres]

So you don't think that the roles make sense in the context of the show?

setup*
I don't care about flavor shit and never will. I do think it's likelier that OGML is town after his recent interaction with us, though.

Also, in 2030 you were agreeing that Eli was town but you later voted him...what made you change your mind.

I'm clearing him for stupid reasons. I really, really, really want him to be town but if he's going to abandon me like this then he probably isn't.

[Titus]

VOTE: OMGL

Brain's flavor analysis is persuasive and the so called vig is deliberately shooting active players. Shooting n1should be reserved for lurkers or people who are known scum. Notice OMGL never said why Majiffy was scummy just merely he was the scummiest active player.

omg

Care to expand?

[MattP]

No ur just scum

[Aj The Epic]

no Matt, this is scum. Amrun, didja ever read my Titus/AJ connection?

Why was leaving out AJ in particular so damning?

'cause I think buddies like to avoid mentioning each other and its a logical disconnect.

Seriously, you have four to five flaws here.

1. You're underestimating my ability to play scum
2. You're using confirmation bias on yourself because I have had you as scum all day and been very vocal about it.
3. That wasn't really a legitimate connection. I voted for JD because I thought the 5 post in a row a scum tell and OMGUS on OGML's calling flavor analysis a scum tell.
4. I've posted a very low amount since that incident and am admittedly more or less forgettable.
5. That was a terrible bus if it was one, and an even worse reaction.

On the mollie/OGML issue: I personally still have both as town. Mollie's mechanic makes perfect sense, but I don't believe herder to be alignment indicative. As of right now, though, it mine as well be a clear because she did take out a scum with it.