Newbie 1391 - Game Over - FINALLY!!!

[Karnage]

Maybe we could Lynch Nacho today. Allow me to explain:

We Lynch Nacho today. Here's how we proceed if he flips town:
Champ jailkeeps me(considering everyone has doubts about me)

If there is no nightkill, we have 5 people left tomorrow and you all Lynch me.
Champ will likely die next and Flay/Karnage/Generic play lylo

If there is a nightkill, I will be confirmed town and we'll lynch out of Generic/Flay/Karnage tomorrow.


This will get rid of Nacho/me at lylo. So in case on of you is lying, the odds are better.


Did I Miss something or does this make sense?

Yeah you missed something. If we lynch nacho and he isn't scum it means mafia is a Roleblocker and could block champ so he couldn't JK you. So you can't be cleared tomorrow.

I think I'm coming around to lynching Stubbs today and nacho tomorrow if necessary.

[Mr. Flay]

3.5 days to go until deadline. Nacho may or may not be abdicating his kingship, but we should decide if our backup lynch really is Stubbs, or what. Also everybody taking stances will help if we go to LyLo.

[champinoman]

but we should decide if our backup lynch really is Stubbs, or what.

Also everybody taking stances will help if we go to LyLo.

I agree. Everyone should make their views know prior to this lynch.

Mine is irrelevant but I am happy with the Stubbs lynch. I am less certain of Generic being town though after his reaction throughout this day. Just not sitting well.

[Mr. Flay]

I'm still fine with Generic. I think his behavior today mirrors my own, i.e frustration at the game, not at his chances as scum diminishing. *shrug*

Bydefault that would Karnage down as my second (after Nacho of course), but Miss Stranger was sort of a non-entity for non-game reasons there...

[StubbsKVM]

If it's not Nacho, I'm thinking Generic.

[Mr. Flay]

Bydefault that would Karnage down as my second

Wow, typing fail.

"By default, that would make put Karnage down as my second" (after Stubbs and Nacho)

[champinoman]

Bydefault that would Karnage down as my second

Wow, typing fail.

"By default, that would make put Karnage down as my second" (after Stubbs and Nacho)

Have a 3rd try? lol.

So you believe Generic is more town than Karnage?


On a side note, over 3 days now since Nacho's last post.

[Generic]

My order taking nacho out is Stubbs, flay and then karnage.

I must point out flay is far townier than karnage in this but I cannot ignore the predecessors. Flay may be simply a bloody good mafia player.

[StubbsKVM]

My order taking nacho out is Stubbs, flay and then karnage.

I must point out flay is far townier than karnage in this but I cannot ignore the predecessors.

Flay may be simply a bloody good mafia player.

This is what worries me too.

[Generic]

Bear in mind also it was gen wolf who tried to introduce the idea mafia had no killed twice and we should no lynch back... Felt at the the time like he wanted to get back to the night phase to aim elsewhere this time...

But my top two remain my top two, that's my lylo option.

[StubbsKVM]

prod on Nacho?

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Prodding Nacho.

Vote Count 4.5

StubbsKVM - 2 (Generic, Mr. Flay)

Not Voting - 4 (champinoman, Karnage, Nachomamma8, StubbsKVM)

4 to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2013-08-11 07:00:00)

[/b].

[Mr. Flay]

I must point out flay is far townier than karnage in this but I cannot ignore the predecessors.

I'm not ignoring that, I just can't do anything to 'argue' against it. *shrug*

[Mr. Flay]

Also, Nacho just replaced into ANOTHER GAME. JFC.

[Mr. Flay]

Post or Perish.

UNVOTE: StubbsKVM
VOTE: Nachomamma8

[Nachomamma8]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_RWtdm81WU

enjoy this music while I catch up!

[Nachomamma8]

In general/meta, or in this game specifically?

This game specifically.

It's pure buddying. "I believe in you Nacho! You can do it Nacho! As long as you're not going to lynch me..." And he does it again in 692.

He is buddying, but I think that I've made it pretty clear that Stubbs isn't even in my top 3 and thus probably won't be lynching him, so it's not really necessary for him to pull something like that at this point; it's only necessary for him to keep doing what he's doing. I also haven't really had any troubles in reading him (yet), so that type of trust in me based on our past is pretty consistent.

I think if scumnacho thought he would be given the lynch without question he would remove me, because you are scummier looking and he can try and talk his way out of the lynch the next day.

Flay, this is Generic pulling the exact same "lynching me is a scumtell" that you accused Stubbs of earlier, whereas I think this one is a bit more clearcut.

If generic is scum, why would he have hammered antagon so quick at the end of day 1?

It was town because it didn't allow for counterclaims. It wasn't town enough where Generic is cleared.

[Nachomamma8]

Vote: Generic

Sorry for taking so long in this; I don't really feel confident in this vote at all but as far as finding scum elsewhere, I don't see anything but this. Flay has a very small outside chance of being scum if this doesn't yield fruit but I don't really see scum anywhere else.

[Mr. Flay]

UNVOTE: nachoslacker8

[Generic]

Well there you go guys, that's his second choice.

Make sure if noone dies toNight he is lynched without hesitation toMorrow.

Stubbs is my secondary, but remember if its flay or karnage and they win you have nacho to thank for our loss. Not even for choosing me for you all to lynch, but for ignoring the game after requesting the two lynches.
No thought has gone into this choice, so unless he is scum I place any potential loss on his shoulders.

My vote will not be moving, goodbye and good luck champ and the rest of the town.

[Nachomamma8]

Stubbs is my secondary, but remember if its flay or karnage and they win you have nacho to thank for our loss. Not even for choosing me for you all to lynch, but for ignoring the game after requesting the two lynches.
No thought has gone into this choice, so unless he is scum I place any potential loss on his shoulders.

i agree that the loss would fall on my shoulders
but if i actually did manage to catch you out then i'm riding home from this win on a parade wagon and i'm taking pictures.

[champinoman]

I'm completely shocked and in disbelief that Nacho voted for Generic. [/sarcasm]

VOTE: Generic

We might as well get a move on. No need to drag this out considering Nacho probably wont post again with only 2.5 days left until deadline based on previous record.

[StubbsKVM]

VOTE: Generic

[Mr. Flay]

Will not vote Generic except to avoid a NL. Karnage can have the hammer.

(this is not scummy, because if I'm wrong, we win)

[Generic]

At least my first mislynch on your site was a tactical lynch whereby it appears only the mafia player believes I'm gonna flip scum