The Walking Dead Mafia! ( Game Over )

[Titus]

Ok, I'll hold my reservations on meta judgment until then. Also, I'm going out of my way to really look at this meta since a lot of people disagree with me. Normally, my belief is meta has little value since the player is aware of it.

[sangres]

Am I the only person who caught what this vote was about?

I saw no logic in it and dismissed it as flail.

I didn't see it as flail, given who posted it.

Interesting to note, however: Neither of you had any part in the discussion. May I ask how you came across the discussion?

I read way more than I post in the mafia discussion forum. In that particular instance, the topic was of interest to me because about that time I was playing an ungodly long newbie game and someone replaced into it at the start of day 2. He asked for a summary and I did a sort of conversational mode Q&A rather than a wall. It turned out to be a good way for us both to develop reads. There may be something to Mara's summary tell, but it's more nuanced than summary = scummy. The fact that it was the summary with the flowery turns of phrase and narrative style that pinged for her in this game probably says something about how she thinks about the tell, herself.

[Thor665]

Mostly yeah. Did those links have any influence on your read?

I'd need to go look at a larger sample size to see if I felt it held true - I also am not fond of a hydra being part of the example set.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go
Scum Nero

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go
Town Nero

I'm not sure I'm buying this as a reliable tell.

[Ellibereth]

heyro catching up now~

[Desperado]

Mostly yeah. Did those links have any influence on your read?

I'd need to go look at a larger sample size to see if I felt it held true - I also am not fond of a hydra being part of the example set.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go
Scum Nero

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go
Town Nero

I'm not sure I'm buying this as a reliable tell.

It's not an end all be all meta read. There is a fundamental disconnect between what Titus is seeing and what Sangres/Mastin/myself are seeing re: Nero, and I thought an example of his play might help bridge the gap.

[Desperado]

Mostly yeah. Did those links have any influence on your read?

I'd need to go look at a larger sample size to see if I felt it held true - I also am not fond of a hydra being part of the example set.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go
Scum Nero

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go
Town Nero

I'm not sure I'm buying this as a reliable tell.

It's not an end all be all meta read. There is a fundamental disconnect between what Titus is seeing and what Sangres/Mastin/myself are seeing re: Nero, and I thought an example of his play might help bridge the gap.

[ActionDan]

Mastin, precisely how much did you meta me? Did you look at both my completed scum games + the QTs?

[Titus]

Can y'all give me something, other than meta, that suggests SC is town?

[Amrun]

Titus, how about you make your own decision about whether or not rc is town?

[RedCoyote]

Alright, folks. I am officially caught up in everything else and ready for an exciting night of Walking Dead Mafia reading.

[Toogeloo]

I hope we see walls of insightful reads that you are known for as well!

[Titus]

Titus, how about you make your own decision about whether or not rc is town?

You are seriously not reading the thread if you think I haven't made a decision about SC being town or not. I think he's scum I'm just giving the people who believe him to be town an opportunity to be fully heard.

[No Brains Here]

heyro catching up now~

Lies!

Eat brainz

VOTE: Ellibereth

[Amrun]

I misread that as RC (and if you'll notice, that's what I actually said).

SC is strangercoug. Call them sugar or something. >.>

[TheIrishPope]

L-3 mkay

[TheIrishPope]

D1 and D2 transitioned with nothing out of the ordinary
Elli is a fine lynch today I guess

[Titus]

I misread that as RC (and if you'll notice, that's what I actually said).

SC is strangercoug. Call them sugar or something. >.>

Why did you mean RC? I figured you made a typo and meant SC.

As for RC, I'd rather see more from him before making up my mind. Why the sudden interest in RC? and why ask your scum read?

[No Brains Here]

Amrun, ActionDan: please bus Elli.

[No Brains Here]

D1 and D2 transitioned with nothing out of the ordinary
Elli is a fine lynch today I guess

[TheIrishPope]

wut

[Titus]

Amrun, ActionDan: please bus Elli.

I can still get on this train if Eli doesn't contribute when he gets back. If he still thinks nothing interesting has happened, he deserves a lynch.

[No Brains Here]

Which three of you below will form the hammer?

TheIrishPope
RedCoyote
Amrun
Aj the Epic
Mattp
ActionDan
Sugar Cain
Mastin2
Titus
OhGodMyLife
Metal Sonic

[Amrun]

Titus: wtf are you smoking? I didn't ask you anything. It's not a "sudden interest" in RC. I READ IT as RC.

DGB:

Okay.

VOTE: elli

[MattP]

ono i have no idea whats going on

ill be free tomorrow night but i guess you dont have to wait for me

[No Brains Here]

I can still get on this train if Eli doesn't contribute when he gets back.

He said he's catching up now and he vanished. That's a rock-hard scum tell and he will hang for it. You will be forgiven for not waiting for a fakeclaim on this one.