Mini 1482: Castle - A Mafia Murder So Vile (GAME OVER)

[Natirasha]

I agree they killed Wisdom because he was seeing the right targets.

[Sweet Pertayter]

Yeah I don't think potato is scum. I just think mara is not thinking.

Come again?

[Natirasha]

Yeah I don't think potato is scum. I just think mara is not thinking.

Come again?

Your posts today have expressed a feeling of not understanding what is going on.

[Desperado]

Yeah I don't think potato is scum. I just think mara is not thinking.

Come again?

Your posts today have expressed a feeling of not

understanding what is going on.

seeing it my way.

FTFY

[Mantisdreamz]

oh desp

[Mantisdreamz]

you silly scum

[Desperado]

It's true. Nat is saying Mara isn't reading because she has a different perspective. It's really scummy.

[Sweet Pertayter]

I am reading?

and I am trying to clarify what exactly happened

So far, what I have gotten is that Desp tracked Mantis, and all I'm reading is WIFOM'ic shit on why Desperado is scum when it is obvious that he isn't given the timing of his claim

[Natirasha]

Do you think I'm scum then?

[Natirasha]

Follow up questions: Why is his claim timing make sense?
Why did he hammer?
If Desperado had not claimed tracker, what would you think?

[Desperado]

Why are you asking Mara a question I already answered?

[Natirasha]

This question is not about what you think your motivations are, it's about what she thinks your motivations are.

[waynegg]

and you were making sense

Don't worry, I will again.

then please stop this desp & i are scum together.
it's making me depressed with this game

did you get a hold of serra's whiskey as well?

If only.

But I am halfway there. This is me now

Town
Me
Nat
Bert
P_A

Scum
Desp

Null
Manti
FG
Pertayter

[Desperado]

...wayne you realize 2/3 of your nulls are scum right? And if you think Nat is town, that means you think tayter is town. Which means you think its me, Mantis, and FakeGod. What's with that bullshit list?

[Mantisdreamz]

It's true. Nat is saying Mara isn't reading because she has a different perspective. It's really scummy.

you realize i know you're scum right?

[Mantisdreamz]

waynegg , why PA as town?

[waynegg]

Desperado is scum when it is obvious that he isn't given the timing of his claim

Please act like I'm a preschooler and point me to where I'm wrong

1 no scum has flipped in this game (SK doesn't count for these purposes)

2 with a m/l today, we're probably in mylo tomorrow still without a scum flip

3 scummotivation is high to push a m/l, probably more today than any other point in the game

4 in the eventuality town catch on to the play, Desp would be the best choice to do this push, because
a) he already has plenty of suspicion on his slot
b) with how little he's posted, it would be safe to assume few connections could be drawn if he flips scum

5) quicklynch is a classic scum tactic

6) tracker doesn't give reliable info on what action a tracked player has taken

7) in general, tracker is all but impossible to disprove without a flip so its a low risk play for scum to make

For the life of me, I CAN'T FIND ANY TOWN MOTIVATION TO HIS PLAY

Pedit. Of course I do, but until I'm sure which I won't name them. Of course, just lynching the list would end in town win.

[waynegg]

I'm glad someone finally asked

***penguin_alien*** ~ Claimed Jenny Shaw

Spoiler:

465 given Slimer's town flip, scum wouldn't take
this line of questioning. Solid town.
1141 owns thread so much with this post
1151 if I could make love to this post, I would

Whether you've played with P_A or not, if you analyze his posts based on the motivation behind them (working within himself and in a limited capacity with others to sort out scum vs. self preservation when facing heat and finger pointing) he's clearly town. This theme has continued throughout the game with him and it would take some really major development for me to consider touching this slot.

Then there's the high probability that Jenny Shaw wouldn't have been claimed right after Jordan Shaw if it were a fake claim because it would be too obvious.

[waynegg]

Is she pushing Wisdom? Yes. Is her point of view off? No. Those are all very valid reasons to suspect him of being scummy. The posts came off genuine and like they were her true beliefs at the time.

[waynegg]

She was the only player who voiced what I was thinking for the most part while I did my read troughs which made her sound even more natural.

[waynegg]

Left Serra off the nulls :/

[Sweet Pertayter]

example of that?

because I don't see it

I also can't see the rationale of scumdesp coming out like the way he has, it looks alot like he thinks he actually did catch scum

I find it weird that there is a tracker and a cop in the game, and I played a normal game where I faked-cop but you aren't an optimal lynch either until later on.

I do find it wierd that you are still alive though

Pedit: I don't think it's that out of the question, no

[Natirasha]

Bert, can you find me a gif of the monks from Monty Python and the Holy Grail smacking in the head.

[Sweet Pertayter]

I think a tracker and a cop in a single game is weird, but I don't find it out of the question

[Natirasha]

Have you talked with Om at all?