Mini 1486: Fruit Basket Mafia (Game Over)

[zMuffinMan]

if we lynch VA and he flips town, who are you going to want to lynch tomorrow?

[Kid A]

i think this va wagon stinks of mislynch and you should all vote don johnson

[mnemonicdevice]

Starting to like the don_johnson wagon.

[Slandaar]

MD could actually be scum.

[Slandaar]

@lucky
Yes.


Killing off big liabilities to town like Guyett isn't a bad start for us.

giffy that hurt

But if you really really want to lynch Saki, I'll bite.

^ lolscum


so we have beast claiming scum
and brian softclaiming scum

and i'm at l-1 why?

UNVOTE:
VOTE: beast
self-hammering in 24 hours if beast isn't lynched by then

So, who believes this is the same VA we saw here?

Who believes someone who understands these things thinks Peabody is scum for the reasons stated by VA?

VA is scum.

VOTE: VA

Muffin/MD are the likely buddies.

[Slandaar]

I don't recall peabody claiming his investigation D2. He claimed it D3, and said he investigated it N1. So D2 we spent without a townie with clear and N2 he risked himself dying without claiming his investigate

so
he's scum?
VOTE: peabody

this is what I am talking about its playing dumb and trying to fake towntell.

[zMuffinMan]

why do you think desp is town?

[don_johnson]

The first rule of Fight Club is: you do not talk about Fight Club. The second rule of Fight Club is: you DO NOT talk about Fight Club!

[T S O]

Mmmm, VA doesn't look great atm.

There's one thing I have to check.

[Slandaar]

why do you think desp is town?

The first rule of Fight Club is: you do not talk about Fight Club. The second rule of Fight Club is: you DO NOT talk about Fight Club!

Sorry Muffin the rules are the rules!

I don't particularly think hes town but If he were scum you would think he would push lynches which are in the stratosphere of remotely viable especially assuming VA is scum which he is (or Desp could bus again).

So, assuming VA is scum its unlikely Desp is and thus we shall lynch VA because the case is infinitely stronger.

For example; Promised content and not deliver, active lurking, not matching up to townmeta, posting really bad things when we can see as town VA is not

that

bad. To make the case he did on Peabody you have to be in like your first ever game and we know VA is an alt because no newbies games and the posts I have shown, soooooooooo lets lynch VA.

And lets analyse faketown tell more? it doesn't work because he says he read Day 2, which he can't have done to miss the cop claim and the reason why Buffy wagon died; we can assume he did in fact know of the claim (because he lied about readin the day)

I don't recall peabody claiming his investigation D2. He claimed it D3, and said he investigated it N1. So D2 we spent without a townie with clear and N2 he risked himself dying without claiming his investigate

so
he's scum?
VOTE: peabody

Honestly, just think about it this is literally terrible and makes no sense. Do you want to see town VA thoughtprocess? lets see here;

remember when I said Guyett was a huge liability?
yeah that's pretty much what I meant

fyi morph the cat is a hydra of Cabd and fferyllt so Cabd's still here, just being a lurker.

I was waiting to see if Cabd/ffery will try to pull off lynches solely based off meta
since that's indicative of scum
and they didn't disappoint
VOTE: morph the cat

you guys look like you're trying really hard not to play to scummeta btw

VA is obviously an alt, VA is also somewhat clever as shown above. Waiting to see if someone does something is actually quite advanced laying traps for scum, I don't believe for a second anyone who does that thinks a claimed 1shot cop is scum because they didn't claim D2.

NOTE: Morph the cat is scum (obviously) you don't even need to read any other posts in the game to know it when you read the above.

Enjoy your day everyone.

[zMuffinMan]

yeah but considering who VA's alt is, all the points you mentioned are null to me at best. VA's activity has been lacking site-wide, and i

can

imagine VA posting in this way as town.

[Slandaar]

I don't know who hes an alt of but I have judged his competancy and it doesn't match with his peabody vote.

On another note, my vote is staying on medic; the more I think about it, I don't like the "was out of town" excuse in a post that said nothing but that. It feels like a prod-dodge post from a lurker, and his lack of attempt at scum hunting/getting involved makes me think he could be scum.

/confirm Sorry it took a while I was out of town.

I generally dislike when people post to apologize for not posting, without saying anything more.

So Formerfish you don't like that I posted a confirm and apologized that it took me a couple of days to do so do to being out of town. Not exactly sure what you want me to say in that situation and you trying to find something in a new player who is still getting his feet wet in this game and saying you generally dislike people who do that seems kinda short sighted to me.

I did point it out before but this is a huge associative tell because he doesn't mention ASP only Fish.

[zMuffinMan]

yeah the associative tells between pdmedic and ASP and the fact i'm null on VA overall is why i'd be willing to compromise on a VA lynch, but it's not preferred.

what do you think of desp calling the thing you think is a fake town tell genuine? because that is why he's not voting VA at the moment. i don't really agree with your analysis of desp (other than because i'm scum reading him) because he's basically committed to calling VA town, and the other option (jumping on VA immediately) would have just left him open to criticism for attacking lynchbait if VA actually is town. the other reason i don't agree with your analysis is that he's not really doing anything with his vote right now, but he was more than happy to criticise me for not "pushing" my vote on him much. *shrug*

[Peabody]

Meh. I like the VA case.

But I like the Desp case.

I'll compromise if needed.

And Elyse, it's not normal to write a case on a person you don't plan on voting. That's what the problem is.

[Viera Assassin]

wait wait wait
i get muffin on my side for a change?
coool

[Kid A]

VOTE: don_johnson

[Elyse]

Meh. I like the VA case.

But I like the Desp case.

I'll compromise if needed.

And Elyse, it's not normal to write a case on a person you don't plan on voting. That's what the problem is.

I do plan on voting for him. He' my number 2 scumread.

[don_johnson]

VOTE: don_johnson

I thought we were friends.

[don_johnson]

check out Kid A's iso and tell me he doesn't fit for number three.

[Elyse]

He doesn't fit for number 3.

[don_johnson]

why not?

[mnemonicdevice]

Well for one, there can't be three more scum. Don, I haven't heard your ideas; Who is scum if VA isn't.

[don_johnson]

maybe you misunderstood:

VA, ASP, Kid A

^^ scum team.

you, mnem, muffin, or Elyse would be my guess. but I don't think Elyse is scum. and I don't think muffin is scum. so you would be my first choice off that list.

if VA was town, no one here would have any reason to push a counterwagon. there is nothing obvtown about VA/pdmedic enough to seriously stall that wagon. and there is nothing scummy enough about anyone else to stall that wagon.

Elyse: why not?

[mnemonicdevice]

Okay then.

[zMuffinMan]

i get muffin on my side for a change?

no, not really. you should probably do something other than fluff post if you're town.

check out Kid A's iso and tell me he doesn't fit for number three.

i'd rather you tell me why he

does

fit.