Newbie 1425 Part Deux -- Game Over

[Nobody Special]

Wisdom, Vanilla Townie,

has been shot.

Day Three begins now.

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-11-23 06:14:05)

[RayFrost]

Vote: Malakittens

I'm feeling a lot better about this than a vote on cats. I did some thinking and soul searching over the night phase, and I get the feeling that cats is too genuine to be scum.

Lynch this for great justice.

[Smudger]

Based on what Ray?

[RayFrost]

PoE mostly

[Smudger]

So Cats is good by PoE, who besides Mal is not? and do share how your process has got to this point?

[RayFrost]

I said why I feel cats is good. It's a feeling of sincerity in his posting style. I am really really good at telling when people are sincere in certain circumstances. Like when someone's efforts are pretty clearly laid out and I can feel the sweat on their brow while reading. Am I weird for being able to do this? Maybe. But I trust the feeling when I get it.

Mala was scummy before, cats was scummy before, I read back over and now feel cats is more likely to be town than scum, leaving mala as the primary choice.

This is given that you're town read to me, arc is town read to me, and I'm obviously town to me.

So yeah.

[Smudger]

but there is more than one scum left Ray is there not? so who is scum 2?

[Malakittens]

but there is more than one scum left Ray is there not? so who is scum 2?

No, there's only two scum in a newbie game.

Man I can't tell if this is actually a genuine town slip.

;-; Ray makes me sad and so does the Wisdom kill. It's what I totally expect a skilled mafia player to do in order to take me down. I can see Ray going "My bad" after I'm lynched and flip town.

[Smudger]

is there I thought there were 3, don't ask me why, I have played this set up several times….. bad mistake on my part

[Smudger]

ok so Mal is scum Ray, I don't agree I still think it is between you and Cats…. however I will go reread.

[RayFrost]

but there is more than one scum left Ray is there not? so who is scum 2?

No, there's only two scum in a newbie game.

Man I can't tell if this is actually a genuine town slip.

;-; Ray makes me sad and so does the Wisdom kill. It's what I totally expect a skilled mafia player to do in order to take me down. I can see Ray going "My bad" after I'm lynched and flip town.

So basically "ray is calling me scum, but he's such a good scum player he would kill someone who wanted to lynch me and then push my lynch with amazingly well thought out cases and logic that I could buy ray scum"

Are you saying you think I'm scum or not? All I get out of this is a very weak snipey as hell discredit attempt. Which really doesn't help your case here.

Now. If you don't think I'm scum, who

is

?

[Smudger]

have now read Cats, Mala and Ray.

Cats does come over to me more town than Mala/ER, I still have doubts about Ray but they are now not that strong, so right now my vote will be on Mala.

VOTE: Malakittens

[RayFrost]

That puts mala at l-1.

Just making sure everyone's aware.

[Nobody Special]

Votecount 3.01

L-1 Malakittens - 2 - RayFrost, Smudger

Not Voting: ObsessedWithCats, Malakittens, ArcAngel9

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-11-23 06:14:05)

[Malakittens]

but there is more than one scum left Ray is there not? so who is scum 2?

No, there's only two scum in a newbie game.

Man I can't tell if this is actually a genuine town slip.

;-; Ray makes me sad and so does the Wisdom kill. It's what I totally expect a skilled mafia player to do in order to take me down. I can see Ray going "My bad" after I'm lynched and flip town.

So basically "ray is calling me scum, but he's such a good scum player he would kill someone who wanted to lynch me and then push my lynch with amazingly well thought out cases and logic that I could buy ray scum"

Are you saying you think I'm scum or not? All I get out of this is a very weak snipey as hell discredit attempt. Which really doesn't help your case here.

Now. If you don't think I'm scum, who

is

?

Thinking its either cats or you as scum. Sorta thinking its you.

AA or cats hasn't checked in since Day has opened. Sadly aa has been posting elsewhere, but still her meta leans towards her town side.

I can see either one of those who haven't checked in accidentally quick hammering.

[RayFrost]

And why do you think it's me, kind lady?

[Smudger]

If it will make you more comfortable Malakittens I will remove my vote, for now, but I intend currently to replace it. But I would point out that there is another reason you have not been hammered, you are the surviving Mafia

[Smudger]

UNVOTE:

[RayFrost]

I think the most significant reason she hasn't been hammered is that the other two people in this game aren't even here yet.

Like... yeah. And besides, hammering super early would be a bad move even if they

were

here. Discussion is good.

[Malakittens]

If it will make you more comfortable Malakittens I will remove my vote, for now, but I intend currently to replace it. But I would point out that there is another reason you have not been hammered, you are the surviving Mafia

... Or it's because two people haven't checked in since Day started.. I really, really hate how you are making an assumption especially 'omg you're the final mafia because you haven't been hammered' when only 3/5 people posted. You could have had a valid reason there if everyone posted, but not when all of them have not. I'm not going to self vote so with only three of us present that's the only way I'd currently have been hammered.

I don't like the fact you jumped from oh she's town to pleasing ray and voting me.

It's kinda just bs atm.

Ray it's basically the same reason you're voting me why I suspect you and cats, it's PoE.

[RayFrost]

A respectable enough reason, I suppose.

But why me over cats?

I mean, I'm the most likely to get lynched in this upcoming game day if you flip town, so yah might as well lay out reasons now to help people know why you think it should happen.

[Malakittens]

A respectable enough reason, I suppose.

But why me over cats?

I mean, I'm the most likely to get lynched in this upcoming game day if you flip town, so yah might as well lay out reasons now to help people know why you think it should happen.

More due to your overly confident attitude right now. This post shows it too.

You're ultimately convinced that I'm the lynch for today. You're trying to lead the town by throwing my lynch down then you're assuming that you'll be the lynch for tomorow.

Once I flip and then you're in LyLo you'll try to discredit anything I were to write at the moment.

[RayFrost]

Well, if I'm lynched today, then your reasons were good enough to change things. The comment about if you flip town I'm the next most likely is actually less to do with you and more to do with the other players.

I'll try to discredit anything you write because it's part of my job to defend myself. Might as well write what you have to say. After all, you need to convince the rest of the town that I'm scum, not me.

[Smudger]

Malakittens, its not BS at all. I re read your ISO, ERs, Rays and Cats, those attributed to you in whatever guise you use. thus my change of vote, I however remain suspicious of Ray but then he was key in the previous lynch of NS IMO.

ok they have not posted, so what. as for my "you are the final Mafia" statement, please don't belittle me or yourself, its a fair observation and where did I say you were town? the only direct statement I make about a read on you is this

Evil Regals’ play began by giving me a null read, there is nothing there to be honest, in fact not much at all, maybe D2 will see more interaction, right now I am cautious of Evil but her actions later on in D1, see below concerning RM hammer, have convinced me to grant the benefit of the doubt

[ObsessedWithCats]

I'm sorry I've not been posting people, I'm ill and suddenly very busy. I'll do my best to give some actual input this evening.