The Fall of Gondolin Mafia: Game Over (The Tale of Gondolin)

[Natirasha]

Nati. If you say this is closer to your town meta, please link me to ypur most tecently finished town & scum games.

Thankfully, I am very meticulous in keeping my wiki updated! The bottom games are the most recent.

[Desperado]

@ Shadoweh: I wasn't just using one game. There were other things in your uPick play that weren't materializing here either. They still aren't.

@ Albert: Still waiting for you to explain your Dan read.

@ Tierce: Righteously indignant town Tierce is my favorite Tierce. I don't agree with your Jacob push; who else is scum?

[Shadoweh]

I'll take that as a compliment seeing as my Upick play was really awful. You're going to have to do better then ambiguous things. Is it because I'm not threatening to set people on fire enough? I didn't bring a gas can to Middle Earth..

[PeregrineV]

2. JacobSavage - Postcount: 6. I honestly didn't realize he'd posted before Scummy Butt: The Buttening. Not really much to go on, instead of explaining townreads please explain which of your fourteen 'scumreads' you think is the scummiest and why, possibly with a vote even, which you are not doing and should.
4. Aegor - I didn't like post 141 as an entry post, it felt like throwing a bunch of things out to see what sticks, plus what I said earlier about his views on Esp. Also not sure what brachylogy means, but if it means empty voting you're basically voting ABR for being ABR, he always does that as far as I've seen? I don't think you'd know that though. Conversation with Sirdan is sensical but you haven't actually mentioned anything about who you think is scum, so not really much to go on. Please explain which of the sixteen people who isn't yourself or ABR you also think are scummy and why. I'm preparing to copy/paste saying that alot!
5. Natirasha - I really want to like your posts but I think it's because you're posting like ActionDan in a non-caring kind of way. You're not Dan thhough so it's weird. I expected you to be more.. cheerful I guess? You were more wordy in the quicktopic, I think. I'm not really sure what I want you to do different to be honest, I just don't want to think of you as scum.
7. MafiaSSK - Last post: four days ago. Considering there wasn't really any meat to sink into at the time, there's not really much to go on here. Please follow up on question aimed at chamber, and answer if you still think Nat and Esp are scummy. SSK was quiet to the point of me not expecting him to reply to posts in the QT, and he's kind of a lurker in general, so it's hard to get a read either way.
9. Espeonage - I actually thought the whole VT on the scene thing was a good reaction test way to start off at first but the overblown NOW YOU'VE ACTIVATED MY TRAP CARD SIRDAN YOU ARE THE SCUMS tunnel is just.. bad.

@sirdan's posting. Look at how he demands to know everything, town definitely wants information yes, but scum need it. It's like how White shouldn't lose tempo because they have the foot up on black in chess.

Nonsensical is probably a better word, and crazy paranoid. "Town would do this, but scum need to do it MORE, so sirdan spamming up the thread demanding to know everything means he's super scummy!" What I really want you to do is stop tunneling Sirdan and make a scum read that isn't based on The Most Easy to Hate Dude making posts at you.
11. Albert B. Rampage - Post count: 6. I don't know if there's a difference between ABR's town and scum games, but I'm already remembering why my eyes keep glazing over as I reread this game. Uhm, you said you would explain one of your votes if people picked one, and the only one person have shown interest in in the sirdan vote, so explain?
13. Desperado - Post count: 5. Please kill me. Wow, are you still voting me? I know I wanted to die while we were buddies, but I think you'll find I was equally suicidal in the game you were half-scum in too. If you're going to use meta then maybe you should use more then one game. You have plenty of my posts to look at and tell me if you still think I'm scum at least. also question, do you think sirdan is town or scum because when I tell someone I have a problem with their posts in your tone, it usually means I'm suspicious of them, but it's not clear in the way you're asking.
15. Elscouta - didn't like entry post of hopping onto the for some reason growing Sirdan wagon. Looking at his later posts though I'd have to say he's at least taking it seriously? Like, the opposite of how I feel about Esp's tunnelrageback. Still needs more scumspects who could actually be scum (tm)
16. PeregrineV - brain asdfghkjing why are you voting me and stop it reads as peregrinev
17. TheIrishPope (replacing xRECKONERx) - is a dude that's here

its hurting to think but I think I think Esp is the worst right now? Really what I'm remembering is that the game still practically hasn't started because half the people still haven't posted things. PS TIP if you seriously would have vigged someone who is obvtown instead of any of the above excluding yourself yyou would deserve to have the shit kicked out of you.

##Unvote
##Vote: Espironage

Tierce, I think you will find I was never actually a voyeuristic old man, I was always a sexy fiery temptress hiding in an old man's clothes. Also I'd have to say I'm as far opposite to being a voyeur as possible. Just pretend you can't read him and remember he's at least trying to help, in his own.. way. I'd stop posting if I were him too, wondering if I were still alive? (Or I'd start swearing at the 'vig' I supose if I was in the mood)
PPS i will take this as your admittance that i was in fact the bestest girl

Mine eyes hath devoured your wordiness. For the length of the post, I was fulfilled.

Then I finished the post.

Alas, my brain is once more hungry.

[Aegor]

4. Aegor - I didn't like post 141 as an entry post, it felt like throwing a bunch of things out to see what sticks, plus what I said earlier about his views on Esp.

My views were already explained. For you to ignore my response and allude to your earlier reasons is just scummy.

Also not sure what brachylogy means, but if it means empty voting you're basically voting ABR for being ABR,

Voilà.

he always does that as far as I've seen? I don't think you'd know that though.

He often does, and I do know. But if the meta is uninformative, why can I not vote based on the merit of the posts in this game?

Please explain which of the sixteen people who isn't yourself or ABR you also think are scummy and why. I'm preparing to copy/paste saying that alot!

I have no strong scumreads. Feel free to copy and paste as much as you like; my thoughts will come out as they occur, not artificially in order to meet someone's timetable.

[Plum]

It is not said that Aredhel was wholly unwilling, nor that her life in Nan Elmoth was hateful to her for many years. For though at Eöl's command she must shun the sunlight, they wandered far together under the stars or by the light of the sickle moon; or she might fare alone as she would, save that Eöl forbade her to seek the sons of Fëanor, or any others of the Noldor.

VOTE COUNT 1:9

Shadoweh

- 2 - Desperado, PeregrineV

Natirasha

- 3 - ActionDan, shos, TheIrishPope

TheIrishPope

- 3 - Aegor, chamber, Natirasha

Espeonage

- 3 - SpyreX, Shadoweh, sirdanilot

sirdanilot

- 2 - Albert B. Rampage, Espeonage

JacobSavage

- 2 - Tierce, Elscouta

MafiaSSK

- 1 - Cogito Ergo Sum

Not voting (2)

: JacobSavage, MafiaSSK

With 18 players alive it takes

10

votes to lynch.
Deadline is in

(expired on 2014-01-23 01:00:00)

.

MafiaSSK

is V/LA until Sunday.

[ActionDan]

I like Eol. Tierce is not yet town

[JacobSavage]

Neighbor post:

Code: Select all

Yarr.

Shadoweh's last post looks pretty off to me.

You should totes claim to me by the bye.

This first post by CES reads clumsily, and disjoined in a way which this following post by chamber doesn't:

Code: Select all

I don't like the way Peregrine came into the game like that. I'm wondering if he even read the thread.

tiercexReck is really boring. I don't think I see any useful information there, were you expecting reck to do anything other than FAKERAGE by piling on the pressure? Hard to get meaningful reactions from him.

I don't really get the shos wagon. He's being a bit of a derp but most of that was after it started. I need to go look for the root cause of it.

Shadoweh has had some more bad posts since her first. Especially post 64.

I'm VT, just going to obv town it up and get NKed though, nothing special. Spryex locking in his vote means it will happen sooner than later.

This especially as I can't imagine that they discussed this pre-game really, and that fact that his reply is calm suggests calm mindset which tends to come from town a lot more in the very early game.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

For me to bus, you have to ask nicely~

I put it to you that I am in fact being nice by giving you a neat little wagon to jump on for when you realise JacobSavage doesn't look scummy.

[PeregrineV]

Neighbor post:

Code: Select all

Yarr.

Shadoweh's last post looks pretty off to me.

You should totes claim to me by the bye.

This first post by CES reads clumsily, and disjoined in a way which this following post by chamber doesn't:

Code: Select all

I don't like the way Peregrine came into the game like that. I'm wondering if he even read the thread.

tiercexReck is really boring. I don't think I see any useful information there, were you expecting reck to do anything other than FAKERAGE by piling on the pressure? Hard to get meaningful reactions from him.

I don't really get the shos wagon. He's being a bit of a derp but most of that was after it started. I need to go look for the root cause of it.

Shadoweh has had some more bad posts since her first. Especially post 64.

I'm VT, just going to obv town it up and get NKed though, nothing special. Spryex locking in his vote means it will happen sooner than later.

This especially as I can't imagine that they discussed this pre-game really, and that fact that his reply is calm suggests calm mindset which tends to come from town a lot more in the very early game.

Do you speculate they are in a town-town, town-scum, or other type of neighborhood?

[PeregrineV]

I like Eol. Tierce is not yet town

I failed Abbreviations 101. Who is Eol?

[ActionDan]

You failed flavor 101

[chamber]

Vote mafiassk

I kind of feel like he'd just get BAM's though.

[Espeonage]

Nati's smugness/lackofcare isn't sitting right.

Unvote, Vote: Nati

[TheIrishPope]

someone is smart
nat has committed all the major scumtells and he is still not lynched
-voting someone because they suspected him
-buddying hardcore
-fence sitting
-having a scum role pm
and so help me god if anyone, ANYONE says nat is town I will club them with a bat full of rusted nails

[TheIrishPope]

And what I've gathered from dan's reactions, he's Town, so don't touch him

[SpyreX]

Spyspy:

Now that you made me go back and actually read it I'm not surprised at it bodes well for the future.

However actually trying to engage in something in this morass is a good sign.

Chamber taking the time to go meta as scum at this point looking for a bite under what would have been the strangest pretenses ever is waay more likely town and scum.

The English-Ur-quan translator failed in these sentences, I suspect. I think I know what you mean in each, but could you just clarify them?

The chamber/ces nonsense had a VT claim in it that I didn't see because I wasn't reading it. Seeing it makes me sad inside (and, if i had the druthers, I think there may be some parsing against that one versus the esp one that could be interesting later).

However chamber reading Els's games and noticing a different in style of posting and then probing to see why feels waay more town motivated then scum mostly because, even if he did find something, scum-chamber trying to push a lynch through on HE TYPE DIFFERENT would be the most uphill and eye pulling kind of thing ever.

---

I'm not sure why the hell I'm seeing so many OMG NO CONTENTS posts but lets round this up so you guys can get a new drum to bang on:

Tierce is town.
Sirdan is town.
PV is town.
Chamber is town.
Els is probably town.
Shadoweh's latest posts give a good solid feeling.
Shos is town and probably the one that will lose this at lylo.

I liked Reck. I'm not stoked about TIP.
JacobSavage is..strange and I can't tell if its due to being nabbed or just weird brain to keyboard circuits.

Esp needs to die.
Nat is actively doing nothing and thats awesome.
Desp is my gut pick for scum at the moment.

And there's a lot of slog. Way, way too much.

[chamber]

scum-chamber trying to push a lynch through on HE TYPE DIFFERENT would be the most uphill and eye pulling kind of thing ever.

I've done this before as town. SO HARD.

[Tierce]

scum-chamber trying to push a lynch through on HE TYPE DIFFERENT would be the most uphill and eye pulling kind of thing ever.

I've done this before as town. SO HARD.

Yes, and he sees it as Town, so... I'm not sure why the comment?

I mean, unless you're bragging about EFFORT, which etc.

[chamber]

scum-chamber trying to push a lynch through on HE TYPE DIFFERENT would be the most uphill and eye pulling kind of thing ever.

I've done this before as town. SO HARD.

Yes, and he sees it as Town, so... I'm not sure why the comment?

I mean, unless you're bragging about EFFORT, which etc.

I don't filter my thoughts for usefulness.

[Natirasha]

Nat is actively doing nothing and thats awesome.

thx

[TheIrishPope]

Guys this is seriously getting annoying.
Lynch Nat.
Pls.

[SpyreX]

I would be interested, but, you know. Votes and glue and all

[TheIrishPope]

Could you please let go of your pride for one day and we can lynch Esp tomorrow?

[SpyreX]

Could you please let go of your pride for one day and we can lynch Nat tomorrow?