Newbie 1471: Italian Ice (Game Over!)

[Wagon Me Pal]

Guys bcj is trying to escape his lynch by requesting a policy lynch. Scum scum scum.

[AbboTT]

Hostile place

Okay. Dude. This isn't helping anybody.

[AbboTT]

Guys bcj is trying to escape his lynch by requesting a policy lynch. Scum scum scum.

That's a stretch. You got "requesting a policy lynch" out of one emoticon?

[Wagon Me Pal]

Hostile place

Your posting style makes me laugh.


Is this all that is gonna be offered? At this rate there won't be a replacement, and I don't wanna push for a policy lynch but... Really?

Notice the "but... Really?"

Bcj is scum, lynch him.

[bjc]

Not scum here bro. I'm very confident there's at least one scum in Rob, Tier, and ED.

[AbboTT]

Alright. Rob clearly isn't going to be pressured, so that vote is useless until we make a decision about lynching him.

UNVOTE:

I'm comfortable putting bjc at L-1. His self-proclaimed "go with the flow" attitude towards D1 doesn't mesh well with my ideal townie profile. I do like that he isn't actively over-defending himself, but I'm starting to read that as scum playing it cool.

All in all, I think he's a solid choice. We will learn a thing as a vote count analysis and some ISOing should yield good info on D2 regardless of his flip.

My mind could be changed for a Rob lynch if anybody is down for that.

VOTE: bcj

[bjc]

That is such a lame vote. Good job enabling scum to sit on my wagon.

[bjc]

Any intent to hammer?

[Nachomamma8]

Sorry then.

Fwiw your rob vote is weaker, do something with your vote. What do you think your vote on rob will accomplish?

At this point? Lynching scum.
It amazes me that everyone else apparently thinks that there's a chance of this guy being town.

[ika]

That is such a lame vote. Good job enabling scum to sit on my wagon.

well im here too, and i have yet to move my vote, your stance is starting to sound liek "you cant lynch me bro"

i will say now, if you act cocky like that, it is a quick way for me to get a policy vote on you from me unless if you have reason. i have found scums act more cocky then town.

and yes if you keep up your cockyness i will hammer

[Nachomamma8]

Why the hell is cockiness scummy?
How is bjc in any way expressing cockiness?

[TierShift]

Sorry then.

Fwiw your rob vote is weaker, do something with your vote. What do you think your vote on rob will accomplish?

At this point? Lynching scum.
It amazes me that everyone else apparently thinks that there's a chance of this guy being town.

He's null and you aren't gonna convince me otherwise on the basis of 4 empty posts.

[AbboTT]

Yeah. I mean it's hard to base a scum read on lurking alone.

@Nacho: What would Rob's his lynch teach us after the flip?

That's the big reason why I'm not pushing it.

[ika]

Why the hell is cockiness scummy?
How is bjc in any way expressing cockiness?

its not always scummy, it just find that scums do it more often.

That is such a lame vote. Good job enabling scum to sit on my wagon.

this to me reads a null-cocky attitude. but its just kinda what m getting from it. i still kinda get a town from him but his continued way is starting to reach out to me as "you wont lynch me"

[Nachomamma8]

Sorry then.

Fwiw your rob vote is weaker, do something with your vote. What do you think your vote on rob will accomplish?

At this point? Lynching scum.
It amazes me that everyone else apparently thinks that there's a chance of this guy being town.

He's null and you aren't gonna convince me otherwise on the basis of 4 empty posts.

Why do you think he playing the way he is?
Do you not think the posting to avoid replacement is a little bit sketchy despite apparently having no interest in the game whatsoever?

[bjc]

I think there's a little bit to be gained by the RobW flip, not a whole lot though. I think we're in a bind though: He posts just enough to not get replaced. So... What the hell is his usefulness to us?

@ ika - Want to know why I feel like "you won't lynch me?" Because I'm town. Just like you said you don't feel threatened due to being town, I feel like I won't be lynched because I'm town. There's a reason I'm wanting to know if someone has intent to hammer.

So tell me: Do you have a serious intent to hammer?

[ika]

Sorry then.

Fwiw your rob vote is weaker, do something with your vote. What do you think your vote on rob will accomplish?

At this point? Lynching scum.
It amazes me that everyone else apparently thinks that there's a chance of this guy being town.

He's null and you aren't gonna convince me otherwise on the basis of 4 empty posts.

Why do you think he playing the way he is?
Do you not think the posting to avoid replacement is a little bit sketchy despite apparently having no interest in the game whatsoever?

ever thought of board citizen (or vt as you guys call it)? i dont doubt he could be scum but ive seen citizen do almost no content post becasue they are just board. also if he does flip town you would become another big target becasue you are the one who started it.

[Nachomamma8]

Yeah. I mean it's hard to base a scum read on lurking alone.

@Nacho: What would Rob's his lynch teach us after the flip?

That's the big reason why I'm not pushing it.

We will learn that he's scum. Towns in newbie games that manage to lynch scum Day 1 have a 90% chance of winning. That seems a fine enough scenario to me.

[Nachomamma8]

Why the hell is cockiness scummy?
How is bjc in any way expressing cockiness?

its not always scummy, it just find that scums do it more often.

That is such a lame vote. Good job enabling scum to sit on my wagon.

this to me reads a null-cocky attitude. but its just kinda what m getting from it. i still kinda get a town from him but his continued way is starting to reach out to me as "you wont lynch me"

"Scums do it more often". Where do you get this information from?

[bjc]

Look, if you guys are eager to lynch someone now, then lynch Rob holy hell. He isn't posting crap but just enough to stay in the game. There is probably scum on my wagon.

[Nachomamma8]

Sorry then.

Fwiw your rob vote is weaker, do something with your vote. What do you think your vote on rob will accomplish?

At this point? Lynching scum.
It amazes me that everyone else apparently thinks that there's a chance of this guy being town.

He's null and you aren't gonna convince me otherwise on the basis of 4 empty posts.

Why do you think he playing the way he is?
Do you not think the posting to avoid replacement is a little bit sketchy despite apparently having no interest in the game whatsoever?

ever thought of board citizen (or vt as you guys call it)? i dont doubt he could be scum but ive seen citizen do almost no content post becasue they are just board. also if he does flip town you would become another big target becasue you are the one who started it.

If he's bored, then he would replace out or talk or say that he's bored or something. This is just ridiculous.
And yep, I'm aware of that. It doesn't affect my stance on him.

[bjc]

I take that back. There IS scum on my wagon. The question is whether or not it's the whole team or one of them plus RobW.

[Nachomamma8]

Look, if you guys are eager to lynch someone now, then lynch Rob holy hell. He isn't posting crap but just enough to stay in the game. There is probably scum on my wagon.

I hate this post.

[TierShift]

Why do you think he playing the way he is?
Do you not think the posting to avoid replacement is a little bit sketchy despite apparently having no interest in the game whatsoever?

Lurking =/= scummy get over it

Yeah. I mean it's hard to base a scum read on lurking alone.

@Nacho: What would Rob's his lynch teach us after the flip?

That's the big reason why I'm not pushing it.

Also this.

[Nachomamma8]

Sorry then.

Fwiw your rob vote is weaker, do something with your vote. What do you think your vote on rob will accomplish?

At this point? Lynching scum.
It amazes me that everyone else apparently thinks that there's a chance of this guy being town.

He's null and you aren't gonna convince me otherwise on the basis of 4 empty posts.

Why do you think he playing the way he is?
Do you not think the posting to avoid replacement is a little bit sketchy despite apparently having no interest in the game whatsoever?

You didn't answer my questions.