Xenosaga Mafia (Game Over)

[Metal Sonic]

General knowledge: skulduggery is really good at looking town but has poor scum hunting skills

remember this (for those of you who have not played with skull before


also i just iso'd myself and it is shitty lmao!

[Aegor]

I don't think you understand my metaphor. Read the explanation I gave Cephrir in 372 and then let me know if you're still confused.

I understand your metaphor completely. I simply completely reject the notion that scum would not join the wagon.

You asked whether I would count myself as a Scum candidate among the early voters on the Brian wagon. My response was, "Why the fuck would I count myself as a Scum candidate when I know that I'm not Scum?" I don't see what you're confused about.

I am not confused. My question was whether you would consider the fourth voter on a bandwagon to be among the early voters. Or whether you were identifying categories that would conveniently exclude you regardless of Brian's flip were he lynched.

By that logic, all of our lynches are indefinitely in the future. What makes Brian's so special?

That was the one I was discussing.

Again I call bullshit. No vote is cast in a vacuum. You can't say that you don't like my vote on Flandre and then cover your ass by saying that you have no opinion of Flandre.

Yes I can. I could not like your vote on Flandre and also think Flandre is scum. This is easily possible in two situations:

1) I am not 100% sure that there is only one scum faction.
2) My dislike of your vote is relatively stronger than my read of its target.

In this case, both apply.

Do I sound like I'm crying about anything? No, no I'm not. Grow up.

kk

Do you think that childish name-calling is going to make the other players

more

willing or

less

willing to listen to you? Serious question.

Do not care. Serious answer.

Do me a personal favor, would you please? Either learn how to use a semicolon correctly or don't use them at all. Thanks.

Commenting on my grammar is a losing battle for you, but I encourage you to pull at that thread if you so desire.

[Metal Sonic]

your quotes are messed up ^

[Aegor]

Whoops. That's awk. All the quotations belong to Skull.

[sangres]

This has to be at least the third or fourth time you've said, "I want to do such-and-such, but I should consult with Nacho first." With all due respect, what are you comfortable doing without Nacho's input? If your hydra partner isn't keeping up, what's stopping you from just playing solo? This is the kind of thing that makes me dislike hydras.

For all intents and purposes, I am playing solo. Your irritation is noted, though and I'll keep your concerns in mind.

It has nothing to do with being a hydra, per se. It has to do with wanting Nacho's opinion on some players that I know he can read well. I'd want his opinion if we were playing separately. The difference is that his role and alignment are mod confirmed to me because it's my role PM too, so I won't have to weigh any of that up in evaluating his opinions.

[Skullduggery]

General knowledge: skulduggery is really good at looking town but has poor scum hunting skills

remember this (for those of you who have not played with skull before

Dude, what the fuck is wrong with you? We've played

one

game together.

One

game. And, as I recall, I correctly identified three of the six Scum players in that game without too much trouble. Who the fuck are you to say that I have poor Scum hunting skills? When did you become an expert on my play? All you're doing is talking out your ass.

Again I ask you: What do you hope to accomplish by slandering and discrediting me so early? Are you afraid of people listening to me? If so, why?

My question was whether you would consider the fourth voter on a bandwagon to be among the early voters.

The fourth voter on a ten-person wagon? Sure, that could be considered an early voter. For this scenario, though, I'm not going to consider it because I already know the alignment of that fourth voter. Other players can if they want to, though.

Do not care. Serious answer.

So you don't care whether anyone else believes your laughable case on me? What are you going to do, lynch me all by yourself? You have fun with that.

Commenting on my grammar is a losing battle for you, but I encourage you to pull at that thread if you so desire.

I'm so scared. Maybe I should post a picture of my Master's degree in English to show you how scared I am.

For all intents and purposes, I am playing solo. Your irritation is noted, though and I'll keep your concerns in mind.

Thank you. I'm sorry if I sounded snippy, but as I'm sure you've noticed, certain other players are starting to get on my nerves.

[zMuffinMan]

pieguy is presenting an argument

first, this is... like... a borderline fucking retarded answer. "you're sure pieguy is scum and it's too early to be sure of anything so you're scum, but pieguy being sure of you and mastin doesn't mean anything because he's presenting an argument!"

like, really? that's how you defend your stance here?

second, so what? do you think scum is more or less likely to try to blend in by making up reasons for their suspicion? and if you respond by saying something along the lines of "WIFOM", i'm just going to ignore you for the rest of the game. your reads are awful

also, saying pieguy is presenting an "argument" is meh, especially when the basis for his "argument" is similar to the reasons mastin was wagoned in xenogears

[Metal Sonic]

@Skullduggery,

Sorry if my post was offensive or what, but I remember you posted in some game that you were waaay better at looking town than catching scum, and that stuck in my head.

In fact, that's in the book. Not trying to discredit you or whatever but yeah that stuck for me when I think of you...

[Metal Sonic]

umm by the book i meant this


Once again I apologise if my statement was rude :/

[orcinus_theoriginal]

Please show me what your book has to say about me :O

[Metal Sonic]

private and confidential

but this playerlist is good

[orcinus_theoriginal]

VOTE: ms I don't think you understood my request

[zMuffinMan]

that masonry didn't last long

[zMuffinMan]

Muffin can be scum just for being this sure of anything before page 20

i was thinking about this

have you never seen people be sure of a read before p20?

[Angry Frat BROs]

^ You can distance all you guys want, Angry P is still going to shoot you in the face tonight.

[zMuffinMan]

can you put the head on that knows how to play

ty

[Angry Frat BROs]

UNVOTE: whoever (mastin?)
VOTE: Cephrir

All aboard that scum wagon.

P-edit: Join me, bus for cred before its too late.

[Angry Frat BROs]

Votecount 1.5 (No Change)

[7] mastin2 (Angry Frat Bros)

Dan, vote Cephrir with me and I won't serial kill you tonight.

[Angry Frat BROs]

Dan, vote Cephrir with me and I won't serial kill you tonight.

Oops, I typed vigilante but my phone auto-corrected it to SK, LOL.

[Angry Frat BROs]

Mollie is confirmed town.

[zMuffinMan]

not yelling "X is town Y is scum nothing will change my mind about this"

also how much of my posts are you reading? because i have pretty clearly explained where the read on pieguy comes from here, here and here

just because i'm not breaking down every single post he makes and explaining why he's scum because of it, doesn't mean i don't have reasons to think he's scum.

it is largely a meta-based read. there are differences in how he plays as scum and town, and i am pretty sure this is his scum game. i don't really expect anyone to be convinced by me saying this, but you can compare and contrast how he talks in games he's town yourself (if you're any good at reading tone and attitude, and i don't think you are based on your current reads, so maybe it's a long shot you'll actually be able to do this)

[Angry Frat BROs]

votehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehimvotehim

Dan might be mafia. his posts look sort of town, but I'm not seeing Dan-town specifically here.

[Metal Sonic]

VOTE: ms I don't think you understood my request

ummm way to get my attention

no i obviously did not understand your request

[Venmar]

did i do it right?

[ActionDan]

Votecount 1.5 (No Change)

[7] mastin2 (Angry Frat Bros)

Dan, vote Cephrir with me and I won't serial kill you tonight.

Seems legit... brother?