In post 2240, macmollie wrote:I think that it would be pretty dumb for mastina to be all ack! ack! ack! the sk is BAD! lynch him! only to be the actual sk.
Mastin hasn't actually been saying that, though. It's mostly been a lot of idle chatting about the SK and presenting possible scenarios with no real definitive stances on what we should do with them.
In post 2240, macmollie wrote:I mean he is telling us that the sk is unleashable and it seems like a stretch for him to set himself up like that if he was caught out. if mastina is scum it is grpscum IMO
In what way do you think Mastin is "setting himself up"?
I do recognize the possibility that I'm wrong and Mastin really is group-Scum, but I'm just not getting that vibe from her posts. She seems anti-Town, but independently so. I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on this for now since this seems to be a matter of perspective for both of us.
In post 2242, Aegor wrote:Skullduggery wrote:I don't find it odd. Do you think everyone in our neighborhood is Town?
You should find it odd. And you should also realize that your question is a straw man. Think about it.
Cool story, bro. Do you think everyone in our neighborhood is Town? I wasn't aware that I was asking you a difficult question.
Like what?
In post 2263, mastin2 wrote:Because the entire reason for suspecting SSK is him being at sangres N1, and pie dieing N2 as a 1x-BP Bodyguard, and people making the logical deduction that pie's BP was used N1 protecting sangres and that one of the others visiting sangres was killing. If that's not true, then there's no reason for SSK to be scum at all. Thinking he's scum-tracking-sangres is just, well, off.
Because it doesn't make sense for Scum to both track and kill Sangres on the same night, right? Which means that either SSK is telling the truth about tracking Sangres on Night 1 or he's lying about that and taking a huge risk by saying that Sangres didn't perform an action when he has no idea whether Sangres has a night action or not.
Alright, I think I understand now.
UNVOTE:
In post 2268, mastin2 wrote:(Quoting this as one more reason Skull's post was BS, by the way.
)
If it's any consolation, eliminating the Serial Killer isn't my top priority right now. You can stick around until Day 5 or 6 after you've stabbed a couple Scumbags for us.
In post 2281, Venmar wrote:(The SK speculation is dumb without seeing if two kills a night persist. Existence of a SK also complicates the fact there was only 1 kill Night 1.)
Pieguy was one-shot Bulletproof, he died on Night 2, and there was only one kill on Night 1 while there were two kills on Night 2. What do you
think
happened?
