Mini 1560 - Reck's Walk of Shame (GAME OVER)

[~Jordan`]

it's just that newbs who flake are disproportionately scum

[absta101]

at the end of the day, I'm the one who's right and you're the one voting town

What makes you think Aegor is town?

[Aegor]

Jordan, am I scum?

[absta101]

lol

[Slandaar]

I feel like I am at the theater.

Fate/Doc/Titus.

[Fate]

I see you're still a clown Slandaar

[~Jordan`]

Jordan, am I scum?

probably

[CooLDoG]

noted that doc is lurkering...

[Aegor]

VOTE: Doc

[~Jordan`]

damn it aegor what are you doing

[Slandaar]

I see you're still a clown Slandaar

It might just be that your explanation didn't include enough juggling and pie throwing metaphors for me to be able to comprehend but I think most likely it is that you forgot to enlighten the clown populace as to your reasoning for Doctown.

[Freak]

damn it aegor what are you doing

he's crossing the streams

[Freak]

the ones in Fate's play anyway

also absta thanks for the props. I'm as new as the date says!

[Freak]

Jordan, am I scum?

probably

what's scum abut Aegor? I don't like the lack of (expressed) motivations behind his last votes, but that seems to be a common thing around here.

[Slandaar]

Freak; want to vote Doc with the cool kids?

[Freak]

and leave the scummiest of the bunch with zero votes? nah. you guys seem to be doing fine without me.

[Slandaar]

Hes town so it would be better to have zero votes on him, yes.

[Freak]

then why he's been acting like scum that has been cornered since after I started questioning his motives?

besides, I already expressed myself on doc, so you can say I picked a side of that fence before it became mainstream.

[ChannelDelibird]

Hi guys! Busier start to the week than I expected. Catching up.

[Fate]

my god CDB is scum as fuck

[~Jordan`]

<3

[CooLDoG]

my god CDB is scum as fuck

I could see that actually. I want more content from him though.

[Aegor]

Upon re-read, I still think the following posts are the worst in the game:

Spoiler:

^goodposting

CDB is probTown

you're really flippant with reads, huh?

Who? Neither of the reads posted since your last were flippant, they both pretty clearly stated their reasoning.

Oh, you're referring to me calling CDB probTown. That was more obvious than I thought.

CDB is putting clear effort into sorting the good from the bad

, and right away spotted a cognitive dissonance that I missed. That is not how scum tend to think, their cases tend to be built slowly and carefully, because they have to think about it more.

Jordan, posting townreads as well as scumreads is useful because it gives people more opportunities to take concrete stances on each other, which is always a good thing. For me, the difference between scum townreading a buddy and scum simply 'not scumreading' a buddy is large enough that it should not be discouraged. Openness and readability are pro-town.

At this point,

I have mild-to-reasonably-strong townreads on Doc

, Jordan, Cooldog and Freak. I also like Aegor's response to me here as a contrast to his demeanour when I last saw him as scum, so I'll look elsewhere for the time being. I think his scumread on me is pretty silly, given our recent experience, but he'll get over that.

Unvote: Aegor

Vote: JKMatthews

VOTE: Doc for scummy reasoning and agreeing with CDB when there was no reason to.

You're aware that waiting a couple of pages to say "Oh my god! You suck!" doesn't make it less scummy, right? You're also committing

exactly

the same scummy sin that CDB initially called you out for - seeing something, going on about something else, then going back and saying "You know what, my vote should be

here

, even though I didn't think it warranted it right away." That kind of calculated sophistry does not scream Town.

To the people that have been saying I have bad reasoning, or haven't explained, or whatever else, fuck you. I explained well my solid reads perfectly well. Jordan is scummy for trying to build cases on people out of thin air, early nervous votehopping, and

really

bad reactions to being voted, CDB is probably Town for demonstrating a logical, discerning thought process, and Aegor is getting scummier for cognitive dissonance. Everyone else is too weak a read to bother with.

If Freak ever flips scum, this post deserves attention:

Got ninjaed by undo.

Undo's comments seem to be discrediting the newb, but they all appear to be valid criticisms. I'm going to deliberately avoid interrupting that to see if Freak can model constructive scumhunting questions. Whenever I see something that says, well so and so isn't scumhunting, my alarm bells go off that someone's trying to lynch the newbie.

[Fate]

oh wow when its Cooldog of all people agreeing with me this town is in it for the long haul

[undo]

If Freak ever flips scum, this post deserves attention:

Got ninjaed by undo.

Undo's comments seem to be discrediting the newb, but they all appear to be valid criticisms. I'm going to deliberately avoid interrupting that to see if Freak can model constructive scumhunting questions. Whenever I see something that says, well so and so isn't scumhunting, my alarm bells go off that someone's trying to lynch the newbie.

QFT

I suggest we lynch Freak and go after Titus tomorrow.