In post 1660, BipolarChemist wrote:I'm just past page 40 on my catch up now. I guess I'll give a quick update on thoughts now.
I'm copying a lot of these notes from my notebook. I won't be going into too much of a wall, people just skim those, so I'm open to any and all questions if you need me to elaborate.
First 500 Posts:
I found peregrine to be very town acting, helpful and overall decent. I found Mister Rogers the same way, I liked his reads and they feel honest, and he's very contributive. My interaction with Zdenek was interesting, I wanna throw him into the town pile, but I'm not quite ready to. Talah felt very flip floppy, one second inferring he doubts the Fake Vig stuff, but then, in the same post, says I'm most likely town.
This is just a bunch of scummy Information Instead of Analysis.
AngryPidgeon came out swingin' onto the quiet Pisskop, I like the idea of him getting lurkers to talk, not fully sure on him though. I did like Yates doubt of the Fake Vig thing, I found it to be a good perspective that wasn't mentioned yet, but his posts just became big one-shot walls of unhelpfulness, and
I quickly started to find him scummy
. Mastin is still null-scum, but I don't wanna comment until he's back and not dealing with shit.
This is non-committal to the extreme and doesn't really feel genuine?
DeasVeil hasn't posted too much, but I find him decently town. I don't like Thad's or Project Matt's liking of the Fake Vig, seems disgenuine and like they're trying to buy townie points, PM then was very on the fence, not taking a side on the matter.
Hes very much focused on the vig interaction, almost obsessively which is a pretty easy thing for scum to sideline on.
Posts up to about 1000:
Peregrine continued to seem town for the same reasons to me. Same with Rogers. DeasV seemed to drop right off here, I doubt it's scummy, but my town feel is going away. I now like Angry Pidgeon's pushing a lot more, looking more town. I find Pisskop to be decently town acting, not particularly contributive in volume, but he keeps some discussion going.
Snork's entrance into the game was big and seemingly town, as time went on I began to question some of his stuff, I want to put him in my town pile, but I just can't yet. Snow still has barely said anything enough to post on, same with aptil. Zdenek also seemed to go away...
Nothing here looks town? Hes just throwing reads at people and commenting on who is contributing and who isn't.
Thad moved from scum to null for me, I found him to be quite a bit more useful and contributive. Rach still hasn't done much, coasting, unvoting even though she said she hadn't caught up. Nero moved right into my scum pile, unhelpful in kind of an annoying way. Talah's drunk posting was funny, but I still think he's scum. The Oracle claim feels weak, and I don't like it. Yates kept on doing what he does, not changing my opinion of him.
And he actually thought Talah was claiming something serious? The fuck? There is nothing town about this post, so why do you have this guy as lolmegatown?
and I kinda think AP's town for the way he's pushing pisskop. Pisskop was sarcastic and rude, not scummy. I could see where he was coming from and in the end talah and luca both flipped town so any reads based on which of those anyone thought were scummy should be null and void.
Obviously I don't have a good answer for my BPC read. I never said it was rock solid, and even when you asked about him and DV together it should have been pretty clear based on the answer I gave you that it was a gut read, yet you are acting like this is news.
