The theory is this: If we misslynch today, and there is a nightkill tonight. That leaves 2 scum and 3 town tomorrow. If you are scum, you pop your gladiator on your partner. Then, no matter which scum town lynches, the game is over because the remaining scum has two votes in a 3-way.In post 1471, Hadrian wrote:Riddle me this big guy, why didn't I use it? Why haven't I today? If we're so clever we could make this lylo, why fight it. If we're scum and one of morph/username is town why not use it? We could make a case against either and there's enough suspicion to potentially go through. I wouldn't care if I lost because oh ho ho, I wouldn't.In post 1463, Porkens wrote:AUN, how could scum Hadrian make this lylo?
Do you see me using it or do you see me not using it. Oh durr must be because we're town.
Since you could be scum, isn't the best play to lynch you today? Is there a flaw in this I'm not seeing?
My initial reaction is "the charter idea was shot down because it infringed on how people liked to play."In post 1472, Hadrian wrote:In post 1470, Porkens wrote:I'm going to ignore the personal and needless insults, even though it is quite a challenge for me to do so.
What about lynching you doesn't make sense? You could be scum, and, if you are, this is lylo. Is there something wrong about the logic of that?
They're not personal insults, your play is lazy as fuck. And you know what I probably wouldn't mind, but you came up with the charter, so sorry bout your luck but I'm going to hold you to a higher standard because you thought of yourself so much better. You criticize other peoples play, like you did to us in wizards saying you wouldn't tolerate our nonsense when we were actually giving thoughts about the game. I expect you, if you're going to start the game with a charter, to oh I don't know try to figure out the game. You criticized pless yesterday for actually trying to figure things out because you'd prefer to be lazy and not.
I actually don't mind being lynched if it removes the gladiate fear, which I've already said more than once and interacted with you about. I already suggested gladiating kdub so that we would be certain the double votes would go to town. You've already interacted with me about that.
We are town. This is not lylo. It doesn't make sense to lynch us because it will be a mislynch. It only makes sense in getting rid of gladiator fear.
My deeper reaction is hurt feelings. I'm not being cavalier or lazy about this game. I'm not sheeping anyone or blowing off any serious discussion. I have strong reads, and I'm pursuing them. AUN has a really good point about your role and what it could mean for the game. I still think he is scum, but I think the right move is lynching you. If someone can come up with a compelling reason why that's not the best move, I'll listen. There are constructive ways to get your point across, and you are utilizing none of them.