Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

owait your scum, keep doing what ur doing

[Jake from State Farm]

im burned out and this game does not interest me one bit

why is this so boring, and jake stop tunneling

Do us a favor and replace out

[BROseidon]

Will get to this later today.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

we would never replace out. shame on you for suggesting that!

[Jake from State Farm]

who just typed that post?

[Squirrel Girl]

1) This game started just over a month ago. At no point was AJ not lurking. His recent replace out does not address the several weeks of no content.
2) People who lurk produce little/no content, and therefore you question about whether there is any other scum case is impossible to answer, since other scum cases require content, of which AJ has deprived us.

1. And yet it does.
2. So your case is that he was lurking because he was scum. And that he replaced out...because he was scum really committed to selling the lurking as legit?

I wanted AJ's thoughts first. I had a reasonable townread on him from d1 reachouts but during night one I wanted to see how his reads were looking. Obviously I couldn't reply (the gap you are referring to between AJ's was the wee hours of the night here) but I opened my posting on n2 in the neighbourhood with my reads as well.

That reads as weak to me. He was a town read for you so you wanted his thoughts and to have a discussion but when he wasn't posting you just sat quietly but hated on him for not sharing? I don't really get it. Why not just share first yourself? WHat big difference did it make? What did you learn by making him go first?

It worries me cus it looked like you were trying to spin me out to be delibrately not posting, or at fault for the lack of posts, when in fact it was AJ's - evidently, he couldn't help it though.

I was trying to be deliberate in showing when Night and Day happened - yes. I would also say it is reasonable to suggest the lack of communication was from your end - AJ did post more and more substantively in the QT.

[Aegor]

1. And yet it does.

No. Just no.

2. So your case is that he was lurking because he was scum. And that he replaced out...because he was scum really committed to selling the lurking as legit?

No, my case is that he was scum-lurking and then replaced out. You speak as if it is impossible for someone to scum-lurk and then replace out legitimately. That has a stark false dichotomy.

[Kdub]

kdub, the aegor wagon isn't likely to happen. time to join the HKC wagon

I'd prefer Mac to HKC if there's still interest there, but I'll get behind an HKC lynch if that's the most viable option. Really, any flip of SG/Mac/Aegor/HKC would be useful IMO.

[Squirrel Girl]

No, my case is that he was scum-lurking and then replaced out. You speak as if it is impossible for someone to scum-lurk and then replace out legitimately. That has a stark false dichotomy.

Was he lurking because he was busy or was he lurking as a strategy to win?
If the latter - why did he replace out, since his posting activity seemed in line with his strategy?
If it's the former - how can you tell it was scummy as opposed to townish lurking?

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

I mean you said you were going to catch up when there wasn't anything to catch up on and then you didn't even catch up. Nor have you even attempted to do anything that remotely looks like trying to find scum. Obviously that means you aren't trying to find scum which means you are scum.

It's pretty simple really

neither have you!

[Jake from State Farm]

1. Answer my question. Who made that earlier post

2. You are kidding me right? Must I remind you that I single handidly handed town smp. Not to mention I looked at cvs and gave a very good short list of possible scum.

[Jake from State Farm]

*Looked at VCs*

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

And that was Bert, but I'm saying don't pull that shit because it's lazy as fuck, and completely discredits all the work I have done, considering I had worked my ass off D1, found myself some pretty solid town-reads, actually tried to work out my scum-reads and, have tried to not succumb to apathy.

you? all you have done is discredit people left and right, and have not yet made an actual case against anybody while I have made several cases over, and over D1 and D2. If I was scum, I would be pretty intent to just tunnel fuck all my way through D1, not take a break and consider other scumoption outside of you all just to try and appease ffery/cho.

asking us to replace out is pretty funny, because it seems like you are trying to get rid of the people who is the biggest threat to you, a threat you can't really kill because it would just point to you. Yeah, we're pretty apathetic, I have been since gamestart, but so is every other person in this game for the most part.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

You can keep saying that, but the only reason SMP really ended up getting lynched was because Ffery led it, not you.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

I also do not lurk regardless of alignment unless I am busy and don't want to read, in which case I will outright say so

[Jake from State Farm]

1. You really haven't done much "work" unless you consider trolling and fake drunk posting work.
2. You found town reads? Congratulations. But this is mafia and the object is for mafia to kill town and town to figure out who mafia is.
3. I made a case against smp and he was scum. I provided reasons why you are scum , why Mac could be, and why muffin could be.
4. I discredit people? Even if that was true so what? I'm not here to make friends. I'm here to find scum and everyone is a suspect
5. You aren't a threat to me. If you are town you are violating a site rule and since no mod ever actually forces it ( except me) I have every right to ask you to replace out. You can't even convince people to lynch me when I'm daring you to lynch me.
6. If you are town you are a disgrace to the game. You have no interest but self survival which is a scum trait not a town trait.

Al that is just wasted words though cause you have to be scum. Have to be. Town would never play so anti-town like this would they ?

Bork would surely have modkilled you if you were town, lord knows I would if I were a mod.

[Jake from State Farm]

Not only is it a site rule, it's a game rule too.

#8 - play to win

If you are town you absolutely aren't doing this

[Aegor]

Was he lurking because he was busy or was he lurking as a strategy to win?

Either is possible.

If the latter - why did he replace out, since his posting activity seemed in line with his strategy?

Because RL commitments prevented any participation whatsoever (in-thread, in-QT, etc.), or any other number of possible reasons.

If it's the former - how can you tell it was scummy as opposed to townish lurking?

Lurking is never townish.


VOTE: Mac

Jake, if you fucking mention your "single-handed" handing-over of SMP again, I will votepark you.

[Antihero]

kdub, the aegor wagon isn't likely to happen. time to join the HKC wagon

I'd prefer Mac to HKC if there's still interest there, but I'll get behind an HKC lynch if that's the most viable option. Really, any flip of SG/Mac/Aegor/HKC would be useful IMO.

so what are you waiting for? people to not vote aegor?

i feel like you're milling around because you don't want people to think you're overeager scum.

[Aegor]

KDub and Mac are definitely not both town. Just saying.

[Jake from State Farm]

@hkc

[6. If you are town you are a disgrace to the game. You have no interest but self survival which is a scum trait not a town trait. [/quote]

I apologize for this. I went too far

[Jake from State Farm]

Fucking quote fail.

[Kdub]

so what are you waiting for? people to not vote aegor?

i feel like you're milling around because you don't want people to think you're overeager scum.

3 days left, I'm not scrambling to climb aboard a deadline wagon just yet.

I'll ask the same question about Aegor that you asked about me. Does anyone think Aegor is town? I'm interested to know who will defend him and on what basis.

KDub and Mac are definitely not both town. Just saying.Just saying.

Did you come to this conclusion based on our last exchange? Explain please. Feels like you are trying to set up another lynch if one of us flips town.

[zMuffinMan]

aware deadline is 3.5 days out, will be finished reading some time tomorrow afternoon (roughly 14-16 hours from now)

been skimming recent posts and still totally cool with a SG lynch if that is still viable

[borkjerfkin]

dfqwd