this is absolute shitIn post 8042, CarbonFiber wrote:I won't discount Magenta being town and it would make sense for Nacho to die quietly if that's the case. Perhaps it is best to not rush into a lynch then and consider all options. What are your reads on me and JSU at this point?
In post 7923, magenta_thegreat wrote:and this makes no sense? Orc governed and had the lynch between us and some other person that had gotten lynched. I don't recall having read that happeningIn post 7846, Just Sheep Us wrote:Also, do you think it's a coincidence that Nacho directed the day-1 lynch onto Orc, of all the lurkers?
No?
I didn't think so either.
VOTE: Magenta
lets not forget the existence of these, because at this point this completely breaks apart the reason CF has on me and is a pretty big thing to have ignored.In post 7924, magenta_thegreat wrote:VOTE: CF
aside having me as scum, he isn't even voting me (or, if he is, didn't do so before or during that T/S list of his) and completely disregarded the fact that one of his town reads, JSU, had confirmed AP as town when they apparently don't get a result on scum
No.In post 8056, CarbonFiber wrote:Brian, Beli, let's do this first and get back to the others later.
Why are you suddenly so sure that Magenta is a mislynch?In post 8057, Red Gyarados wrote:
I told you, we're not sorting my shit out in any possible lylo situation.
What the fuck are you talking about Falcon? I brought up my CC way before you called me out.In post 7987, Red Gyarados wrote:Also, I straight up CC'ed Fox's night action. Why is it one of AP/RG/Fox instead of one of RG/Fox?
When did I say Magenta is a mislynch? I'm saying we can't flip Magenta without resolving my CC first. End of story. Get your head out of your ass if town, plox.In post 8059, AngryPidgeon wrote:Why are you suddenly so sure that Magenta is a mislynch?In post 8057, Red Gyarados wrote:
I told you, we're not sorting my shit out in any possible lylo situation.
In post 7995, Red Gyarados wrote:This is pretty convincing.In post 7993, CarbonFiber wrote:Magenta case in a nutshell:
1) Mara was fooled in a grand fashion by Nacho in NY169: Mara's EPIC XD Failure to read Nacho where she persistently townread Nacho and was left alive late game as a confirmed town Mason. Tammy, Pieguyn and I were scumreading him in that same game and Mara never thought to interact with any of us to refine her read.
2) Mara lacked paranoia of Nacho and seems too sure about her read (basically what Tammy said earlier).
3) Nacho pushing Orc lynch D1 as a feel-good lynch when we now know that Orc was a D1-only governor feels really slimy (basically Tammy fucking called it as Nacho bussing Orc). AP will say I am buddying with Tammy again but meh. If this flips scum as I think it will, there's only one person I can really credit for this lynch so yeah.
4) Magenta roleblocking Stalin is seriously scum motivated. Although tbf, I don't know why they would claim it. They could have just shut up and done nothing. But then again, everyone was suspicious of Magenta so they might have thought WIFOM would help, I don't know. But their night actions still don't make sense from a town POV.
.
But if I give you Mara, I want Fox's head
Ya ok, but that isn't what you said before.In post 8061, Red Gyarados wrote:When did I say Magenta is a mislynch? I'm saying we can't flip Magenta without resolving my CC first. End of story. Get your head out of your ass if town, plox.
I'm here and I've been trying to get to the bottom of this for quite a few rl days now so.In post 8065, AngryPidgeon wrote:Where the hell is foxhound. Can the people who actually give a shit about this situation have a power hour and figure out what exactly is going down? Its like Fox is mostly apathetic to this all going down, RG is convinced their role works a certain way that seems unlikely, and I have no idea what CF thinks of RG's whole spheal right now, but Im not going to deal with what happens if we lynch Fox and they are town unless we are beyond any doubt that Rg is just making this shit up in that case.
In post 8064, AngryPidgeon wrote:Ya ok, but that isn't what you said before.In post 8061, Red Gyarados wrote:When did I say Magenta is a mislynch? I'm saying we can't flip Magenta without resolving my CC first. End of story. Get your head out of your ass if town, plox.
And you are still trying to argue that someone is lying about a role that they are now confirmed to have. And the argument that they are claimign a scum buddies role for them is shit. I dont know what is going on here.
Look, not every person in this game can be scum. So I'm just going to give everyone the benefit of the doubt here.In post 8065, AngryPidgeon wrote:Where the hell is foxhound. Can the people who actually give a shit about this situation have a power hour and figure out what exactly is going down? Its like Fox is mostly apathetic to this all going down, RG is convinced their role works a certain way that seems unlikely, and I have no idea what CF thinks of RG's whole spheal right now, but Im not going to deal with what happens if we lynch Fox and they are town unless we are beyond any doubt that Rg is just making this shit up in that case.
Off the cuff: Scum have daytalk. This would be very easy to coordinate in a scum/scum situation.In post 8067, AngryPidgeon wrote:I'd like to hear your off the cuff thoughts right now even if you dont like them yet.
Ya, I just doubt they are lying though? Their tidbit about Yggdra sounds really genuine and we have now confirmed that they knew RG's rolename. Rg is claiming to have failed on them...the night that they apparently had their role not work. And the plausibility of them claiming something incriminating when a buddy flips is.. ??? That would only make sense if that buddy were like JSU (maybe?) or Tammy. Still.In post 7940, The Fox and the Hound wrote:N1: Yggdra Union- evolving fonic JOAT (no idea why fonic isn't in their flip)
N2: RG- Artist (no, I have no idea what that is, that's why we're shitty)
Coast in 5p and maybe 3p LyLo. It was what I tried to set up in AoT with faking getting RB'd by Pasch.In post 8068, CarbonFiber wrote:I am not sure what the scum motivation for RG would be if they are scum to hard cc another player a day away from LYLO.