Mini 1585: Muskoka Murder Mystery - Game Over

[chaoslord54]

Okay so I will explain the reason why I dropped originally the Reinoe vote and focused on Chevre. Because I started to lean towards Chevre being scum but still felt that Reinoe was scummy. I began to change my mind though because as I read more and more over people's comments I felt like there was more evidence against Chevre at the moment instead of Reinoe. So I changed my vote because I was hoping that during day 2 I could then find more evidence to help bring Reinoe down. But, I was obviously wrong so it wasn't a scummy play, it was just a bad read.

[startfromtheheart]

another day of 1 big wagon and not much else

hmmm i hope that's a good omen

UNVOTE:

anen is at l-1 btw ladies and gents

[startfromtheheart]

L-2 not L-1, worst typo ever.

[Antihero]

hmmm i hope that's a good omen

it's not

broodking especially is making me rethink this

[Antihero]

UNVOTE: for a second

[BipolarChemist]

Official Vote Count

Aneninen (3):

Misaka Network, Guyett, BroodKingEXE

chaoslord54 (1):

Konowa

Antihero (1):

Aneninen

Not Voting

: Boonskiies, chaoslord54, evilpacman18, don_johnson, startfromtheheart, antihero

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Time Till Deadline: (expired on 2014-07-25 23:00:00)

[BroodKingEXE]

Okay so I will explain the reason why I dropped originally the Reinoe vote and focused on Chevre. Because I started to lean towards Chevre being scum but still felt that Reinoe was scummy. I began to change my mind though because as I read more and more over people's comments I felt like there was more evidence against Chevre at the moment instead of Reinoe. So I changed my vote because I was hoping that during day 2 I could then find more evidence to help bring Reinoe down. But, I was obviously wrong so it wasn't a scummy play, it was just a bad read.

Okay, D2 who's the scummiest player now?

[don_johnson]

I think chaos should be full claiming.

antihero was my biggest suspect going into night. if you go back you notice him abandoning the chevre wagon just when its getting solid. then he dances around it a bit. I'm not seeing the case on anen.

chaos: what did you do last summer... er night?

misaka: why do you think anti has drawn town?

bert: why are you speculating third party killer?

vote: antihero

starting here. please note my v/la.

[Antihero]

when did i dance around it?

[Antihero]

also, why do you think the chevre wagon went to completion?

[don_johnson]

you were on. you were the downright champion of the wagon. then you jumped off rather unceremoniously. I don't recall you working that hard for anything else except epm, who was basically being condemned for not doing stuff. you voted bert at one point. you never really addressed the chevre wagon again, until you vote him again with little to no explanation as to why you are voting him and/or dropping the epm case(you also spent some time grouping your other suspects as "scum with chevre"). then you unvoted him, stated his posting was town and that he'd probably not flip scum. then you acquiesced to the lynch due to a looming deadline and the appearance of the softclaim, BUT did nothing about it.

do you have a better way to describe your actions? cause to me, "dancing around the chevre wagon" sounds spot on. but whatevz.

also, why do you think the chevre wagon went to completion?

um... because he got lynched? because active players campaigned and voted for him. of which you did neither.

[evilpacman18]

reread and short notes FINALLY incoming.

[Antihero]

um... because he got lynched? because active players campaigned and voted for him. of which you did neither.

oh yes i did.

read the fakegod/me exchange yesterday.

that's

why the chevre wagon went to completion.

[evilpacman18]

from like middle of page 6 because this is the first thing that pinged:

Guyett looks scummy in response to reinoe saying he is an RVS vote leftover. Especially with reinoe's tone in that post, it's pretty forced to read him as scum from it. Like that's clear anti-town but not scum play and Guyett would have picked up on that I think.
Anti picking up on that is comforting. so is 144
I don't think reinoe is scum after his turn around on how Konowa should be responded to... I think scum would tunnel that town read. And given Chevre interactions with reinoe I think he's pretty town.
don_johnson, I had a scum read on him at some point. I think I'm coming back to that.
moving back towards town on Guy around 207
Boonskiies is super looking out for Chevre in 321, doesn't seem like he would've been concerned about anyone else like that? associative tell?
huh about 326... I guess context is important. Sorry Anti.
I can't think of a better word for dj's posts than flaccid and he's never seemed that way to me in the past

ok that's half. the other half soon.

[evilpacman18]

someone tell me if we're still feeling the same as p.15 on dj scum

[startfromtheheart]

?

Reinoe is dead

[evilpacman18]

oh

[evilpacman18]

good I was right

[chaoslord54]

I feel right that EPM is coming off the scummiest. He's been lurking almost the entire game, all of his current reads are based off of older posts that have already been discussed and then tries to play off the fact that Reinoe's death proves his reads because he didn't know Reinoe was dead? I call bs.

Vote:Evilpacman18

[evilpacman18]

what part of that seems like "trying to play off not knowing" to you without you having to project some intent that's nowhere to be found in the posts onto me?

[chaoslord54]

The thing that betrays you on the idea of not knowing is the fact that you took a V/LA to catch up on everything and then in639 when the day ends you then mention that you're going to take time to read everything over. Then you lurk more and finally when you start posting you bring things up that are slightly irrelevant at the moment and then say you didn't notice Reinoe was dead. That's bs because with all the time you've been taking to "catch up" you should actually be having more to contribute then just some remarks that aren't too helpful and then play it off in 742 of trying to be right because then you just happened to notice Reinoe was dead.

Also, you were never a supporter on the lynching of Chevre and although I was hesitant at first, I still leaned on the idea that Chevre was scum. You though never supported it. So I call scum.

[evilpacman18]

I think you just don't get the concept of catch up posting. If I suddenly just appeared and had reads everyone would have to be asking me a bazillion questions about how I came to my conclusions. Catch up posting, at least the way I intend it, just covers some essential read-related thoughts that I've had so that if let's say I finish my read and vote DJ, there's some chronological trail in my short notes that leads to that being an understandable conclusion for me. It's essentially short nuggets of posts that I would have elaborated more on probably if I was actually present at the time the posts I'm reading were more relevant.

Also, you were never a supporter on the lynching of Chevre and although I was hesitant at first, I still leaned on the idea that Chevre was scum. You though never supported it. So I call scum.

this isn't even worth a response.

[evilpacman18]

Annnnnn is town, dudes

[evilpacman18]

Well... Maybe not
Get back to you on that

[chaoslord54]

I think you just don't get the concept of catch up posting. If I suddenly just appeared and had reads everyone would have to be asking me a bazillion questions about how I came to my conclusions. Catch up posting, at least the way I intend it, just covers some essential read-related thoughts that I've had so that if let's say I finish my read and vote DJ, there's some chronological trail in my short notes that leads to that being an understandable conclusion for me. It's essentially short nuggets of posts that I would have elaborated more on probably if I was actually present at the time the posts I'm reading were more relevant.

That may explain some of it, but you still haven't really answered on how you missed that Reinoe was dead.