Mini 1746: Molla's Grand Idea Mafia

[Expedience]

If we don't get a counter claim we have to believe the vet claim.

A counterclaim is meaningless considering the setup.

[Fire Starter]

So you're claiming the role name "vet"? What does that mean, you heal animals?? Tell me exactly what your role does. Please nobody else answer, I want to hear Fire Starter's response.

For realz? Can I also have that ability because that's be sweet.
I'm a paranoid gun owner. I'm just used to off site calling it a veteran. I play lots of town of salem.

Not Jester.

[Expedience]

Which one of these scum PGOs are you, then?

[Fire Starter]

Take a guess.

[BBmolla]

i would not allow scum innocent child. In same vain no mafia Mason's or werewolf lovers.

[Expedience]

Werewolf one-shot PGO.

[Expedience]

i would not allow scum innocent child. In same vain no mafia Mason's or werewolf lovers.

Okay.

I'm thinking that JohnnyFarrar initially thought he was an innocent child that could choose when to reveal.

[Fire Starter]

*buzzer* nope. Try again. Literally the only town role there that I'm describing.

[Diego1487]

If we don't get a counter claim we have to believe the vet claim.

A counterclaim is meaningless considering the setup.

You're right. I wasn't thinking about scum counter claiming just to kill fire starter.

[Expedience]

A paranoid knife owner is not a paranoid gun owner. It is neither a veteran, nor a survivor.

I asked you to tell me exactly what your role did for a reason, and you didn't describe a paranoid knife owner.

[Fire Starter]

For all intents and purposes, yeah it is. If you want to fucking start a mob because of my phrasing, then god damn your either dumb town or scum.

[Fire Starter]

And I never explained what my role did for a reason.

[Diego1487]

Bullet is fire starter who you thought was the vig or sk or whatever you thought?

[Diego1487]

Never mind I forgot bullet replaced. I guess this question goes to expedience.

[Expedience]

Bullet is fire starter who you thought was the vig or sk or whatever you thought?

I'm not quite sure what you're asking, but at a guess I think Lucky was shot by a vigilante. He came across as really scummy to me when I was reading through. Really, a SK is no different to any other faction since there's probably only one of the same faction at this point.

And yeah, I feel vaguely like Fire Starter's telling the truth here? I would still probably vote him over Skybird though.

UNVOTE: Fire Starter
VOTE: dramonic

[Skybird]

UNVOTE:

I'm listening expedience. Let's rock this game out.

[Expedience]

I also thought that Vedith was very town, I didn't realise until now that Fire Starter replaced him. Just really hate survivors.

Actually, when looking at how there were 3 kills and 2 could be accounted for by Lucky and SirCakez, I don't see why both Skybird / Fire Starter can't be town, since there could be 5 scum instead of 6. So I change my answer to: there isn't a vigilante, dramonic is scum and the source of the third kill.

[dramonic]

That's a pretty fucking dumb theory.
I'd have shot Diego on D1.

[Skybird]

Dram, do you have any theories of who might be scum with one of the flipped ones?

[dramonic]

Geez, have you not been reading the game?

[dramonic]

Srsly, you've asked me like 5 times to explain my scumread on BNL...
and now you ask who I think is scum.

[Skybird]

I'm reading the game Dram. You have just been unmemorable in your cases.

[dramonic]

Considering you asked me several time where my scumread on BNL was coming from, I'm pretty certain you should be perfectly aware who I'm scumreading him.
IT SEEMS LOGICAL TO ME!

[Expedience]

That's a pretty fucking dumb theory.
I'd have shot Diego on D1.

Self-meta is not at all convincing.

Considering you asked me several time where my scumread on BNL was coming from, I'm pretty certain you should be perfectly aware who I'm scumreading him.
IT SEEMS LOGICAL TO ME!

Your stance on BNL

has

been reasonably consistent, but it's one-dimensional in the same way that your push on Diego is.

[Expedience]

Seriously, I can't see how you could possibly still be entertaining the possibility that Diego is scum. There's a greater than 99.9% chance that a quadruplevoter is town, if I calculated correctly. Even so:

I hate to use arguments like this, but the way that his restriction was enacted mid-game shows that he's town. If he was scum, it would've become immediately obvious to BBMolla that his role was broken from the start. It was introduced mid-game because not adding it pseudo-confirms him as town.

The fact that you continue to push him after this astounds me. I conclude that it's some sort of "why would scum anger the quadruplevoter hes just honestly really dumb!!" thing.