New Year's Eve Masquerade Ball - [Game Over]

[Parama]

his point was an argument in favor of cerb being scum

you agreed with his post

his post called cerb scummy

what other conclusion am i expected to draw here?

[Dunnstral]

Only way she is scum is she is scum with Dunn

Why

[Gamma Emerald]

it wasn't directed at you it was @maria

What do you mean you can't follow it

From page 54 on I'm asking people their thoughts on Kagami

That's more helpful
gimme a sec

[Gamma Emerald]

I never said Cerb is scummy for what Jester said.

way behind but this sticks out to me as a bold faced lie.

You explicitly said you agreed with jester's reasoning for scum reading cerb

Why are you trying to pass off any blame to jester?

If you don't understand the meaning of me saying "he has a point" and "he is scum because of what Jester said" then even god can't help you.

So you admit to the charges I have filed against you.

[Parama]

the most irritating thing is

i have been given no reasons to townread you shadow

why do you expect my scumread to just go away, when you've done nothing to warrant such?

why should i stop calling you out, when i'm only given more and more evidence to suggest you're scum?

[Gamma Emerald]

Kagami is townlean

[Parama]

i'm gonna actually attempt to catch up proper 'cause there's been 20 pages since i did a nice good read of the thread and i figure it's probably important to see all of that
but i'm gonna try and avoid spamming the thread too much otherwise the problem will just get worse (seriously guys chill a bit)

[Parama]

Anyone scum reading Shadow should be voting him, regardless to Maria's align (secret - It's scum!).

i legitimately don't understand how you can have this opinion

like okay let's just say that there is one universe in a hundred where shadow is town
why would scum pair with the sinking ship that likely isn't going to survive to intermission over the easily manipulateable lurker?
i'll grant that neither of them are great choices but one of them is more likely to survive than the other

but the other 99 universes shadow is scum anyways and if maria was scum with him she'd have left him behind for bussing credit

[Parama]

like gonna be honest i have made absolutely no attempt to read maria because her alignment is at this point completely irrelevant

[Parama]

vedith on page 36 is just pretty generally bad tbh. his arguments either rooted in meta (inherently bad) or just outright absurd (dunn + maria scum and then maria paired with shadow scum instead of dunn, this is like, tinfoil conspiracists laughing at your tinfoil hat bad)

wouldn't cry over seeing him lynched but eyes on the prize, shadow's gotta flip red for me first

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Only way she is scum is she is scum with Dunn so there is no way I'm getting lynched today.

No no no no no.

Like.

No.

You don't get to fucking do this.

[Gamma Emerald]

vedith on page 36 is just pretty generally bad tbh. his arguments either rooted in meta (inherently bad) or just outright absurd (dunn + maria scum and then maria paired with shadow scum instead of dunn, this is like, tinfoil conspiracists laughing at your tinfoil hat bad)

wouldn't cry over seeing him lynched but eyes on the prize, shadow's gotta flip red for me first

No actually what Vedith is saying makes sense
MariaR was very averse to pairing with Dunnstral. Me too, but the point is it feels like she was making a show of it.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Unvote

Vote: Shadow

This goes first today.

[Parama]

Might be the overexplanation/defensiveness of trying to defend Jester and making it clear she isn't going to determine his alignment

i don't really find this alignment indicative at all, just really, really stupid. i believe MDS in that she joined just to play with jester.

that aside, jester is likely scum anyways so i mean, this isn't a -bad- lynch. i don't really have much of a read either way on MDS but she was smart enough to figure out the scumslip from shadow right away so she's got that going for her at the very least

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Only way she is scum is she is scum with Dunn so there is no way I'm getting lynched today.

No no no no no.

Like.

No.

You don't get to fucking do this.

Ftr this is one of my strongest scumtells because I usually tend to use it A LOT as scum.

The pulling "you don't dare lynch me today"/"I'm not getting lynched today" card.

[MariaR]

vedith on page 36 is just pretty generally bad tbh. his arguments either rooted in meta (inherently bad) or just outright absurd (dunn + maria scum and then maria paired with shadow scum instead of dunn, this is like, tinfoil conspiracists laughing at your tinfoil hat bad)

wouldn't cry over seeing him lynched but eyes on the prize, shadow's gotta flip red for me first

No actually what Vedith is saying makes sense
MariaR was very averse to pairing with Dunnstral. Me too, but the point is it feels like she was making a show of it.

This is fucking scum parroting something someone else said

[MariaR]

you're saying the most basic thing someone can ever say to throw shade "It looks fake" I SAID THE EXACT SAME FUCKING THING LAST GAME SO HOW THE FUCK DOES IT LOOK FAKE THIS GAME

[MariaR]

Did I ever go like "oh I would've just paired with dunn as scum have no reason to stall duhh" no I just didn't want to fucking pair with dunn and wanted to pair with shadow while dunn gets someone else to deal with is that so hard to get through your head

[Parama]

1 thing I will say, if Gamma is scum, then Maria isn't, however, if he's town, then I'm deadset on Maria being scum.

let's gather round the campfire, and sing the false dichotomy song

[MariaR]

This isn't gamma's town game by a LONG SHOT
I wanted him left but he panicked and asked Vedith because I knew I wanted his ass left out and then threw shade my way when I was the one who left sick

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

@Mod: Would it be possible to order the vote counts from people who have the most votes on them to the least please?

Sorry if it's a bother and I understand if you're on the phone and can't do it etc, just one of the pet peeves of mine :/

[Gamma Emerald]

vedith on page 36 is just pretty generally bad tbh. his arguments either rooted in meta (inherently bad) or just outright absurd (dunn + maria scum and then maria paired with shadow scum instead of dunn, this is like, tinfoil conspiracists laughing at your tinfoil hat bad)

wouldn't cry over seeing him lynched but eyes on the prize, shadow's gotta flip red for me first

No actually what Vedith is saying makes sense
MariaR was very averse to pairing with Dunnstral. Me too, but the point is it feels like she was making a show of it.

This is fucking scum parroting something someone else said

I'm axknowledging the fact you didn't want to pair with me when that devalues my case
Why would I do that as scum?

[MariaR]

Shadow isn't scum btw I am fairly sure on that now and gamma is just spewing w/e he can to try to get us lynched while Vedith is just...Vedith

[MariaR]

vedith on page 36 is just pretty generally bad tbh. his arguments either rooted in meta (inherently bad) or just outright absurd (dunn + maria scum and then maria paired with shadow scum instead of dunn, this is like, tinfoil conspiracists laughing at your tinfoil hat bad)

wouldn't cry over seeing him lynched but eyes on the prize, shadow's gotta flip red for me first

No actually what Vedith is saying makes sense
MariaR was very averse to pairing with Dunnstral. Me too, but the point is it feels like she was making a show of it.

This is fucking scum parroting something someone else said

I'm axknowledging the fact you didn't want to pair with me when that devalues my case
Why would I do that as scum?

Because if you didn't I would've called your ass out on it

[Shadow_step]

I don't want you to TR me, you're scum reading me for the wrong reasons which isn't my fault.
I said he had a point which was the setup spec thing I didn't agree with his whole goddamn post.