In post 1156, Gamma Emerald wrote: In post 875, RadiantCowbells wrote:KillTheStory (9): drealmerz7, The DEO, RachMarie, Creature, Klingoncelt, LycanFire, Creeps20, Gamma Emerald
GE votes both (is voteless Day 2 and 4)
Postie votes RM (is voteless)
The DEO votes both
Creature votes both
Zefiend votes RM (could not vote D1)
drealmerz votes both
JR votes RM
Klingon votes both
Lycan votes KTS
Creeps votes KTS
In post 1040, Deimos27 wrote:Anyway, that's gonna be it from me for today. Reading and analysing those 35 pages was super tiring already, so d2 can wait till tomorrow.
so this is why deimos' reads were awful. without RM as top scumread, his reads were fair enough to have, but his auxiliary scumreads make no sense with RM as top read because they were on both wagons. the main problem is that he gave us these reads as a result of a faulty VCA. the only reason to bring up the composition of the day 1 wagon is to use it for day 2 (super obvious) and to use it as a mechanism to develop reads has the motive of finding scum to lynch. so in the context of day 2 ISOing RC for a day 2 vote count was apparently too hard to get reads that matter.
tldr if rach is scum, KTS was a scumwagon and rach is a townwagon. suspecting DEO, drealmers makes no sense because they were on top of both wagons. he threw shade on creature and nullread him (despite having an opinion on him) while creature is on both. this is after the fact, but creeps20 has joined both wagons since deimos' #1037 post, someone deimos omitted.
if KTS was primarily scumdriven, then deimos' post trying to pin when it was pushed is a good attempt at analysis. my problem is that he throws out the part where 3 people voted SS within 20 posts, and focuses more on his critique of drealmerz (who made one of the townier pushes on KTS) then fills in the rest of his reads without consideration of the previous. it felt like a very "i want a mislynch but i don't want to appear to only want to contribute a mislynch today" post.
if deimos' top read was anyone besides RM there would be no consistency issue.
that's why i'm weary of lynching RM and poked both of them about it. i've only gotten silence about it. i'd expect townies to want to work with me. ignoring me has scum motive where they pray i don't have a scumtell and get interested in someone else.
regardless i want to do a reread. i thought rach was annoying not scummy.