First, @Mathdino:
A) Why did you just say something to one line of the post? Ignoring everything else looks like you're trying to avoid points that you simply can't counter.
B) It's funny that you bring up Slayer's Gambit specifically. I don't think that was coincidence. I think you've read Inferno's Meta and knowingly chose that gambit, or are using it because that's what you believe he's doing here. Well, this is just 'Ferno's playstyle; messy and aggressive, while I like to ask questions and feel out scum most of the time.
In response to point A above, it feels to me like the way you are responding in this exchange is in attempt to force a policy lynch on us without really having anything to back it up. PL describes the lynch of a player who is not found to be particularly scummy, but because the player's bad play will hurt the town later on.
-- From Wiki
So what you've done is turn what you're saying about my play from "This is scum" to "this is not scum, but bad and hurtful town play." Which 1) you're already scumreading us, so why are you trying to policy lynch us, and 2) It's an incredibly AoP move on only half a hydra.
Also, when I mention that game, I was not trying to use Slayer's Gambit, in fact I had never heard of it. I simply got lucky in the fact that I used it and drew out scum. My point is not that I used it, but that you're using the "The wiki meta is crap" defense to ignore my reasoning, which is that your use of scummy is not supported by the meta.
Second (Still at Mathdino): #216 feels really weird and fabricated to me. It's coming off as short and kind of almost skirting the questions, but not really doing so.
Third:
Mathdino wrote: In post 193, TheGoldenParadox wrote:Mathdino is town. I will literally quit mafiascum if math is scum here.
Effortpost tommorrow, too tired today.
Wow huh did I actually roll into my first game with scum Paradox
Also I'm basically down to policy lynch brafin at this point
They're never getting NKd if their reads include gems like
- BuJaber getting annoyed at BJ is alignment indicative
- Beefster scumslipped by saying TW and I share alignment
I have no idea what you're talking about. What post are you referencing?
- Beefsterscum purposefully took an RVS vote as serious for ~reasons~
That doesn't strike you as even a little weird? It was an obvious joke post?
- Either I think IB is a jester or I'm admitting I'm scum
Inferno just clued me in. More below.
Hey IB I guess I'm scum
- Mathdino is scum for being defensive
It's not your defensiveness that pings me, it's how bad your defense actually is. It feels like you're looking for a way to cover up a bad scumread.
Inferno: Beyond this, I've already mentioned how massively misrepresentative the first two are. Nowhere have I said those are AI.
For point 3, it occurred to me another reason to play scummy: you're a PR trying to avoid the NK. But no matter how you spin this, there's no way for you to call our play intentionally scummy and not also call us town. Why would scum play intentionally scummy?
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
genuinely not sure.