OK. Here's an update.
Remorald -- I think his comments about me are a stretch. I get lost and confused easily. You can see evidence this in the Large games I've been in, in which the game size was just too much in me. In both of these Large games I was town, so it's not a scummy thing. It was difficult for me to start scumhunting up to that point because I'd mostly seen a bunch of talk about vote counts, multiple votes, and weird role talk from forbiddan and DTF that left me pretty much in the dark. I have never been good at just diving into these sorts of things and picking them apart until things really start to get going, so the issue really is that I wanted to post to let you guys know I was trying not to lurk, but I also needed to be honest and let you know that I hadn't found anything to comment on. I also expressed why.
I don't see anything wrong with that, but I've said this in several games and I'll say it again: stretching things is a necessity to get things out of the random voting stage. So I can understand why Remorald would jump on me for my comment and I don't find it especially scummy. I may find it scummy later if he continues to beat this drum, but at the moment, I think it's good to overreact in order to get the game going. He should eventually be able to admit that he's stretching, however. At the moment it's a nulltell.
Do I think that DTF's votes are OMGUS? I think there's some OMGUS-iness in a few of them. DTF has admitted that. His OMGUS votes seem a little like random/joke votes, do they not? (Danchaofan, Citizen Karne.) I don't as a rule find joke OMGUS scummy, but I kind of wish DTF would take those votes off because I don't think they're necessary anymore. Do I find his OMGUS votes scummy? No. Bad play? Maybe. The rolefishing accusation thing is kind of iffy. I'm not a big fan of that. forbiddanlight 1/3 claimed, then 2/3 claimed. DTF forced her to claim the other third. I don't like that, but the way he went about it doesn't read as particularly scummy to me, I dunno.
DTF, I am not sure what the "White Elephant" thing means. I asked the mod and he said he would not answer that question, and made an evil emoticon at me. I am not a "White Elephant" as far as I know. That does not have any connection to my role that I can imagine, and I have quite the vivid imagination.
One thing I've found so far is a small note of hypocrisy from veerus. When he was confused about the voting system, he attempted to vote for everyone at the same time. (It would only have been necessary to vote for about 3 people to test this, by the way.) Then he voted DTF for voting "pretty much everybody" (fewer people than he attempted to vote!) He'd probably argue that he would have unvoted most people immediately after figuring out that he had multiple votes had it worked, but I don't really buy it. I see it as just a reason to cast a vote and look useful. (Now I'M the hypocritical one, I know, but hey, at least I'm admitting it!) His last post was another sort of psuedo-scumhunting post that didn't really serve any purpose. Yeah, my case on veerus is a stretch. And that's what it's supposed to be at this point in the game.
Vote: veerus
"Time forks endlessly toward innumerable futures. In one of them I am your enemy." —Jorge Luis Borges