RVS reads:
Gaiden townish, the eagerness to post first that strongly doesn't make me feel newscum.
notscience townish as well, I feel making a first post that is relevant to someone you already know means you're comfortable with what you're posting, i.e. townvibes.
Titus null SE talk
mail-mi scummish, the 'guize' feels forced and faked. I haven't seen anyone use that way of typing in in years. Admittedly it's already stupid since it's a self-vote but that doesn't redeem the tone of the post.
Verbs null
JKM had a similar thought process to myself regarding Mail's selfvote, so I automatically think he's relatively town.
Considering mail's experience mentioned in 15, I'd have expected him to have voted someone after the unvote, doesn't change my read.
Titus looks a little worse off, the parenthesis in 16 feel like an afterthought added to make his previous statement more inoffensive
17 he redeems himself though, that feels like something that comes from town regarding PRs, scum wouldn't have that on their minds yet (They'd prefer a possible mail!PR screwing up somehow)
notscience and Gaiden townreads strengthen
As of the beginning of page 2, mail-mi has failed to attempt to create content, which while I would understand coming from a newbie, reflects badly on him a.a.r of him having experience.
JKM continues to follow my train of thought down the page, strengthened town read.
Verbs still tastes null.
Titus mentioning FoS's puts him down to scummish again, as at that point he hadn't mentioned any suspicions at all yet, which indicates a lack of searching for them.
@Gaiden
- in post 33 you mentioned you thought of it being a WIFOM situation - About when did this idea occur to you, thread-wise?
@Gaiden
- If you've never dealt with it, why did you suspect Mail of WIFOM?
asked by Titus, nvm
@Brian
- How much experience do you have with Mafia?
reserving Brian read till answer
answered
Verbs is asking for opinions which reflects nicely as a newbie
Gaiden's attitude regarding WIFOM strengthens my townread on her still, her thought process when she said 'I never had to deal with WIFOM' is sensible, since she's only played as scum before.
End of page 2 and Mail read is the same, see above, he lacks deliverance after his supposed 'content creation'.
Brian doesn't have much Mafia experience, so the earlier role related questions probably aren't faked. If he was a Goon/RB he'd probably at least have some awareness of what's going on in the setup, so light townread as from what I can tell so far he doesn't seem savvy enough to fake that.
Disagree with JKM & notscience, I didn't see much buddying behaviour, not to mention that is an outdated scumtell
and
that Titus is an SE. Titus votes at this point aren't bad though, just for other reasons.
Dislike Titus's 58, he should have mentioned the above ^^^ as a counter to the buddying accusation, not attack someone off his wagon.
61 from Mail furthers my scumread, he's done jack-all at this point, three days into the game, this isn't town motivation from an 'experienced' player.
Gaiden's random chip-ins are starting to leave a bad taste in my mouth, lowers my townread some.
I liked Verbs's pressure on Mail until I realized Verbs still has his old Titus vote on him, doesn't feel good and a possible buddy association with either of those two, though I might be getting ahead of myself.
@Titus
- post 73 - Why not just up and vote Notscience at that point? You already declared your suspicion of him. It just comes across as meek and spineless.
Verbs's thought process w/r/t Titus on top of Page 4 is good, however his nipping at Mail earlier still makes me feel bad.
Titus isn't redeeming himself. As a whole, scum like to latch onto specific, singular things without looking at the big picture in order to simplify their manufactured scumhunting/make their jobs easier, this feels like this behavior.
Nacho will take me some time to read, but he saw what I saw on Verbs so that's a good sign.
Titus
- by post 84, what did you make of notscience's push on you? What is your read on Verbs?
Liking Brian more w/r/t his attitude.
. 