NS 95 wrote:If you defended beast any harder......
I don't know if I'd characterize it as "defending", but I guess you could put it that way.
---
cxinlee 96 wrote:Could you elaborate? Both of his posts are just fluff so far.
Using random.org to vote, as has been brought up, is scummy. His response to sns calling him out was a joke, but sns brought up a serious point. Why not engage sns either positively or negatively? It seemed like he was dodging the issue.
cxinless 98 wrote:seems like a town slip, because the setup is actually nightless.
Oh, good point. I hadn't considered that. Yeah, I'm good with sns now.
---
SiX 102 wrote:That was obviously an unserious vote in case you didn't notice.
If it wasn't serious, why did you trouble yourself to use random.org? Why didn't you just pick a name yourself? Why did you ignore sns' valid criticism?
---
Snarky 107 wrote:RedCoyote: My post was unclear. My list of scum players is all the players that have pinged my scumdar for a reason or another, not just those who have interacted scummily with beast's theory. You are on there because of your post 24, which was a copycat of what Aegor had already said previously.
But I liked your last post, so I remove you and cxinlee from my scumlist for now, cxinlee because of the townslip thing.
Understood. I also agree with you about cxinlee.
---
sns 111 wrote:Don't remove cxinlee just yet. Regardless of his alignment, due to the nature of my role(which I will not delve into yet), he basically knows I'm town. So yes, sticking up and saying it was a townslip is town, but scum could easily know this and use it to make themselves seem town and get on my side by sticking up for me. I'm not calling scum, I'm simply saying don't rule it out because of that.
Here we go...
Why did you drop this out so early? Also, I see a supposed contradiction that you need to clear up.
sns 111 wrote:due to the nature of my role [...] he basically knows I'm town
sns 112 wrote: Given what he knows about me he should've thought of me as scum
These two statements contradict one another, I think.
---
Snarky 113 wrote:Also, how is the townslip in any way related to you? RedCoyote made it...
As I understand it, cxinlee was referring to the person I was referencing in that quote (sns) as the person that committed the townslip. Whereas I thought it was scummy for him to consider scumtalk in the way he did, cxinlee argues that it should be seen as a townslip that sns didn't realize there can't be "night talk" between scum in this game.
Kind of confusing, I know, lol. If you go back and read the appropriate posts, it should be more clear though.