Mafiascum.net

In post 1057, Infinity 324 wrote:

In post 1047, Tigerente wrote:i don't mind kerset's posting since he came back honestly

What do you think about the post where he was like "people are scumreading me because of meta" without offering a counterargument or even mentioning that it oddly doesn't apply this game

That post felt very scummy to me

In post 1059, Infinity 324 wrote:

In post 1055, Tigerente wrote:why would i do that day1 here

Your team is in massive trouble, and your goal is to gain enough towncred by bussing kerset to protect cakez in the future

In post 1076, Tigerente wrote:like it's not great but i guess i feel like he would try more if scum here
or like be anxious about the fact a maassive wagon popped on him
or something

he's just not

In post 1065, Infinity 324 wrote:Skitt when you get back I'd like to talk to you about gamma. I feel like his play here is a huge contrast to panic room and you should probably put some weight on my read on him.

In post 1080, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:Skitter I don't know if Bork ever told you this but there was a game where he/cakez were scum and I was pushing cakez and he voted cakez and then I told him that he was bussing cakez so he decided to vote his other scum partner at the time to bus the other partner instead :>

<3 bork

In post 1070, Infinity 324 wrote:

In post 1066, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:I’m scumreading gamma too

Can you explain how he’s different from panic room? because I made a comparison thinking he was similar

- lilith

He's different in, like, every way? In panic room he was awkward and all over the place, here he's calm and treating the game like an intellectual exercise

You said his defense of cakez was like his defense of murder in panic room which again, I don't see the resemblance at all. In panic room there was way more desperation and the reasoning didn't justify the strength of the read, here he doesn't feel compelled to justify himself. Umlaut's reason for TRing gamma was related to this and was a very good one.

In post 1073, Infinity 324 wrote:Dw bork we all sucked that game

In post 1080, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:Skitter I don't know if Bork ever told you this but there was a game where he/cakez were scum and I was pushing cakez and he voted cakez and then I told him that he was bussing cakez so he decided to vote his other scum partner at the time to bus the other partner instead :>

<3 bork

In post 1044, Tigerente wrote:

In post 853, SirCakez wrote:

In post 851, Dwlee99 wrote:I feel like the game stalling on a wagon is not normally indicative that they are on town??

if the wagons were on scum presumably we'd see counterwagon attempts, no?

isn't kerset your counterwagon, no?

In post 1081, Infinity 324 wrote:

In post 1076, Tigerente wrote:like it's not great but i guess i feel like he would try more if scum here
or like be anxious about the fact a maassive wagon popped on him
or something

he's just not

Is this a meta thing or? Idk I feel like if scum doesn't know what to do you shouldn't townread them for doing nothing

PEdit: @skitt I don't really agree but it doesn't really matter

In post 273, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 222, xHeavenx wrote:

In post 218, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:@heaven what’s your opinion on cakes voting you and our current discussion of whether it is scummy for me to be pushing cakes for it?

- lilith

Your own reasoning is fine but mine slightly differs. I don't like what cakez is doing because it's awkward. I said pointless earlier and then his response to that was that he was making a joke. Jokes usually require a bit of knowledge or even a setup but there I think he was just excusing himself. His words come out only at the concern of others and even then I just don't really believe him.

I like this post, question is whether it’s town indicative

In post 282, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 247, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 223, Datisi wrote:i didn't. but considering you're not revealing the reason, it's quite literally no use to me. i cannot tell the difference between town!lilith having an actual tell vs. a scum!lilith going "hehe guys i have a tell on cakez, no i will not tell you~"

really?

I don't think she needs to out the tell for you to have an opinion on whether she believes she has a tell on cakes or not.

On this subject, I’m thinking Cakez is town because of how he reacted to the unspoken tell situation, I remember him in two prior cases involving such things, once as town and once as scum, and his reaction feels similar to but not exactly the same as his reaction as town in the prior situation.

In post 287, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 268, Almost50 wrote:Interesting! "Vairy" interesting!! (The Gamma take on me is).

At first I thought he was joking or pulling a reaction test, whichever. But the more I read the more it felt like he is serious, and the question now is to figure if it's an "innocent genuine" suspicion or if it's because we know each other well and he wants me out ASAP.

Actually it was a reaction test, I knew my read was tenuous at best, so I feigned confidence to try to gauge your response
I feel decently well about it I think
UNVOTE:

In post 374, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 368, xHeavenx wrote:

In post 366, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 361, xHeavenx wrote:

In post 354, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 320, xHeavenx wrote:

In post 265, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 214, xHeavenx wrote:I feel like half of the posts I'm reading so far are heavily influenced by meta on the other players and it's making me feel left out.

Do you have any thoughts of your own?

Not too much I'd be willing to commit to but I'll try my best. Limit is the one person I think is just town. A lot of the other people I'm not getting a sense of who they are, rather what they claim. The decisive arguments I want to see instead turn into what seems like bickering mostly.

I think Limit trying to persuade others with their own experience with cakez is the most townie thing in the game so far. Their words really jumped out at me, and it didn't seem like they were just showboating. It was an attempt to understand but also generate reads, which is what I tend to look for.

Are you generally an analytical person?

I think therefore I am?

Is that a serious answer?
Depending on whether the answer is yes or no to the original question, it will affect how I read you.

It's a serious answer. I can't tell you the reason for why my thoughts come out this way, they just do.

I'll interpret these combined responses as a yes
Which means I unfortunately cannot comfortably call you town for your thought process just yet, since I was wanting to TR your depth of thought, but it seems that's just how you are as a person.

In post 1056, Tigerente wrote:

In post 991, SirCakez wrote:@people who know Skitter well
Would she go in to WK and probably pocket a townie in trouble as scum?

do u think i'm scum doing this

In post 1088, Tigerente wrote:i would start a non-sircakez wagon on any of the other lhf slots not named kerset