Mafiascum.net

VC 2.3

Not voting (1):

the worst

the worst (6) (HAMMER):

Dunnstral, implosion, Almost50, Something_Smart, Scipio1, Save The Dragons

implosion (3):

Battle Mage, PookytheMagicalBear, Salsabil Faria

[/spoiler]

VC 3.0

Not voting (8):

Scipio1, Something_Smart, Dunnstral, Salsabil Faria, Save The Dragons, implosion, PookytheMagicalBear, Almost50

(expired on 2021-04-16 01:10:36) until deadline

happy scumday dunny

VOTE: Dunnstral

dunn who do you think is scum

In post 1093, Almost50 wrote:

In post 1069, Something_Smart wrote:So we're waiting on Scipio, Salsa, and A50 to counterclaim/not counterclaim.

Looking back at it, I probably should have just CC'd.

A50 can you explain this? Was this not intended to be a soft-CC?

In post 1104, Save The Dragons wrote:dunn who do you think is scum

Who knows

awesome

In post 1105, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 1093, Almost50 wrote:

In post 1069, Something_Smart wrote:So we're waiting on Scipio, Salsa, and A50 to counterclaim/not counterclaim.

Looking back at it, I probably should have just CC'd.

A50 can you explain this? Was this not intended to be a soft-CC?

I'd rather leave it to your best judgement.

Were you intending to make people think you were follower?

If so why?

Once again: I'll leave that to you better judgement.

The question is: Do you TR me or SR me? If you TR me don't ask silly questions (that you probably know the the answer to). If you SR me go ahead and make a direct case rather than beat around the bush. Finally, if you're Scum.. well GOOD LUCK (cuz you're probably going to need it)

My case is that you soft CC'd follower to get a PR executed and now you're being dodgy about it.

I don't necessarily think you're scum, but I don't see how it benefits town for you to be cryptic right now.

Like, I made a a case on Mini well before I said that. So how the hell was I soft-CC'ing?

I fully believed she was lying scum and I wanted to draw the NK, only it occurred to me to do that too late. The elimination itself was NOT a result of that post, but of her bad wording of "went nowhere" which is never what a Follower gets.

I don't think A50's 'soft' is scummy

this slot is scum and/or useless

VOTE: dunnstral

In post 1114, Almost50 wrote:I fully believed she was lying scum and I wanted to draw the NK, only it occurred to me to do that too late. The elimination itself was NOT a result of that post, but of her bad wording of "went nowhere" which is never what a Follower gets.

I guess. I mean, I voted partly because I thought that you might have been implying a CC, just like PP was.

I suppose I shouldn't press it anymore. It's annoying, but within the realm of annoying things I've seen you do before as town

A50 is a valued member of APD which is clearly all town since we keep getting shot at night by nefarious anti-animal actors

I choose to blame the brief site crash yesterday for me not posting yesterday.

While I don't disagree with a Dunn elim in principle the game feels a lot more losable than it did yesterday with mini flipping PR, us possibly having no other PR and needing to lim both scum.

I don't think A50's soft is scummy; I also don't really think he's scum. The only other townread I feel comfortable with right now is Salsabil. Honestly I was probably going to have Battle Mage paranoia today too though I think I'd have managed to get over it. I think the easiest universe is the one in which 2/3 are scum in Dunn, SS, scipio, and that's my current high-interest pool. I should have motivation to do some digging today or this weekend, I feel a bit more motivated than yesterday (it helped having a night phase... this week has been somewhat challenging).

I don't know where I'd be voting today, so I guess I'll sheep chief Pooky

it's between implo and dunn for me

implo cuz battle mage got shot last night and he was all up for killing implo

dunn cuz he's literally done nothing except push town.

maybe they're both baddies who knows.

let's wait for Sergeant Salsa to check in and then pick one of these two to yeet.

got any solid reasoning you'd like to share with the class?

On a skim of Scipio's ISO he hasn't really done anything overtly scummy IMO, the way he was positioning around the mini/dunn/me thing was generally reasonable enough; maybe the most suspicious thing is him being kind of tepid on not wanting mini for the "i aint scum" thing just bc it kind of reads as waffly in a bad way. But I think it really did look like I was going to be the lim yesterday and him waffling in that particular way doesn't exactly benefit him as scum if he's voting for me and I flip town.

He doesn't have the strong townvibes from last game (like I mentioned) but I don't think that really means he's scummy here.