Mafiascum.net

In post 1264, Sephiroth wrote:It seems like how I would respond if I didn't think a wagon really warranted a response because it wasn't that serious. It also seems like how I might respond if I wanted people to think I wasn't taking the wagon that seriously. Thus NAI. Now you go.

I wasn’t asking about whether he thought it was serious, I can see your point there
I’m asking about what about his play looked like he was ignoring the wagon

just fyi, tchill isn't voting BEF right now, so while I'm A-OK with BEF going through today, I would in fact like a claim before hammer.

So if someone wants to take him back to L-2 so tchill doesn't pull a not_mafia quickhammer that would be nice

In post 1276, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1264, Sephiroth wrote:It seems like how I would respond if I didn't think a wagon really warranted a response because it wasn't that serious. It also seems like how I might respond if I wanted people to think I wasn't taking the wagon that seriously. Thus NAI. Now you go.

I wasn’t asking about whether he thought it was serious, I can see your point there
I’m asking about what about his play looked like he was ignoring the wagon

I guess we're having a miscommunication in terminology. The above is what I meant by ignoring the wagon. Not like literally ignore it happening, just not really respond to it in a way that gives it any credence. Sorry if that was a confusing turn of phrase.

nvm I missed PP changing to Gamma, he's still l-2

If post count ever correlated to player alignment, then Tchill flips scum here every time btw

I'm just not sure if that's a good metric, but I think the games DrD linked point heavily to Tchill scum for that as well as the engagement point Sephiroth observed as well

In post 1279, Sephiroth wrote:

In post 1276, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1264, Sephiroth wrote:It seems like how I would respond if I didn't think a wagon really warranted a response because it wasn't that serious. It also seems like how I might respond if I wanted people to think I wasn't taking the wagon that seriously. Thus NAI. Now you go.

I wasn’t asking about whether he thought it was serious, I can see your point there
I’m asking about what about his play looked like he was ignoring the wagon

I guess we're having a miscommunication in terminology. The above is what I meant by ignoring the wagon. Not like literally ignore it happening, just not really respond to it in a way that gives it any credence. Sorry if that was a confusing turn of phrase.

Okay. I see your point and agree it’s possible, but your analysis doesn’t exempt him from being scum, and I just really don’t want to let this go

In post 1279, Sephiroth wrote: I guess we're having a miscommunication in terminology. The above is what I meant by ignoring the wagon. Not like literally ignore it happening, just not really respond to it in a way that gives it any credence. Sorry if that was a confusing turn of phrase.

I should have said, acting like he doesn't care. Not ignoring.

And I think the clearest reason I’ve seen for voting BEF is he didn’t explain his reads?

Oh, I was pre-posted. Twice!

Yes I see your point as well. I think the reaction itself is NAI but I tr him for other reasons. I tr you both atm. I'm still curious what gives you the whole caught scum vibe, though.

Combination of a strong sense of this being his scum meta and also believing even if it isn't he won't contribute much as town. But really I'm fairly confident in this being his scum game after playing 2038 with him. Read Nics ISO and check his meta case on BEF, which was 100% spot on, and compare it to this game then to some other BEF town games. Its a pretty strong correlation.

I’d rather not have to dive a bunch of games rn
Can you just give me a play-by-play of how his meta differs?

To BEF's credit his wife was expecting during our last game together so he's probably got a lot going on at the moment. That being said, its generally --

Town BEF: engages with game, posts reads, attempts to sort people. generally higher activity
Scum BEF: active lurks, actually lurks

My wild 2/3 is DrD + tchill and someone i havent found yet

Should we make it a thing then Joey?

VOTE: Tchill13

@Gamma think there's a chance end of this day should be between Tchill and BEF? Or is PP still better?

Tchill and BEF are both fine by me. I will not vote for PP today.

I would rather not DrD but could be convinced.

What about Mew as a dark horse pick tho

VOTE: tchill sure

Tchill is still one of my scum reads so I'll put my vote back on him.
VOTE: tchill

In post 1294, BrightEyedFish wrote:Tchill is still one of my scum reads so I'll put my vote back on him.
VOTE: tchill

I mean, it's okay, you can in fact just write "Tchill is not me" LOL

Of course that was also a reason, I won't deny that.

BEF who even are these alleged scum reads

In post 1297, Gamma Emerald wrote:BEF who even are these alleged scum reads

A50, tchill and nako

In post 1248, Nako wrote:Very good post. DVa is town.

Agreed. Not because of the post precisely, but because I was finally able to lock her main down without doubt, and this is Town her.