You sent "Thesp" in as your target.
I switched Thesp and Glork.
That means that you actually targeted "Glork."
Thus, the result you got back was "Glork and Thesp."
I omitted 4 because I believe that if DoS were scum, he would've been the guy making the kill last night. I can't see PBuG-Thesp scumgroup not trying to finish the game. Also, option 6 is completely impossible.Mr Stoofer wrote:I don't like that post, and not just because of the last 3 words.
First, Zindie presents his 3 "explanations" as being the only ones possible, but they omit a number of others, including:
4: DragonsofSummer is scum
5: PBuG is scum and didn't kill (for fear that if something went wrong it would be obvious he was scum).
6: PBuG is scum and tried to kill me but Zindie saved me.
And no doubt there are others I have missed...
They probably have different priorities.Secondly, I don't like the way Zindaras dismisses out of hand the possibility that he could be scum. Especially since that would explain why the Scum haven't targeted the doc for 3 nights...
Ah, I get it now. Yeah, I was completely wrong. Can't divulge anything from tonight.Glork wrote:Also... we don'tknowwhether Thesp made the mafia kill. Stoof trackedMEinstead of Thesp, don't forget; so I don't know why we're assuming that Thesp made a kill at all. In fact, given that yesterday he accurately predicted that I targeted Stoof on the previous night, I would expect Thesp toNOTmake the kill so that he could report an accurate Watcher-result.
Consider this possibility:
PBuG targets Glork, Thesp targets Stoofer.
Zindie protects against Thesp's kill; PBuG's kill redirects to Thesp; Thesp dies.
Nobody (except possibly me) is cleared right now. And you two are using a flawed premise in that you're assuming that Thesp made "the Mafia's kill" last night.
I probably would've randomed it. I'm not entirely sure about the math, but I think it could've helped.Zindie -- I explained why I didn't want to use my ability N0. We had a pair of info roles which I didn't want to mess up at the start of the game. It should be apparent that my usage of the Bus Driver ability has been as a protective role -- I've consistently targeted one player whom I thought was town and one player whom I thought was scum. I have no possible way of using the ability like that on N0.
It almost feels like he thinks he just won the game to me...PBuG wrote:DoS, thanks for the stupidity.
It's still distinctly possible that PBuG/Thesp was in fact the scumgroup. DoS's observation of PBuG's post is interesting. I would very much like PBuG to respond to that post. It's possible that Zindie and I turned the tables on what should've been an auto-loss...Glork wrote:Consider this possibility:
PBuG targets Glork, Thesp targets Stoofer.
Zindie protects against Thesp's kill; PBuG's kill redirects to Thesp; Thesp dies.
I was talking about the huge mistake of hammering him so quickly. Maz was town, if you forgot. I wasn't the only one upset about the hammer.DragonsofSummer wrote:It almost feels like he thinks he just won the game to me...PBuG wrote:DoS, thanks for the stupidity.
MajorFoS:PBuG
Rules wrote:The Mafia have to choose someone to send to kill; that'sinsteadof their usual nightchoice, and they are trackable/whatever as such
That you omit yourself as far as suspicions go is fine by me, but not taking yourself into account when calculating chances is absolutely bonkers.Mr Stoofer wrote:That leaves DoS, PBug and Zindaras. We have (at least) two lynches left and so at worst that gives a 67% chance of success.
I was just talking out loud, as it were.Zindaras wrote:That you omit yourself as far as suspicions go is fine by me, but not taking yourself into account when calculating chances is absolutely bonkers.Mr Stoofer wrote:That leaves DoS, PBug and Zindaras. We have (at least) two lynches left and so at worst that gives a 67% chance of success.
PBuG [172] wrote:I'm in agreement with Glork that everyone is pretty suspicious, and Glork is the only player I trust (and, by association, Stoofer).
PBuG [177] wrote:Glork is the only player that seems legitimately pro-town to me. I don't think Stoofer is definitely town, but I trust Glork's judgement thus far.
PBuG [192] wrote:Stoofer is mixed. On one hand, he was very against Vitamin, and tried to hasten his lynch. On the other hand, there are a few actions where it looks like Stoofer is testing the waters with a particular scummy line of thought and then pulls it back when there is discontent, but this is VERY subject to interpretation. Also, Stoofer seems to passively suspect me; he slightly argues for me being scum, but never really does much about it. Plus, in the past, I have attempted to hasten a scumbuddy's lynch to make myself appear as town, and successfully often.
It looks to me as though the real reason he is "suspicious" of me is because of my suggesting that he is scum (i.e. OMGUS).PBuG [221] wrote:I'd vote for either Stoofer or Zindaras. I am starting to lean more towards Stoofer.