Stars Aligned - GAME OVER

[semioldguy]

Perfect game for town

@Percy
I really enjoyed this game. The flavor/theme was a lot of fun and got me really into it. Thanks for modding such a great game!

(will post my other thoughts later)

[Datadanne]

I survived, Sweet.

[SlySly]

I survived, Sweet.

Your time was limited. I was going to stalk you and vig you if the game continued. I had not even thought of it until Nacho brought it up.

[Looker]

U guys are just too smart for me

[CSL]

Nice one town. I was rooting for you ever since my lynch.

Unfortunately for the town, you lost a few, remember?

[CSL]

Mod, what were the roles of the other 3 that died?

[semioldguy]

But never by our own doing. Town kills were always by either cult or a murderer.

[Sajin]

We win with 11 town? Awesome. Almost disappointing though, I was looking for a good logic problem.

Although the nature of "going murderer" makes the game swingy, the fact that the 2 anti investigator factions annihilated each other was a huge help.


I want KoC's comments about my lets have a murderer joint with the town false theories. Heh I was trying to catch a murderer not reading the win conditions closely. Fail town for calling me out on it but the trap was sprung anyways. But I expected to catch dramonic or another 3rd party murder, not a cultist gone murderer.

Also, my night 1 action was actually a stalk on sarag. Which is why he heard noise. After nhammen pronounced Sarag innocent, I changed my next action. Sorry for juking your protection the next day pablo.

Which btw, changed the game for the investigators as had I been bloody I would not have had a res kit and I would of blown pablo's up and therefore Semi would of died etc and so forth.


@Percy- Protecting someone with a res kit, if previously not bloody was hard confirmable by others. No other action could make you bloody and not have you gain insanity. Was this an oversight, or intended? Just curious.

As a whole the strategy seemed to be to confirm a few people and then have those people cross confirm others and build out a "mason" group. Would of played out a lot differently had we a few more murderers or cultists not cross kill.

Awaiting mod notes!!!!! (and list of actions, and cultist QT)

@Semi- I cannot believe you still suspected me. You know I slow play information and always keep something for later. Just because I *claimed second*. Meh.

@Csl- Perfect games for town are games where town never miss lynches. Therefore this game was perfect. Town will usually have a few town deaths by mafia in any mafia game.




My night action would of been a forensics on Slysly. If he did ward me and no one else claimed responsibility for noise on me he would of been proven to me as he could not have laundered and warded.

[SlySly]

My night action would of been a forensics on Slysly. If he did ward me and no one else claimed responsibility for noise on me he would of been proven to me as he could not have laundered and warded.

I would have been stalking Data. I was sick of him being treated with kid gloves. No one seemed to want to lynch him for his unhelpful play and after Nacho mentioned that he should have already been vigged, I decided to take it into my own hands.

I wish I would have been in this game from the very beginning. It took a while for me to get a grip on a few things that would have been easier had I been a part of the game from the start.

[Chaco]

Replacing into this game was hard. Like I never felt like I could just hop in, so atleast my vote helped towards lynching cult.

Good job town, though!!

[Furpants_Tom]

Go team! Impressive guesswork all round; bad luck for the cult, especially on day 1. I don't have much to add, unfortunately; but I'm wondering if KoC is still around to explain his play?

[EriktheRed]

The sheer number of replacements on D1 seriously screwed over my knowledge of my cultbuddies. Plus, having Mastin and Zwet on our team did not help. I hadn't considered that half the scumteam would be policy vigged N1, and I had wanted to bus Zwet since he was such a liability.

[ryan2754]

The sheer number of replacements on D1 seriously screwed over my knowledge of my cultbuddies. Plus, having Mastin and Zwet on our team did not help. I hadn't considered that half the scumteam would be policy vigged N1, and I had wanted to bus Zwet since he was such a liability.

Not only that, but we were pretty damn lucky getting you as well.

[Nachomamma8]

Yay for us!

[Sajin]

I just want to point out that the cultists could of equiped res kits n0 and used them on their cult buddies to prevent them from being vigged n1. Not saying this was entirely practical, but possible.

[Sarag]

Sadly we were beset by many murderers, who managed to swing the game strongly in town's favour early on. That plus a lucky day 1 lynch meant we just had to play it out without messing up too much.

Sorry CSL, for pushing a bandwagon on you just after you replaced in. Not all that sorry for lynching scum though.

Good job Magua for sticking out a game that must have been hard going, especially after KoC's betrayal.

Kudos to nhammen and semioldguy for doing a lot of good detective work, Tom for breathing some life into an issue I was struggling with, and Sajin for setting a great murderer trap. I also thought SlySly came in pretty strong, he was a great replacement to have.

I think I managed to make up for my crappy day 1 play. I just had a lot of stuff going on at the start of the game that I wasn't expecting. I'm glad I was able to keep playing though. I enjoyed this game, although I realise now that I prefer smaller games. Thanks Percy, for running it.

[nhammen]

The sheer number of replacements on D1 seriously screwed over my knowledge of my cultbuddies. Plus, having Mastin and Zwet on our team did not help. I hadn't considered that half the scumteam would be policy vigged N1, and I had wanted to bus Zwet since he was such a liability.

Not only that, but we were pretty damn lucky getting you as well.

Hey! That wasn't luck! That was mee!! My first scum catch!

This was a good game. I caught my first two scum (DeathNote and EtR were my only major suspects this game). And I unfortunately misread my pm. However, after misreading my pm, some player (forget who) commented on my hearing noise, and I just assume he misread my noise list. It was probably a tell. Oh well, I think I did a good job for the most part.

[EriktheRed]

Yeah, Magua, great job. I probably would've given up in your situation. I saw your post in the quicktopic, something like, "HELLOOOO? Anybody here? *crickets*" and really felt bad for your (our) situation. I was really tempted to post something there, but didn't want to risk anything bad befalling us through mod-anger.

And you have no idea how annoyed I was that people preferred to lynch me over Zwet, haha.

Congratulations, nhammen. I hope one day to return the favor.

[dramonic]

See, I was a completely unecessary lynch ;_;
WEll, until later I guess XP

[nhammen]

Honestly, dramonic, you went Murderer too early. It is better to leave your options open. If you intended to go murderer, it would be best to stalk and murder one player as town, and then switch after stalking another. That way, if your kill was blocked, you could remain town for a little longer; keeping your options open that much longer. The way I read it, you can't murder a second player, but you could stalk a second.

[semioldguy]

That's the way I saw it, for me it would not have made sense to choose murderer as an insanity until after you successfully stalked the second person and having that person still be alive for you to murder them when that day after your stalking opens. Still murderer was an unattractive option in terms of maximizing chance of victory. The best chance a murderer would have of winning is if there were only two murderers (since you'd have to get rid of all murderers too).

@Sajin
I was pretty certain you were town. But if lynching Magua didn't end the game I didn't really know where else to look for cult, you were one of the few that in theory could have been with the available info (though your play strongly suggested to me that you wouldn't be cult). After Magua and Kise (and Datadanne) I really didn't know where else to look since I had fairly strong town feelings of most everyone else by one way or another.

[SlySly]

After Magua and Kise (and Datadanne) I really didn't know where else to look since I had fairly strong town feelings of most everyone else by one way or another.

Yep, after seeing the Kise insanity count correction by the mod, I was thinking datadanne was the only threat left and that he was a murderer. That was why I was going to go against the ward wishes and try to take care of the player that no one seemed to want to lynch!

Sorry about pushing for your lynch so hard yesterday. Magua's reaction to why you were cleared sure made it seem to me that you 2 were a scum team. At least, though it was for all the wrong reasons, I was right on one of those counts!!

Great game, Percy!! Lookin' forward to another one of your creations!

[Datadanne]

Your time was limited. I was going to stalk you and vig you if the game continued. I had not even thought of it until Nacho brought it up.

Lol, And then what?
Claim that you vigged me, Obv town data.

[SlySly]

Your time was limited. I was going to stalk you and vig you if the game continued. I had not even thought of it until Nacho brought it up.

Lol, And then what?
Claim that you vigged me, Obv town data.

Yep, I was going to make it clear that I had stalked you and let everyone know that you were going to be taken care of during the next night. I was willing to take whatever happened to me. Your anti-town play had been allowed for far too long.

[Sarag]

Data would have been the next lynch target I think. :p