Mafiascum.net

What do you think of peta's argument that I have produced no content? I think my reads are largely discernable.

Oh wow, opportunism from Chaos.

In post 2022, Dwlee99 wrote:I was making analogy to VCA. Sure, some of them are probably TvS but which ones and why? You made it seem like you think all of the pairings you named have at least one scum in them, not that one of the pairings has one scum which is meaningless because of how mathematically certain it is correct.

Look where my vote is, look what pairings I’ve made, and how I’m seeing the game. I think I’m not just saying oh there’s TvS arguments here, I have no idea where they are. I think if you just think for like a second, you’ll figure out where my suspicions are.

In post 2025, Titus wrote:What do you think of peta's argument that I have produced no content? I think my reads are largely discernable.

I don’t think that argument holds any water, no.

I just realized something. If I am correct on my theory, it makes town neighbors less likely. Permission to out my theory DotW?

In post 1980, petapan wrote:

In post 1978, Dwlee99 wrote:That's ridiculous.

shes scum dude

Like c’mon. This isn’t what you would typically expect from Partners. peta aggressively pushed Nero, and is doing the same here to Titus. DW you are aligning yourself hard with peta and to a lesser extent Anya, and pushing here. Are you going to argue all of you are Town? I find that really hard to believe.

Andresvmb are you getting the same response from dotw crumbs that I am and the logical deduction that follows? It is explains dotw and dgb early play. Just answer yes or no unless dotw approves otherwise.

In post 2030, Andresvmb wrote:

In post 1980, petapan wrote:

In post 1978, Dwlee99 wrote:That's ridiculous.

shes scum dude

Like c’mon. This isn’t what you would typically expect from Partners. peta aggressively pushed Nero, and is doing the same here to Titus. DW you are aligning yourself hard with peta and to a lesser extent Anya, and pushing here. Are you going to argue all of you are Town? I find that really hard to believe.

Please outline exactly which groupings you think have scum in them. I thought you were saying that you had pairings with scum in them, not groupings, which is why I thought they were bad.

I think that haha they’ve made themselves way obvious by saying they’re not a Cop but that mechanically they know what the other person’s alignment is. It’s almost too obvious. I hinted at it based on how you three were behaving previously.

In post 2033, Andresvmb wrote:I think that haha they’ve made themselves way obvious by saying they’re not a Cop but that mechanically they know what the other person’s alignment is. It’s almost too obvious. I hinted at it based on how you three were behaving previously.

If so, doesn't it follow that either anya or ssbm is scum?

A lot of my read of the situation with Anya and SSBM was the premise that I thought they were masons btw. If that's not the case then my "I trust Anya to read Kyo" comment kinda goes out the drain and I don't have much of an opinion on Kyo anymore.

In post 2032, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 2030, Andresvmb wrote:

In post 1980, petapan wrote:

In post 1978, Dwlee99 wrote:That's ridiculous.

shes scum dude

Like c’mon. This isn’t what you would typically expect from Partners. peta aggressively pushed Nero, and is doing the same here to Titus. DW you are aligning yourself hard with peta and to a lesser extent Anya, and pushing here. Are you going to argue all of you are Town? I find that really hard to believe.

Please outline exactly which groupings you think have scum in them. I thought you were saying that you had pairings with scum in them, not groupings, which is why I thought they were bad.

Maybe to clarify - when I placed two names in brackets like {here}, I’m saying I think one of the two is Scum, most likely not both. There’s always a chance that it’s TvT.

In post 2034, Titus wrote:

In post 2033, Andresvmb wrote:I think that haha they’ve made themselves way obvious by saying they’re not a Cop but that mechanically they know what the other person’s alignment is. It’s almost too obvious. I hinted at it based on how you three were behaving previously.

If so, doesn't it follow that either anya or ssbm is scum?

Probably Anya as Informed. It’s possible.

In post 2035, Dwlee99 wrote:A lot of my read of the situation with Anya and SSBM was the premise that I thought they were masons btw. If that's not the case then my "I trust Anya to read Kyo" comment kinda goes out the drain and I don't have much of an opinion on Kyo anymore.

Alright. Time out out the theory. DGB and DotW are masons.

They attacked the neighbor claim immediately because there's no way that masons plus all town neighbors exist.

Omg really? I wouldn't have guessed that based on the play. DotW should have went with me saying he was a cop ftr

In post 2040, Dwlee99 wrote:Omg really? I wouldn't have guessed that based on the play. DotW should have went with me saying he was a cop ftr

Look at his statements. He can confirm DGB as inno but not a cop inno.

Either I am voting anya or ssbm today.

In post 2041, Titus wrote:

In post 2040, Dwlee99 wrote:Omg really? I wouldn't have guessed that based on the play. DotW should have went with me saying he was a cop ftr

Look at his statements. He can confirm DGB as inno but not a cop inno.

It was sarcasm

In post 2043, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 2041, Titus wrote:

In post 2040, Dwlee99 wrote:Omg really? I wouldn't have guessed that based on the play. DotW should have went with me saying he was a cop ftr

Look at his statements. He can confirm DGB as inno but not a cop inno.

It was sarcasm

I'm bad at detecting sarcasm.

In post 2023, Andresvmb wrote:

In post 2020, petapan wrote:d1 read rate is one of the most overrated skills in mafia games

Funny enough, I agree. You know what isn’t though? Making yourself obvious Town. You most certainly haven’t achieved that here. And by trying to present so much strength behind some of your arguments, I think you come across worse.

dunno dude i'm not getting voted so i think i'm doing fine. am i persuasive? also no but i blew that with how i approached day 1 and most of the players here are up their own ass and not really willing to dialogue, the shenanigans with anya being run up for fairly lousy reasons and then being attacked have set me on edge because of pattern recognition

I was trying not to out that, but I didn't want town on the wrong path. Anya fmpov is most likely of the two to flip scum. Maybe they both are. I'm not buying the neighbors though.

In post 2030, Andresvmb wrote:

In post 1980, petapan wrote:

In post 1978, Dwlee99 wrote:That's ridiculous.

shes scum dude

Like c’mon. This isn’t what you would typically expect from Partners. peta aggressively pushed Nero, and is doing the same here to Titus. DW you are aligning yourself hard with peta and to a lesser extent Anya, and pushing here. Are you going to argue all of you are Town? I find that really hard to believe.

you are wack if you think scum interacts that way inthread

Peta, what do you think of masons and neighbors theory? You seem to be complaining I have no content while skipping over it.

In post 2046, Titus wrote:I was trying not to out that, but I didn't want town on the wrong path. Anya fmpov is most likely of the two to flip scum. Maybe they both are. I'm not buying the neighbors though.

Neither one is in danger, what is your concern about town being on the wrong path in reference to, and why does outing this help?