1542: Book of Shadows Vol. 1 ~ Game Over

[ProHawk]

[quote="In post 2048, Squirrel Girl"I feel like I'm slam dunking this right now, and that I should have an achievement award flare up with every post I'm making.[/quote]

What exactly are you slam dunking aside from confirming that Mastin is scum? Because we have about 36 hours to choose between me or MC.

[Kit]

Vote Count 5.07

With six alive it takes four to lynch.

Messiah Complex: ProHawk [1]
Scienceshrimp:
Mastin2: Squirrel Girl [1]
Squirrel Girl:
ProHawk: Messiah Complex, mastin2 [2]
Nero Cain:

Not voting: Nero Cain, scienceshrimp [2]

It is now Day 5 and it ends in (expired on 2014-03-22 09:26:00)

Notscience is vla.~

[Squirrel Girl]

Maybe a better question is what do you believe the setup is. Do you think there's 1 mafia and a third party left? Do you think its 2 mafia? 2 mafia and a third party? TBH, I don't really care but I think you are the most likely killer. I think Hanzo was a lil' liar about his actions. His claimed n1 action makes very very little sense from a town perspective.

I can't help you with Hanzo.

I tend to buy into your VT count theory, as such that leans ProHawk town and consequently MC scum, which suggests that scum are the ones with the Poisoner because otherwise his play doesn't make sense. In that setup, I would expect two scum. I don't think a 3rd party killer makes sense because then where are all the other poison kills? If it was a poisoning SK then I would expect more dead by whatever kill flavor poison is, but we aren't seeing that. At that point, the SK looks really weak, and SKs are not known for winning a lot of games even when pretty strong. So I don't think that makes sense.

So.......you didn't think I was dodging anything and you aren't scum reading me and yet you kept on making a dozen lil' posts about me not being around, what was the purpose of them then?

To be cute, and to try to pressure you to start being more active. I personally think it kind of worked. Would you be willing to vote Mastin? I think I showed that SK is unlikely, and though you are unable to describe your case on me for me to dismantle, you did indicate that you thought I was SK, and I think it's pretty clear that there is no SK. So...Mastin vote?

What exactly are you slam dunking aside from confirming that Mastin is scum? Because we have about 36 hours to choose between me or MC.

[mastin2]

Would you like to expand on those - since I don't think you have other than to say you think my role does exist but you don't think it's exactly a town role...which indicates you did believe the role could exist in this setup as long as it had a different alignment, which makes this commentary seem pretty wonky and false.

I'll try, but yes, I did believe the role could exist with a scum alignment and obviously with scum having flavor. Nothing I said says otherwise. I have zero doubts: regardless of your alignment, your claim is at least 90% true. As town it's obviously 100% true. As scum, the 10% not-true comes from the fakeclaim flavor and obviously switching some abilities for others. (E.g. cop-->rolecop.) I previously believed it was scum, that it didn't fit in very well as a town role, and that the flavor vaguely said it was also scum. Now, I'm thinking I was wrong about that, that it could be town and thus would fit. I don't see how that's hard to understand.

Read this explanation here, and then notice that mastin has been arguing about how the only way MC would do this as scum was if it was a scum winning manuver, and then recognize how this doesn't make sense if Mastin thinks MC is scum. I am so right about her!

Read my posts again:
I said that

from ProHawk's position

, the only possibility is that MC would do it as a winning scum-maneuver (or as town with ProHawk as scum, of course, but that requires him to be scum). The thought of scum-making-a-not-game-winning-maneuver would never occur to a town-him.
From

my

position, the only possibilities are that MC is town and has a guilty, or that MC is scum faking a guilty on his scumbuddy for the towncred. I've made this quite explicit. The reason I'm not voting MC is the possibility (albeit not probability) of the former scenario. In either case, ProHawk is scum.

ProHawk is scum for a multitude of reasons, too. There's the claim from MC. There's his play being a dead-ringer for Tales. There's also my preliminary analysis of the deceased which points that way. And then there's his scumslip. Any one of these by itself would be strong; together, they confirm him as scum, 100%. Like...MC's 90-95% likely to be scum. ProHawk is 100% scum.

[Squirrel Girl]

Explain the flavor bit some more. How did my flavor not work?

[Nero Cain]

vote:MC

[Nero Cain]

vote:MC

[ProHawk]

Did we really just miss the deadline again? Well at least that proves my theory that town is just giving up this game.

[ProHawk]

And that probably means SG's rant about missing the deadline last time was fake considering she didn't vote for anyone.

[scienceshrimp]

VOTE: MC

In case it does count

[Kit]

It's now night 5. You have no lynched.

Night ends in 48 hours.

[Kit]

(Prue drinks the cocktail while Phoebe fights Jackson. Jackson hits Phoebe over the head and is knocked unconscious. Prue collapses to the floor.)

Jackson: You're making this too easy, lady.

(He gets a metal cake server. Prue's spirit floats out of her body.)

What the hell's going on?

Prue: "Ashes to ashes, spirit to spirit, take his soul, banish this evil."

Jackson: No!

[Cut to the door.]

Andy: Prue, you home?

(He sees Phoebe lying on the floor.)

Prue: "Ashes to ashes, spirit to spirit, take his soul, banish this evil."

(Jackson starts fading away.)

Jackson: No! No!

(Andy goes in the kitchen.)

Andy: Prue!

(He starts giving her C.P.R.)

Prue: Andy, don't. Not yet.

Jackson: It's even better, I get to kill a cop too.

Prue: Andy, behind you.

(Andy looks behind him and grabs the cake server.)

"Ashes to ashes, spirit to spirit, take his soul, banish this evil."

(Jackson yells and disappears. The soul collector appears.)

Who are you?

Soul collector: I was hoping to take you or your sister. But it looks like you soul is safe. For now.



Squirrel Girl, Prue Halliwell,

Town Witch of all Trades

, was killed while trying to defeat a demon.*

*Technically in the show she survived, but let's just pretend, kay?

Vote Count 6.00

With Five alive it takes Three to lynch.

Messiah Complex:
Scienceshrimp:
Mastin2:
ProHawk:
Nero Cain:

Not voting: Nero Cain, scienceshrimp, ProHawk, Messiah Complex, mastin2 [5]

It is now Day 6 and it ends in (expired on 2014-04-07 16:16:00)

[ProHawk]

VOTE: MC

Let's not no - lynch three days in a row mKay?

[ProHawk]

Or not. Lets instead just let scum night-kill us to death. Good plan.

[ProHawk]

I miss you Squirrel Girl!

[Nero Cain]

I don't.

[ProHawk]

You have a heart of steel Nero.

[Nero Cain]

How'd you know I have a heart? You claimed VT not investigation role. You just scumslipped.

vote:Prohawk

[ProHawk]

Nero/MC? Why would you drag that day out like that?

[ProHawk]

If you are town, you should probably take that vote off me.

[ProHawk]

No seriously Nero, you were confirmed town by Serra/Smudger, get your freaking vote off me.

[Nero Cain]

Are you really OMGUSing me, bro? How did I drag yesterday out?

unvote

[ProHawk]

If you were scum, you would have dragged the day out by not lynching me.

[Nero Cain]

If you were scum, you would have dragged the day out by not lynching me.

Why would you drag that day out like that?

you accused me of dragging out the day, I asked you how.

[ProHawk]

By not lynching me when you had the chance. That is how you would have dragged the day out if you were scum. Did I mis-speak?