Mafiascum.net

In post 2308, Kazyan wrote:

Townread

:
Gork (PROTAGONIST OF THE GAME)
Dwlee99 (10-degree tilt for a minute there, literally no agenda, didn't do the scum tell)
Dann (I get good vibes from every post Dann makes; he seems like he's trying to bring order to a chaotic town. I know he's been burned by unwnd's scumgame in a chaotic normal before.)
The Worst (extremely town discussion with unwnd)

Townlean

:
unwnd (extremely town discussion with TW, but I'm generally spooked about the strength of unwnd's scumgame.)

Null

:
LLD (I'm, uh, done having opinions on this slot for a while)

Confu

sed

About

:
Pooky (Obviously not an SK anymore, and has completely dropped the indecision about who to kill. I have a hard time believing that his drunkposting spree could have been done with scum intent, but I need to ask whether this is typical of town!Pooky or not. I haven't seen him like this in his towngame yet, but I've seen him death-tunnel a claimed PR in Dogs Vs. Cats, in which he was mafia.)
House (I can't put my finger on what it is. I feel the towniness, but House has also just sorta been skirting every single discussion since the first few 24-hour days of the game, which I feel like is a good place for scum to hang out in. I also can't help but look at how he was on the only one on a non-viable wagon yesterday and think 'what's up with that'?)

Scumlean

:
MurderCat (This is where my heart wants to vote. I get what he's saying about Meg. I'm also kinda tinfoiling that the no-kill was specifically to kneecap MCat's ability to VCA if that's what he does every game, but I don't know. MCat, do you do VCA in most games?)
Gamma (PoE tbh)

Delet this

:
Meg (Meg has been diffident, wagon-hopping in a way that looks manufactured, and only broke out the actual convincing statements when directly pressured, i.e. saving themselves. The more I think about that "pick scum among these five at random" post, the more I think of it as throwing miselim options at the wall and seeing what sticks.)

-----

The trees I want to shake are the "Confused About" ones.

In post 2319, Dannflor wrote:probably the loudest and clearest thing that I remember happening D1 was gorkington pushing Kazyan

I think gorkington's pushes are always going to be given some credence because of the universality of the town reads on him. usually, that means high night kill bait. now he could just be so obvious that scum don't want to risk getting their kill blocked or what have you, but the other explanation is that they are mostly *fine* not killing gorkington because he's wrong on one or more major things. I think the most prolific take he had D1 was kazyan!scum and I think Kazyan is a slot that even if a lot of people town read them right *now*, could come back into question later.

In post 2325, MegAzumarill wrote:This doesn't feel genuine, at least the part about when I gave my POE post i gave yesterday.

In that post I gave 2 of the lowest other 3 slots on this list (and Navi/Kaz themself)The idea that I am scum and am trying to miseliminate town, but they also think who I am trying to mislim is scum?

It doesn't work logically for something they claim to spend a lot of time thinking about.


Rest of the readlist lines up mostly with my thoughts, ignoring both reads on me/gamma.

In post 2327, Dannflor wrote:dwlee just seems kinda lost. I don't have a good sense of where they want to go today or what they want to do. I'm hesitant to just mark that as towny though because this is a weird game state in general and I could see scum being a little frozen right now

In post 2324, Kazyan wrote:Does MurderCat/Gamma/Meg make sense as a solve? I'm trying to figure out if a Pooky or House swap-in makes more sense than a team that's constantly bussing each other apparently

In post 2327, Dannflor wrote:simplest

In post 2329, Gorkington wrote:tw just as an fyi reiterating this thing about me being uncooperative and thus a bad nightkill because im just negative utility for the game is making me feel like checking out. if thats your goal then feel free to keep at it and i guess you get what you wanted from scum last night.