Greatest Idea Mafia - Game Over

[NotMySpamAccount]

hey Micc thanks for modding a great game
let's just reroll again with this playerlist

/in

hehe /in I won't be as crappy this time I promise

[NotMySpamAccount]

People who are asking for a sequel, what are your thoughts on rolling and having players choose cards for 5 different setups. Use the most playable one as determined by game mod?

seems fine, though as others have said, 3 might be more manageable

[Elsa Jay]

Very much /in. And making 3 roles and being given 1 of them seems fair enough for balancing.

[Gamma Emerald]

Votecount 4.02

ofrhz (5) -

OkaPoka, brassherald, Vedith, TTTT, pinturicchio

Not Voting (4) -

Gamma Emerald, ofrhz, DoubtingThomas, Nimueh

With 9 players alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

A lynch has been achieved.

well this happened

[Gamma Emerald]

Also I said everything I needed to when I claimed. I think I made a genius play imo
Also as stated in my personal PT I realized a little bit after I did it that my "wait til day 3" thing was very akin to what Kokichi Oma does

[DoubtingThomas]

in

[Gamma Emerald]

People who are asking for a sequel, what are your thoughts on rolling and having players choose cards for 5 different setups. Use the most playable one as determined by game mod?

I think TheHolySpirit tried this to decent success, but with 3 instead of 5
personally I'd like to see an inventive way of doing Greatest Idea. Grand(est) Idea has so much you can do thanks to the large role list but with only 146 cards Greatest Idea has to be more conservative.

[Gamma Emerald]

That said, I wouldn't object to the 3 parallel draws idea. Maybe make the criteria more straightforward than a subjective "best", like choose the game with the closest-to-ideal faction balance without looking at roles.

Agreed. However if that's done and I play I'd definitely have a word at the start.

[Gamma Emerald]

My Private Thread, used for catch-ups and data crunching.

[TTTT]

I had crappy crads for the most part: tentacled townie and alpha goon, mason doc was the only decent one and had to be aligned with town. That made the choice easy. I also didn’t know your discards get outted.

Mason doc is a great role
you get the unlimited night action
you get a PT with another player
you can roleswap with the other mason(s)
just the fact that you can claim and have it backed up by another player is very strong
mason+ability is my dream role

[brassherald]

I have never been a mason. I would like to have more private threads in my life.

[Elsa Jay]

The one time I was a Mason I was also a Werewolf, so.... Yeah.

[Gamma Emerald]

I have a mason...twice I think? I've played so many games idk
But I know I've been one once

[pinturicchio]

I'll /in for formality as I already intended I wanted to play this again, and making some kind of restriction that makes the game more balanced would be pretty cool.

I'm calling this out again by the way: if I have the chance to be a third party, I'll pick that. I miss being a survivor

[davesaz]

I had a feeling 3p would be a good plan.
Right up to the point where I misremembered what had been claimed.
One of these days I'll actually write stuff down as it goes, instead of wishing I had.

[Elsa Jay]

Sorry I couldn't get you a win Dave. Frankly I did have scum motivation to kill you AND him at once, but I honestly did want You to win.

[Micc]

I'll put together a sequel but its going to be a few days cause i expect to be kinda busy this weekend.

[brassherald]

I'll put together a sequel but its going to be a few days cause i expect to be kinda busy this weekend.

How dare you! Tell anyone you were supposed to see this weekend that you have better things to do,!

[Vedith]

I'll put together a sequel but its going to be a few days cause i expect to be kinda busy this weekend.

Just cancel your plans I don't mind.

[Alchemist21]

/in too

[Nimueh]

I had crappy crads

for the most part

: tentacled townie and alpha goon, mason doc was the only decent one and had to be aligned with town. That made the choice easy. I also didn’t know your discards get outted.

Mason doc is a great role
you get the unlimited night action
you get a PT with another player
you can roleswap with the other mason(s)
just the fact that you can claim and have it backed up by another player is very strong
mason+ability is my dream role

I know, that was my point. It was the only decent card out of the 3.

[pinturicchio]

/in too

By the way Alch, well played. We succesfully recognized each other as town, yay for us!

[Alchemist21]

:fistbump:

[Micc]

Alright I /in'd to the queue. Will be doing the three setups thing and choosing the one with the best faction balance.

Spoiler: Pre-ins

TTTT
Allomancer
Vedith
ofrhz
brassherald
davesaz
NotMySpamAccount
Elsa Jay
DoubtingThomas
pinturicchio
Alchemist21

If I missed your pre-in or if you want to pre-in just let me know.