Mafiascum.net

In post 2327, Dannflor wrote:I will state that it's weird Gamma started feeling better or less uneasy today about me because I feel my posts have been particularly contentless today

I disagree with this statement.

You've thrown out some decent probative questions prior to that post, and your analysis shows depth.

In post 2424, MURDERCAT wrote:no lol that's dumb

why is it dumb lol

do u think the scum r just going to let our claimed doc and claimed parity cop live to fuck with us?

In post 2421, Dannflor wrote:fuck it ill sheep my homie pooky after every1 else checks in

we just need unwnd to complete the loop

Flipping Kaz proves nothing if he flips green. If he flips red, then cool. Gamma is real and I eat crow. However, if he flips green then Gamma can just go 'see I told you it's unwnd!' but like the same circumstance can happen if you were to eliminate me. It's just a shoddy claim and I kind of(?) get why Dwlee wanted to eliminate outside but yes it is quite useless in the scheme of things.

In post 2426, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 2424, MURDERCAT wrote:no lol that's dumb

why is it dumb lol

do u think the scum r just going to let our claimed doc and claimed parity cop live to fuck with us?

Because if you think Gamma is town then you should lim within the 50% scum group.
If you think there's a good chance gamma could be scum then he claimed to buy time and hopefully 2:1, in which case you don't give him more time by limming elsewhere.

What do you do tomorrow when Gamma says "I was RB'd"?
What do you do tomorrow when Gamma gives a result?

At some point we have to lim Gamma or his targets so what do we gain with delaying it?

In post 2428, unwnd wrote:Flipping Kaz proves nothing if he flips green. If he flips red, then cool. Gamma is real and I eat crow. However, if he flips green then Gamma can just go 'see I told you it's unwnd!' but like the same circumstance can happen if you were to eliminate me. It's just a shoddy claim and I kind of(?) get why Dwlee wanted to eliminate outside but yes it is quite useless in the scheme of things.

lmfaooooooo
Weren’t you just howling about how powerful my role was?
Eat rope, scum.

what if scum dont have a roleblocker and they need to kill gamma to avoid giving us more results

like ur just assuming the scum team has a counter for parity cop

at the same time you're assuming gamma isn't even a parity cop

like lol

In post 2400, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:i wanna hear from everyone else if they believe this gamma claim and how they want to proceed

its day 2, 12 alive

calm your ass down we're not on the verge of getting reamed

I don't buy the claim.

I see why town would lie about it.

can you explain why you don't buy the claim

VOTE: Gamma (E-1, I think)

I know TSQ doesn't do the "conventional game balance" thing but I'm pretty sure he knows about Follow the Cop.

In post 2428, unwnd wrote:Flipping Kaz proves nothing if he flips green. If he flips red, then cool. Gamma is real and I eat crow. However, if he flips green then Gamma can just go 'see I told you it's unwnd!' but like the same circumstance can happen if you were to eliminate me. It's just a shoddy claim and I kind of(?) get why Dwlee wanted to eliminate outside but yes it is quite useless in the scheme of things.

Agreed

Shea put in a follow the cop in the last game I played under him. Do you not remember dogs v cats?

I stopped paying attention after I was N1'd

I'm not sure what the solution is here?

And technically it was just a dog cop and dog doctor (and a second dog cop) so cats/rats could kill the dog cop but dogs were completely unable to stop a dog cop for 2 nights and only because the dog doctor claimed for ??? reasons

yea not only did cats v dogs have cops/doctors

the scum team didnt have a roleblocker

shea is pretty old school

Oh wait I do remember this

I get why you want to keep us 3 off the table but that seems inevitable.

Anyway idk I think the claim doesn't make sense given the way gamma has played this phase I just don't want to kill an investigative that could give us a ton of info potentially.

I don't feel good about flipping Kaz.

I don't know.

I'd like to request being parity'd against someone if we let gamma live the day. The worst should be on him as well

I think this is just a sacrifice to break up the townblock.

I mean why even kill any of Kaz/Unwnd/Gamma ?

If there's no mafia roleblocker the mafia have to take care of Gamma for us no?

In post 2431, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:what if scum dont have a roleblocker and they need to kill gamma to avoid giving us more results

Then you have to assume TW is lying right? I give Shea enough credit that I think that if there is a parity cop and a doc in the game scum has some counter.

It's also just math though. Assuming 1/3 of the trio are scum we have a 33% chance to hit scum inside the trio. If we go outside that group given the same assumption then it's 2/9 = 22% chance.

you're making balance assumptions that don't have to be true