Mafiascum.net

↑ VP Baltar wrote:

↑ Debonair Danny DiPietro wrote:

↑ VP Baltar wrote:Yo Rest. Get wit this new awesome alliance of DDD and me and start voting for Peregrine

Why Rest of all people? And I'm not sure we agree on anyone other than PV but at least we've got that awesome-sauce wagon going for us.

I´m feeling town on Rest since she is

too new

to be scum organizing how she is playing. I submit her calling her suspects her top ¨scumtells¨ as support for my position on this.

>joined July 27, 2008
>calling her a newb

Yeah ok have fun with that

↑ PeregrineV wrote:

↑ PeregrineV wrote:

↑ tigerzone wrote:as of right now the only people i'll be happy to lynch today are empking and iecerint.

Only saves on my list are Ice, Levi and Jason.

Meh. Add Rest to that.

Vote: SaintKerrigan

This post is shit

Also explain your townreads and your vote

↑ FourTrouble wrote:

↑ Nachomamma8 wrote:The trying to jump on HD for a scumslip is also weird considering yes, that's what Iec said, and the fact that she just went "oops i made a mistake" instead of looking back through Iec's posts to see that he originally called Rest "scum if levi is town" is also sort of strange.

I'm not following you here. To me, looking for slips like that seems like the kind of scumhunting that comes from a town mindset more than a scum one and besides, RF is obviously not making that the center point of her vote to begin with.

Scumslip-hunting is something scum tend to do; they tend to jump on awkward wording (common from me) as scumslips when they're really not. (I made like 5 or so in M1402 and I got jumped on for it every time)

UNVOTE:
VOTE: PeregrineV

RestFermata wagon is really really sexy

But PeregrineV wagon is even sexier

Like seriously I don't think I've seen anything from him that looks even remotely like it comes from town

↑ VP Baltar wrote:And it is possible we don´t agree on anyone else, but I do know you´ll at least help me lynch PV by his scumpants, so I´m cool with that regardless of your alignment. Tigerzone should get on this lynch too. And SK, this is your chance to redeem yourself.

Agreed, time for fighting your wrong headedness on other people is later, time for lynching PV-scum is now.

↑ Human Destroyer wrote:>joined July 27, 2008
>calling her a newb

Yeah ok have fun with that

join date means nothing in terms of mafia competency. She joined before me and I´ve never seen her before even though I´ve played a mafia game or two in my day.

↑ leviathan93 wrote:whats this vote for? seems out of the blue and just trying to start another wagon. =/

Don't like the other wagons, and contribution-wise, a very good vote.

↑ VP Baltar wrote:fing l

gzade R

↑ Human Destroyer wrote:This post is shit

Why?

↑ Human Destroyer wrote:
Also explain your townreads and your vote

Jason- town meta so far
Iec- just finished modding him as town, this is Iec town
Levi, Rest- posting is town mindset

↑ Human Destroyer wrote:RestFermata wagon is really really sexy

But PeregrineV wagon is even sexier

Like seriously I don't think I've seen anything from him that looks even remotely like it comes from town

That's cool. Who are your townreads?

↑ Debonair Danny DiPietro wrote:

↑ VP Baltar wrote:And it is possible we don´t agree on anyone else, but I do know you´ll at least help me lynch PV by his scumpants, so I´m cool with that regardless of your alignment. Tigerzone should get on this lynch too. And SK, this is your chance to redeem yourself.

Agreed, time for fighting your wrong headedness on other people is later, time for lynching PV-scum is now.

If you elaborate on why I'm scum, it'll really help you be accountable later.

↑ Empking wrote:

Vote; Iece

whats this vote for?

you have very few posts. 6 to be exact. and none of them have anything really of content to help scum hunt. whats the deal? to me you are looking like a huge lurker, and lurkers are very often scummy. explain yourself and your scum and town reads.

↑ leviathan93 wrote:

↑ Empking wrote:

Vote; Iece

whats this vote for?

you have very few posts. 6 to be exact. and none of them have anything really of content to help scum hunt. whats the deal? to me you are looking like a huge lurker, and lurkers are very often scummy. explain yourself and your scum and town reads.

I voted iece because i found his super 180 on you, and his mea culpa of the same is very scummy, as he'd gone from voting you to basing his entire world-view on you being town in a very unnatural way.

↑ PeregrineV wrote:

↑ Human Destroyer wrote:RestFermata wagon is really really sexy

But PeregrineV wagon is even sexier

Like seriously I don't think I've seen anything from him that looks even remotely like it comes from town

That's cool. Who are your townreads?

FourTrouble, Iecerint, VP Baltar, leviathan, tigerzone

PeregrineV wrote:

↑ Human Destroyer wrote:This post is shit

Why?

Deflecting attention on RestFermata to SaintKerrigan, reasonless vote, adding another unexplained townread to your town pile

VP Baltar wrote:

↑ Human Destroyer wrote:>joined July 27, 2008
>calling her a newb

Yeah ok have fun with that

join date means nothing in terms of mafia competency. She joined before me and I´ve never seen her before even though I´ve played a mafia game or two in my day.

Hmmm...alright.

PeregrineV wrote:

↑ Human Destroyer wrote:
Also explain your townreads and your vote

Jason- town meta so far
Iec- just finished modding him as town, this is Iec town
Levi, Rest- posting is town mindset

Let's see, out of all of these:

1 is a (possibly) valid meta case
2 is a flawed meta case (1 game is too small a sample size)
3 and 4 are cop outs

Try harder

Iecerint and Pv for scum team 2013. Calling that shit now.

↑ Empking wrote:I voted iece because i found his super 180 on you, and his mea culpa of the same is very scummy, as he'd gone from voting you to basing his entire world-view on you being town in a very unnatural way.

Levi is pretty town IMO. In fact, I think it's the one thing I'm most sure about in this game.

Levi's posting style is breezy and naive at the same time. That basically always means that the player is town.

In his early post, I didn't get the breeziness at all and I instead got TRYHARD from it, but his subsequent posting made it clear that he was town.

I do not think the change was fabricated because I do not think his level of analysis is consistent with that kind of move.

↑ Iecerint wrote:

I do not think the change was fabricated because I do not think his level of analysis is consistent with that kind of move.

How so? And what is his level of analysis?

Dunno what the mea culpa is, though. I did have one of those with FourTrouble.

I am still OK with my RestFermata vote for now. I'm not really getting a change in my POV as she continues to post. Some other players seem to think her posting-style has made her town, though, so maybe I require schooling.

SaintKerrigan is the main place I am entertaining switching to.

↑ Empking wrote:

↑ Iecerint wrote:

I do not think the change was fabricated because I do not think his level of analysis is consistent with that kind of move.

How so? And what is his level of analysis?

Self-consciously changing the tone of your posts is Machiavellian. I think Levi's meta (from what others have said) and posting in-game are not consistent with that type of play.

HD what's your read on me?

Some quick thoughts before I head out. PV seems to be voting SK for the same reason that everyone is voting PV, which is sort of amusing to me. I could easily see both of HD and PV being scum and the whole confrontation that's going on being a bus. I don't know how to explain it, but I just played a scum game, so the science of bussing is fresh on my mind right now. It doesn't seem genuine. When I get back I'll analyze it further and try to figure out why my subconscious is raising red flags here.

↑ Nachomamma8 wrote:HD what's your read on me?

Haven't really been paying enough attention to you, I'll take a closer look at you later

↑ Nachomamma8 wrote:-snip-

wow this is a bunch of reasons for you to vote me instead of chilling on an easy lynch
so, um.
why are you chilling on an easy lynch?
and why haven't you commented on the DDD awesomewagon?

Town

↑ Nachomamma8 wrote:-snip-
I sort of like this. She's maintaining throwing around her weight even when she's under pressure, and although she doesn't like the wagon, she's not using it as leverage to attack an easier person to lynch and staying with her old scumread of me as opposed to hopping on one of the easier choices, but then there's the hop onto HD that completely fucks that one up. Hmm.

-snip-

Town

↑ Nachomamma8 wrote:Wall of hard-to-readness but that's townish

Town

Okay Nacho you're town

EBWOP: Replace "wall of hard-to-readness" with "disorganized wall"